Spending 1500 on a new pc. Help

blade12

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 29, 2005
Messages
346
Hi, a friend of mine is spending $1500 on a computer and want to know what is the best thing to buy for that budget. He is willing to spend up to $1800 MAXIMUM with shipping included but if its around 1500 bucks, that's better.
He created the following wishlist and needs to know what improvements he should make:
http://secure.newegg.com/NewVersion/wishlist/PublicWishDetail.asp?WishListNumber=3828928

I haven't been keeping track of new hardware lately so I am pretty much a newb right now and very little help to him. I told him to get a 7900 or X1900 XTX which will give better performance than 2 7600 videocards that he picked. He says he really wants SLI but I dunno if that would be a good choice with his budget. I am not sure what else should be changed. Thanks people.
 
1. Core 2 Duo instead of AM2
2. Different power supply, I don't trust Thermaltake
3. Single 7900 GT instead of 7600 GT SLI (you're right)
4. 7200.10, WD Caviar SE 16, or Samsung drive instead of the 7200.9
5. Scythe Ninja or Thermalright Ultra-120 instead of the CNPS-9500 (only thing the 9500 has over the other two is looks)

Sorry, I don't have time to go into much detail right now.
 
Backslash said:
1. Core 2 Duo instead of AM2
2. Different power supply, I don't trust Thermaltake
3. Single 7900 GT instead of 7600 GT SLI (you're right)
4. 7200.10, WD Caviar SE 16, or Samsung drive instead of the 7200.9
5. Scythe Ninja or Thermalright Ultra-120 instead of the CNPS-9500 (only thing the 9500 has over the other two is looks)

Sorry, I don't have time to go into much detail right now.

1) He doesn't want to go to intel side for some reason.
2) Which powersupply would be a better choice?
3) Ok.
4) He wants to sata 3gb and wants to run his drives in raid 0. Those are better choices?
5) Which one is better from those 2?
 
blade12 said:
1) He doesn't want to go to intel side for some reason.

Tell him that if building a pc now from scratch, not going to core 2 duo is just chucking performance increases out of the window for nothing. .
 
blade12 said:
1) He doesn't want to go to intel side for some reason.
2) Which powersupply would be a better choice?
3) Ok.
4) He wants to sata 3gb and wants to run his drives in raid 0. Those are better choices?
5) Which one is better from those 2?

1) Force him to, tell him to look at the latest benchmarks if he still won't
2) SilverStone 750w
4) Yes
5) I think the Ninja is better, assuming it will fit inside his case


I think it would be a good idea to get a case with 120mm fans instead of 80mm (1 120mm fan will pump out as much air as 2 80mm while being quiter), Cooler master stacker and the antec 180 are good choices.


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820231065
Better ram than what he has listed.
 
2) Ridiculous. A 750W PSU for a $1500 build?
4) RAID 0 is pointless for a home rig.
5) The Ultra-120 is better than the Ninja at non-silent fan speeds.
 
Raid 0 is required because he is also a graphics designer. Raid-0 is wanted for that reason. So anyways, what changes do you guys recommend for each part on his wishlist? If someone has the time for that, it would be great.

http://secure.newegg.com/NewVersion/wishlist/PublicWishDetail.asp?WishListNumber=3828928
That's the wish list btw again. I was thinking that maybe Antec P180 is a better case to buy than the Lian-li one chosen. Its looks much bigger and has more 180mm fans.
 
blade12 said:
Raid 0 is required because he is also a graphics designer. Raid-0 is wanted for that reason. So anyways, what changes do you guys recommend for each part on his wishlist? If someone has the time for that, it would be great.

What does being a graphic designer have to do with needing raid-0?

I'd change:

the heat sink fan hes got on there to the Scythe Ninja.
the case to the Antec 180
get a damn intel conroe instead of am2 (the $200 conroe is as fast or faster than a $500-$1000 amd)
If you're going to go with a 650w PSU, you might want to check out this one too http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817139002

They're both exceptional PSUs from what I've heard though. (http://www.jonnyguru.com/PSU/HX620W/index2.htm)
 
He better be a gamer too if he wants a 7900. Please dont tell me hes a graphic designer demanding a 7900 :p

that psu is pretty damn lol for a $1500 system. You can get a much cheaper antec or something thatll do nicely, and shunt the difference into a core 2 processor and motherboard. Refusing to go core 2 right now is sheer stupidity.

Raid 0 on the desktop is also meaningless to most users (its one of those things people continue to push and push for no real reason)
http://www.anandtech.com/printarticle.aspx?i=2101
http://faq.storagereview.com/tiki-index.php?page=SingleDriveVsRaid0

also, you can get a floppy/multi flash reader for just a bit more than just a floppy by itself, and they are very worthwhile.
 
No doubt! Right now, it would be extremely silly not to buy a Core2Duo.

I've been an AMD fan for years...but that doesnt matter. Facts are facts. The Core2's slam the Athlons right now.

Its also pointless to get 2ea 7600's just to "want" SLI. The 7900GT is a much smarter choice.

Im a graphic designer as well. RAID 0 is not necessary. Even for the largest photoshop files (some of my posters reach well over 300Mb with a scratch disk that grows over a gig)
 
Back
Top