SSD questions relating to a Dell E1505

Sgraffite

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jan 10, 2006
Messages
4,405
I have a Dell E1505 which currently has a 40GB, 4200 RPM drive in it. I was looking into replacing it with an SSD and came across some questions that I didn't find clear answers to.

First, Dell never gave the E1505 ACHI support in the bios, even though the chipset supports it. That means I can't use NCQ, which affects performance. It does use a SATA interface for the drive, I think I got lucky with that as laptops with IDE would probably be SOL for using an SSD. Does lack of AHCI affect anything else though?

Second, I currently am running Windows XP. Does this mean there is no TRIM support? Do drives such as the Sandforce rely on the OS for TRIM or is it handled by the drive itself?

It seems worst case I'd need to upgrade to Windows 7, and I'd lose out on NCQ. Overall I still think there would be a significant speed increase over the current 4200 RPM drive. The extra space would be nice too as currently I probably couldn't fit Windows 7 and Visual Studio 2010 on the 40GB.

Is there anything else I'm not considering here?
 
You wont get trim (win 7 only) but some drives support garbage collection, when the drive is idle it will clean itself up, sandforce generally does do garbage collection (although I don't know if all sandforce drives do, some manufacturers might disable it in the firmware). Ssd's can run in ide or ahci mode so one should still work in the laptop the difference isnt that big and the benefits of ssd vs hdd are huge. The speed will be considerably faster loading windows and applications.
 
Back
Top