Steam Hardware & Software Survey: July 2014

Considering that most workloads are integer it's actually a pretty clever compromise that helps with TDP. AMD's 16-core Opteron 6376 at 32nm is 115W TDP while Intel 12-core Xeon E5-2697v2 at 22nm is 140W. I had 80W Xeons that ran hot so I can't imagine 140W with Intel's signature tiny surface area for dissipating heat to heat sink. You're also talking $2500 for Intel and $700 for AMD.

HW-E brings on higher tdp... and 50% more cores... :D
I just wish games wouldn't flat out break due to too many cores.
pita... I have to set affinity just to launch some games.
 
HW-E brings on higher tdp... and 50% more cores... :D
I just wish games wouldn't flat out break due to too many cores.
pita... I have to set affinity just to launch some games.

LOL.

Almost as bad as WFeather using an SR-2 for an NAS. :D
 
AMD cheats because their cores aren't really full cores in that they don't have FPUs for each core. Rather, they share FPUs between two cores so if you have an 8 core AMD processor, it really only has 4 cores worth of floating-point capability.

The shared 256-bit FPU can be split into two 128-bit FPUs, so the "real cores" things is very debatable. Sandy Bridge combines a 128-bit SIMD and 128-bit FPU for 256-bit instructions, and you don't hear anyone complaining that it doesn't have "real cores".
 
Zarathustra[H];1041007904 said:
Two things.

1.) He is using a Phenom II Thuban core, so he actually has 6 integer cores AND 6 fpu's.

2.) The comparison of the bullozer two core module to HT is a bit flawed. The oversimplified description of HT is that it has two sets of decodes per core, presented as logical cores to make more efficient use of a single core and fpu.

AMD on the other hand has two of everything per module, except the FPU, where one 256bit FPU is shares for the module. The FPU is also splittable into two 128bit FPU's so when operating in that mode it's like each core has its own FPU.

AS far as scaling goes, the VMWare guide is that HT scales at about 30% of adding a real core on single socket systems and about 15% of adding a real core on dual-socket systems. (Not sure why it goes down as you add sockets).

AMD's Bulldozer/Piledriver cores - on the other hand - scale almost indistinguishably from traditional non-shares cores.

The reason AMD's chips are slower is primarily due to worse performance of each individual core, not because of module resource sharing.

Again, this is based on virtualized server workloads, as games and desktop applications are usually a poor benchmark for how well a system scales with added cores (except Cinebench, which is actually pretty good at testing this)

It wasn't meant as a criticism, I was simply pointing out that they aren't full cores in the traditonal sense. AMD's new CPUs are great for servers; I have two rackmounts with 2x 8 "Module" AMD Opterons (16 modules each) and they are great for virtualization.

However :
1.Games are FPU heavy and not particularly multithreaded. AMD's extra "modules" won't help. The comment I replied to was about the Steam benchmark.

2.In order to fully benefit, you need an operating system that knows how to take advantage of the new layout (e.g. by not putting two FP-heavy threads on the same shared FPU) and that means that you either have to be using Windows 8, GNU/Linux, or one of the BSDs.

3.Regardless of the fact that the FPU can be split into two 128-bit operations, it is still shared and therefore a module is not the same as a core. A lot of newer applications are using 256-bit operations to speed up performance on vector operations (e.g. AVX) and so you won't always be able to split it up.
 
The shared 256-bit FPU can be split into two 128-bit FPUs, so the "real cores" things is very debatable. Sandy Bridge combines a 128-bit SIMD and 128-bit FPU for 256-bit instructions, and you don't hear anyone complaining that it doesn't have "real cores".

Basically this. It's the individual core's performance that hurts AMD in gaming performance, not the way the multi-core architecture is done.
 
1.Games are FPU heavy and not particularly multithreaded. AMD's extra "modules" won't help. The comment I replied to was about the Steam benchmark.

Fiar point, but on the other hand games are rarely CPU dependent these days. When was the last time you played a title that couldn't push 60fps (given sufficient graphics hardware) on even the cheapest curent core i3?

It has long been my opinion that if ones goals are truly gaming, many of the CPU choices on this forum are rather overkill, so it is silly to put down the fact that others are gaming just fine on lesser CPU's.

2.In order to fully benefit, you need an operating system that knows how to take advantage of the new layout (e.g. by not putting two FP-heavy threads on the same shared FPU) and that means that you either have to be using Windows 8, GNU/Linux, or one of the BSDs.

Agreed, and to further clarify, pretty much any OS running as a guest on ESXi will benefit as well (at least as I read the tech docs), as ESXi is architecture aware, and schedules guest processes to optimize use.

3.Regardless of the fact that the FPU can be split into two 128-bit operations, it is still shared and therefore a module is not the same as a core. A lot of newer applications are using 256-bit operations to speed up performance on vector operations (e.g. AVX) and so you won't always be able to split it up.

True, but as has been mentioned elsewhere in this thread, Intels approach also combines CPU portions to achieve 256bit opetrations through its 128bit SIMD and 128bit FPU.
 
I wonder just how accurate that survey is of the actual users profiles. Less than 1% of Intel CPU's above 3.7Ghz? Must not have been many [H]'ers in that sample
 
I wonder just how accurate that survey is of the actual users profiles. Less than 1% of Intel CPU's above 3.7Ghz? Must not have been many [H]'ers in that sample

well... I am not above 3.7ghz... but I have 16c/32t :rolleyes:
 
well... I am not above 3.7ghz... but I have 16c/32t :rolleyes:

Yeah the point remains the same, the gpu profiles are equalling baffling. Outside of the other category only about 5% of users have more than 2GB of video card ram. Can't be
 
Considering that most workloads are integer it's actually a pretty clever compromise that helps with TDP.
It's so clever that method shrank AMD's x86 server market share possibly below 4% by now (it was under 4.5% last year, and server chip revenue was sharply down QoQ and YoY last quarter). :D AMD doesn't even talk about its "big core" x86 server chips anymore, just the Kabini-based crap (Kyoto).
 
It's so clever that method shrank AMD's x86 server market share possibly below 4% by now (it was under 4.5% last year, and server chip revenue was sharply down QoQ and YoY last quarter). :D AMD doesn't even talk about its "big core" x86 server chips anymore, just the Kabini-based crap (Kyoto).

Well AMD walked away from the highend because they simply cannot compete on anything other than price... Kyoto on the other hand puts the hurt on atom crap.

In the micro server realm of seamicro and HP's Moonshot. AMD also has the upcoming Seattle cpus which are actually quite spiffy.

I wonder what percentage of steam users actually took the survey.
 
Exactly what I thought. Funny those two think that all PC gamers will spend $1k - $3k on multi-head multi-card display setups for slight noticeable visual improvements.

May make their mind explode that I use 1 24" TN panel by choice, not because of financial restrictions.

The [H] is really a place with very high standard concerning gaming. Coming from a place where a low-end GPU is something to brag about, it's funny to see how some people here have really high requirements of CPU/GPU specs for games that run reasonably well on machines a lot cheaper.

I guess that's the nature of the beast. If it wasn't like this, I wouldn't be [H] for crying out loud.

Still, the folks on the General Hardware forum are able to help with down-to-earth information when one wants to build a gaming-capable rig on a tiny budget. I was there, and the machine they put up was the best bang-for-the-buck I've ever had.
 
The [H] is really a place with very high standard concerning gaming. Coming from a place where a low-end GPU is something to brag about, it's funny to see how some people here have really high requirements of CPU/GPU specs for games that run reasonably well on machines a lot cheaper.

Yeah, I'd say its more than just for gaming, or everyone on here would just be on low end core i3's and Geforce 750's unless they were using g high resolution monitors, as that's all it takes for 60fps at 1080 at decent quality settings these days in most titles.

We're obviously in it for more than just gaming, even in the cases where nothing we do actually needs the performance we are buying.
 
Back
Top