Sony, Microsoft Discuss Blu-ray for Xbox 360

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Financial Times is making it sound like Microsoft and Sony are actually in talks about adding Blu-ray drives to the Xbox 360. Are there really talks going on? Or is this just a continuation of the reports we heard a couple weeks ago? Either way, the only Blu-ray drive I see MS doing is maybe another external drive to replace the HD DVD drive.

Microsoft declined to confirm any talks, saying: ”We have made no such announcement. Games are what are driving consumers to purchase game consoles and we remain focused on providing the largest library of blockbuster games available.”
 
cant wait. cause either way i need a new 360 with hdmi or the blue ray addon.
 
A combo player would be awesome. It will never ever happen but it sure would make things easier as far as not having to switch between the 360 and PS3 for movies. :)
 
If there is any kind of profit to be held by either of the two companies by doing this, I'm sure they will go about doing it.
 
I thought MS (secretly) developed a BD drive side by side with the HD-DVD drive just in case?
 
But a Microsoft rep said in a phone interview with Next-Gen that that is "not at all" the case, and Microsoft will "remain focused on the games" for the console, not its movie playback capabilities.

"There are no plans to introduce Blu-ray," said the spokesperson.

"In response to Stan Glasgow’s statement that Blu-ray is a possibility for Xbox 360, we have made no such announcement," the rep added in an e-mail. "Games are what are driving consumers to purchase game consoles and we remain focused on providing the largest library of blockbuster games available."
http://www.next-gen.biz/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=9445&Itemid=2

looks like this is a non-story
 
Too bad, I thought the whole point was to work with HD movies, hence the download service and HD-DVD drive. They should make one for the format that is going to be around.
 
If they only cared about games they wouldn't have made an HD DVD addon in the first place nor would they offer digital downloads for movies.
 
I don't see MS doing this unless they get one hell of a sweet deal.

It could be a sweet deal for MS and retailers if it went something like this:

Manufacturing cost: $50/drive
Sony/Blu Ray royalties: $50/drive
Cost to resellers: $150
MSRP: $200

MS makes $50 per drive, Sony makes $50 per drive, big box stores make $50 per drive, and for $200 the consumer snags an external player that cost the same as the HD DVD player did originally, but now enables blu ray playback on their powerful XBox 360 consoles, which have the processor power and software upgradeability required for HD playback.

That's what should happen, in my humble opinion. If they did that, everybody wins, and for a $200 investment the consumer now can add blu ray playback, which is the winning format, to their expensive xbox 360 setup. Truth be told, Microsoft really owes it to people who invested in their technology partially because of the promise (which MS made) of being able to play NEXT GEN hi def movies. Now that HD DVD is dying and blu ray is taking over the next gen market share, Microsoft should still damn well better fulfill its promise and offer a blasted next gen player for their console. I know many people who invested in the 360 mainly because of games, but also because of hi def movie playback.

Second, I don't see how they would lose by doing it. It's just something else that they'll be able to sell and make money one. Plus, it would make them a more direct competitor to the PS3. The PS3 would still have an edge for being a totally integrated unit.

Maybe it's not MS's fault. Perhaps because the XBOX is PS3's main competitor when it comes to hi res console gaming they would charge prohibitively high royalties to Microsoft for putting out an external blu ray player.

But again, there could be a workaround on that, too. There's nothing stopping other manufacturers from making external blu ray usb devices. What would stop MS from producing a driver/software update for the 360 to add support for such USB devices? Preventing them from doing that would be almost as bad as preventing microsoft for releasing blu ray player drivers for Windows Vista...

Again, this is pure speculation. Does Sony get most of the royalty money from blu-ray producers, anyways?? I wish there was more info. on this readily available. It just seems like the consumer is completely powerless in this battle of corporate giants. We have no say in these matters, and that sucks.

All I know is, last week, before Toshiba's announcement, I was %99 convinced I wanted to get the 360. I had even miraculously convinced my WIFE that it was ok!!! She would be able to play the fun Karaoke, American Idol, and guitar hero games. We would be able to network on xbox live with my brother and dad in wyoming, and sister and bro. in law in washington. And I was excited because I'd be able to attach the HD DVD drive to the 360 for some HD DVD playback on my hi def LCD. In fact I almost bought it one day, but something nagging in my gut made me hold back. The next day, I read about Toshiba's announcement here on Hard Forums. Now no more Xbox 360. And I will not buy until I can add a blu ray drive to it. I've seen customers in the store where I work buy PS3's or hold of on 360 purchases literally because of this sole reason. Instead of buying 360's and the hd dvd players - which I actually have had many customers do - we are now selling way more PS3's as blu ray players. I won't buy a PS3 - no xbox live, no media center extender, and lacking some fantastic xbox multiplayer titles. And I am not going to buy a 360, either, unless they provide blu ray support. But that's just me, and a handful of our store's customers.

Even though Microsoft is focused on games, and making the games sell their console, they are missing out on a big market share and many possible sales by not catering to the winning format. They sold a lot of HD DVD addon units, even though that format ended up losing. Imagine how many blu ray units they'd sell now that the winner has emerged.

/terminate thinking out loud session
 
Microsoft really owes it to people who invested in their technology partially because of the promise (which MS made) of being able to play NEXT GEN hi def movies. Now that HD DVD is dying and blu ray is taking over the next gen market share, Microsoft should still damn well better fulfill its promise and offer a blasted next gen player for their console.

I agree with this. They make the point of the 360 being able to play downloaded HD movies, movies and music over a local network or portable storage device, and physical media. Now that Blu Ray is the de facto physical media standard they really should make a player for it.
 
I agree with this. They make the point of the 360 being able to play downloaded HD movies, movies and music over a local network or portable storage device, and physical media. Now that Blu Ray is the de facto physical media standard they really should make a player for it.

Dang skippy they'd better. But like I said, if they do, good for them and great for us. If not, just another example of our lack of power as consumers in this day and age. Big corporations make all the decisions for us by throwing around large sums of money that most of us (at least me anyways) can't even comprehend. The customer is no longer always right, and now seldom heard. I know there are exceptions to this, to the extent that companies at least have to make their product sellable, but we still have a lot less control over what gets released than I believe we should. don't even get me started on the automobile industry as another example.....
 
They will crunch the numbers and if it looks like they can profit off of it we will see a blueray drive.
 
I think the will offer one, just to appease those who gripe about, to cover the checkbox. But it will remain an add on optional, so it has no effect on those not interested in the drive. Now if they subsidize it a bit, I get a cheap BD drive for my computer. :)

Though talking to Sony seems irrelevant. Sony doesn't own the majority of the patent pool, so they can't cut MS a sweetheart deal and similarly Sony can't deny MS the right to license the tech as it is set up with non-discriminatory licensing package at MPEG LA.
 
This would be awesome. I am very happy so far with my HD-DVD addon... I could use a matching Bluray too!
 
I guess I missed something, i never knew that Blu-ray has won. All i knew is that HD DVD had failed.
 
If they only cared about games they wouldn't have made an HD DVD addon in the first place nor would they offer digital downloads for movies.

They don't care about movies. They're just making sure they get the high def crowd to pay attention to them because when doing comparisons between console, they don't want people to rule out Xbox just because they don't have a high def movie player.

It's just a "look at me too" tactic.
 
I guess I missed something, i never knew that Blu-ray has won. All i knew is that HD DVD had failed.

True, but at least this leaves the choice to the consumers, not Microsoft or the Blu-Ray camp. Get an Xbox with or without a Blu-Ray, same as HD DVD. The option will be there.
 
They don't care about movies. They're just making sure they get the high def crowd to pay attention to them because when doing comparisons between console, they don't want people to rule out Xbox just because they don't have a high def movie player.

It's just a "look at me too" tactic.

Yep, and it's a good tactic. That means that the customers' needs will be met, which is just plain good business and good customer service. Nothing wrong with that. That's part of the reason I was ready to jump on the 360 and worked so hard at convincing my wife!

I guess I missed something, i never knew that Blu-ray has won. All i knew is that HD DVD had failed.

I also agree wholeheartedly with that, and posted another long rant on a forum about how HD-DVD was by no means blu-ray's main competitor! It's silly to think so, because the real competitor for both of them has ALWAYS been good ol' regular DVD's. And guess what, it STILL is the main competitor. Customers have to see enough value in it to justify the extra cost, or they will continue to buy regular DVD's, which is what 80-90% of the consumer base is still buying!!!

I think the will offer one, just to appease those who gripe about, to cover the checkbox. But it will remain an add on optional, so it has no effect on those not interested in the drive. Now if they subsidize it a bit, I get a cheap BD drive for my computer. :)

Though talking to Sony seems irrelevant. Sony doesn't own the majority of the patent pool, so they can't cut MS a sweetheart deal and similarly Sony can't deny MS the right to license the tech as it is set up with non-discriminatory licensing package at MPEG LA.

I was wondering about that. If that's the case then there shouldn't be anything in MS's way.

True, but at least this leaves the choice to the consumers, not Microsoft or the Blu-Ray camp. Get an Xbox with or without a Blu-Ray, same as HD DVD. The option will be there.

That's where the choice should ALWAYS be: with the consumer. I hate it when corporate giants tie our hands behind are backs and tell us what we're allowed to buy for what, and what we have to get to work with what, such as nVidia making us buy nVidia chipsets (whether they're good or bad is irrelivant) in order to use SLI. I should have to buy PS3 in order for my expensive HI DEF console to be able to play blu ray (which is just a type high definition) on the same HDTV my console will be connected to.
 
Do you even have the HD DVD drive? It's not loud at all.

Yeah, that's funny. I have the $50 HD DVD Xbox drive connected to my computer. My computer is almost silent, and I still never hear the disc, except for the initial spinup when it reads the disc title and chapter info. After that ... WHAT HD DVD drive?? My own breathing is louder!
 
It could be a sweet deal for MS and retailers if it went something like this:

Manufacturing cost: $50/drive
Sony/Blu Ray royalties: $50/drive
Cost to resellers: $150
MSRP: $200

MS makes $50 per drive, Sony makes $50 per drive, big box stores make $50 per drive, and for $200 the consumer snags an external player that cost the same as the HD DVD player did originally, but now enables blu ray playback on their powerful XBox 360 consoles, which have the processor power and software upgradeability required for HD playback.

I didn't think of it until this post, but MS would have to develop the software/firmware to run Blu-Ray Java. Java on a 360. Yeah, that's not going to cost anything to develop, debug, deploy and support.

Yikes!
 
The smart thing would have been for the "drive" to have always been HDDVD/Bluray ready, and now they could roll out a software enhancement to enable Blu functionality.

Lets face it, the difference between a HDDVD drive and a Blu drive is almost NOTHING. The software doing the decoding in the computer is where the difference lies.
 
The smart thing would have been for the "drive" to have always been HDDVD/Bluray ready, and now they could roll out a software enhancement to enable Blu functionality.

Lets face it, the difference between a HDDVD drive and a Blu drive is almost NOTHING. The software doing the decoding in the computer is where the difference lies.

i thougth it was also the laser in the driver?
 
I didn't think of it until this post, but MS would have to develop the software/firmware to run Blu-Ray Java. Java on a 360. Yeah, that's not going to cost anything to develop, debug, deploy and support.

Yikes!

Actually it won't be that bad. The XBox 360 is just a mini PC that's made for gaming. I'm sure it's powerful enough for the java interface, and would take very little to adapt. People adapt java for cellphones, smartphones, PDA's and the like. It's no different for the XBOX. I don't think it will be that costly,but I think the return on their investment will be huge. If they can make windows media center run flawlessly on the 360, why not Java?
 
The smart thing would have been for the "drive" to have always been HDDVD/Bluray ready, and now they could roll out a software enhancement to enable Blu functionality.

Lets face it, the difference between a HDDVD drive and a Blu drive is almost NOTHING. The software doing the decoding in the computer is where the difference lies.

Actually, there is quite a bit different.
 
They don't care about movies. They're just making sure they get the high def crowd to pay attention to them because when doing comparisons between console, they don't want people to rule out Xbox just because they don't have a high def movie player.

It's just a "look at me too" tactic.

I think it goes a bit deeper than that esp. with the IPTV capability.
 
The smart thing would have been for the "drive" to have always been HDDVD/Bluray ready, and now they could roll out a software enhancement to enable Blu functionality.

Lets face it, the difference between a HDDVD drive and a Blu drive is almost NOTHING. The software doing the decoding in the computer is where the difference lies.

The main difference is the laser used. It isn't a simple matter of software or firmware, it is a physical difference in the players.
 
Microsoft hates Sun Microsystems. They had years of litigation between the two. So for Blu-Ray to magically appear MS will have to pay royalties to Sun? I don't see it. But I suppose big business makes strange bedfellows...

Second thing is wouldn't this make MS pay Sony royalties especially if MS ditched the standard drive and incorporated strictly Blu-Ray? Sony would get a cut of every game that MS printed. Don't see that happening either.

So that leaves the standalone addon player. If MS can stomach working with Sun, then yeah I can see that happening. The consumer would pay all the royalties up front, and none of the 360 games would be subject to a fee because they would have to be played on the standard drive. That makes sense.

But then again MS could just tell consumers that Blu-Ray's adoption rate hasn't been that great, thus there isn't any need for the standalone player yet. Thus we will wait awhile until the war between digital downloads and Blu-Ray has cooled off. Thus MS has to do nothing but smirk at Sony, as we all know that if we could just download everything we would.

Helluva more convenient, and better selection. Don't believe me just see the MPAA and RIAA lawsuits. Now imagine a legal licensing service being implemented. Sony can only pray....
 
Microsoft hates Sun Microsystems. They had years of litigation between the two. So for Blu-Ray to magically appear MS will have to pay royalties to Sun? I don't see it. But I suppose big business makes strange bedfellows...

This happens all the time. Sony gave Cell processors to Toshiba for example. Microsoft makes Office products for Apple. Automakers around the world agree on standards. And so on.

ISO is what keeps businesses from truly isolating themselves. Everyone needs each other.
 
i dont see why microsoft wouldn't. How many of you own ps3's just to play movies? I would say the majority of people i know or talked to that own a ps3 have them as a blu ray player that happens to play games. Let's be honest, while there are some quality titles on the horizon, the actual good games on ps3 are multi platform.

That being said an inexpensive blu ray add on to the 360 would be a kick in the ass to sony because if you have a 360, then why would you need a ps3?

Though its that exact reason that i wonder how they could pull it off aside from giving the wink to a 3rd party to make one for them.
 
The big problem I see is the same issue Microsoft had with the HD-DVD drive. The Xbox is not capable of decoding any of the advanced sound formats or even sending multichannel PCM. So the best sound you would get would just be Dolby Digital for blu-ray too. I'm not sure that would be an issue or not for the average consumer though.
 
The big problem I see is the same issue Microsoft had with the HD-DVD drive. The Xbox is not capable of decoding any of the advanced sound formats or even sending multichannel PCM. So the best sound you would get would just be Dolby Digital for blu-ray too. I'm not sure that would be an issue or not for the average consumer though.

If the average consumer gets 5.1 dolby digital and all 6 of their speakers work, they'll probably be happy just to be able to play blu rays on their expensive xboxes. I would be happy. HappiER, anyways!! At least I wouldn't have invested in the 360 thinking I could play hi-def, only to have HD DVD die with no apparent future recourse... enter the blu ray addon drive! I sure hope they make one.
 
Back
Top