Sound Card vs Intergrated Sound Chip?

Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
7
I plan on buying a Sound Card eventually to replace the Realtek HDA provided onboard, but I was curious as to why I should.

From my understanding, Sound Cards have their own chip to process audio, whereas intergrated Sound Chips have to use the CPU. But in Windows Vista and 7, I thought that all sound was done on a software level anyway, and not hardware?

Also I heard that Sound Cards sound worlds better then sound chips, however, is this true? Would I notice a difference at all when playing back audio on a 2.0 large speaker system?
 
You're thinking of EAX and hardware acceleration. The reason a sound card sounds better than onboard audio is because its DAC (digital to analog converter) is better (higher signal-to-noise ratio) and thus produces a cleaner reproduction of the source. Onboard audio has come a long way and to many people it is "adequate." To those that enjoy music or high-end gaming, it is still not adequate and so if you spend money on audio gear you should also be upgrading your source.

The better your sound system, the more the requirement for a good source (DAC/amp). So yes, it will still sound a lot better if you are using powered speakers or headphones.

When it comes to computer games, in the past there was rampant support for hardware-accelerated audio effects that required a Creative Labs soundcard to get the best sound from games. Now game developers have dropped that and do all the game audio in the game engine itself and all the processing is done on the CPU instead of off-loaded to another processor on a soundcard.

Long story short: soundcards are not required for computer games for straight up hardware acceleration and FPS, but still make music and games sound better in other ways. For example, if using headphones, you'll want a soundcard that supports either Dolby Headphone or CMSS3D which are basically algorithms that take a 7.1 audio source outputted from a computer game and downmix it into a virtual surround sound for your headphones, so that you can hear people around you better.
 
Modern integrated audio is quite good. What speakers/headphones are you using?
 
I can only tell you my experience. The leap from onboard sound to outboard sound with an M-Audio sound card was extraordinary. I have great hearing, and consider myself an audiophile, but the difference was monumental.
 
i'll just copy what i said from a previous thread...


if your speakers/cans have bad shielding, you wont notice much between onboard and dedicated sound.

If they DO have nice speakers/headphones, you'll notice a noise level difference. The traces on the motherboard will introduce some EMI noise into your onboard audio at high volume levels - very slight hiss.

Having a soundcard puts your audio traces further away from the motherboard traces which helps to eliminate some noise from EMI.

However, if you have cold cathodes in your case, you're going to get hissing in your audio no matter what. Cold cathodes have pretty big EMI fields around them, and thus introduce noise into your sound.

The big concern really with soundcards is the drivers. My auzentech has some terribly slow and glitchy drivers, and i've heard most products with Creative chips in them are the same. But the upside to it is that i can switch the opamps (the amplifiers) and give it my own custom frequency flavor, which is a huge plus for tweakers like me :)
 
I think you'll notice a difference in sound quality if you upgrade your surge protector to one that filters noise. You'll get more of a clean sound without having to purchase a sound card... that being said, a sound card is still the way to go.
 
You're thinking of EAX and hardware acceleration. The reason a sound card sounds better than onboard audio is because its DAC (digital to analog converter) is better (higher signal-to-noise ratio) and thus produces a cleaner reproduction of the source. Onboard audio has come a long way and to many people it is "adequate." To those that enjoy music or high-end gaming, it is still not adequate and so if you spend money on audio gear you should also be upgrading your source.

The better your sound system, the more the requirement for a good source (DAC/amp). So yes, it will still sound a lot better if you are using powered speakers or headphones.

When it comes to computer games, in the past there was rampant support for hardware-accelerated audio effects that required a Creative Labs soundcard to get the best sound from games. Now game developers have dropped that and do all the game audio in the game engine itself and all the processing is done on the CPU instead of off-loaded to another processor on a soundcard.

Long story short: soundcards are not required for computer games for straight up hardware acceleration and FPS, but still make music and games sound better in other ways. For example, if using headphones, you'll want a soundcard that supports either Dolby Headphone or CMSS3D which are basically algorithms that take a 7.1 audio source outputted from a computer game and downmix it into a virtual surround sound for your headphones, so that you can hear people around you better.

Valaire is right and wrong.

OpenAL which is fully supported by Vista/7 is fully hardware accelerated by all X-Fi cards.

The virtual surround effects CMSS-3d and dolby headphone have marginal to good effects on most games.

DACs do play an enormous role in Audio quality and any soundcard is a huge improvement over the DACs provided on motherboards.

If you game more it really comes down to the games you play. For example the Dirt series has good hardware audio support. Dirt1 does EAX, Dirt2 fully supports OpenAL, and I haven't played dirt3 yet :-P.

If music is more your focus then the lower end Xonar cards are better as they are cheap and come with good DACs no matter the model basically.

If you game a lot and you listen to music a lot you're going to want the X-Fi HD as it gives you the best of both worlds.
 
I have no idea but dirt2 is a fairly recent game to support it. I don't know the pros or cons to developing a game with it. But I haven't heard anything outstanding that makes implementing it in a game difficult.
 
Now that I have a sound card, I will never ever go back to onboard again. Its just such a difference. You hear so much more and clearer. Even youtube sounds better.
 
Would I also notice a difference if I were to, hook my 5.1 sound system up and use optical instead of the normal wires? I imagine it would, but would the difference between normal wires and optical be noticeable enough?
 
Would I also notice a difference if I were to, hook my 5.1 sound system up and use optical instead of the normal wires? I imagine it would, but would the difference between normal wires and optical be noticeable enough?

If you use 3 3.5mm to RCA Y-cables for 5.1 you wouldn't need DDL.
 
Would I also notice a difference if I were to, hook my 5.1 sound system up and use optical instead of the normal wires? I imagine it would, but would the difference between normal wires and optical be noticeable enough?

Optical is a digital transport medium which means you'd be hooking up your speakers digitally to your computer instead of analog. This means you are bypassing the DAC on the onboard audio or internal/external soundcard of the computer. The DAC is the primary contributor to a sound card's "sound quality."

So if you get a nice soundcard with a nice DAC for your computer, you want an analog connection. If you have a better DAC built into a receiver or other device, you'd then want to use S/PDIF or HDMI to connect digitally to it to pass on DAC duties to the external device and not your soundcard or onboard audio.
 
Back
Top