Sony Bravia for gaming question

Joined
Sep 22, 2007
Messages
3
I'm looking to get a new TV that I would also like to use for my new computer that I will be getting as soon as the new DirectX 10.1 cards come out. Cnet ranks the KDL-46XBR4 as the best LCD they've tested yet, but they don't list the pixel response time under the specs. I've found the same problem with other Sony TVs I've looked at too. The computer I'm going to build is going to be designed for gaming so I want a screen with a response time 8ms or under. Is it safe to assume that this TV will have that along with other Bravias or does anyone know a site that lists this info.
 
I'm looking to get a new TV that I would also like to use for my new computer that I will be getting as soon as the new DirectX 10.1 cards come out. Cnet ranks the KDL-46XBR4 as the best LCD they've tested yet, but they don't list the pixel response time under the specs. I've found the same problem with other Sony TVs I've looked at too. The computer I'm going to build is going to be designed for gaming so I want a screen with a response time 8ms or under. Is it safe to assume that this TV will have that along with other Bravias or does anyone know a site that lists this info.
In gaming mode, the Sony reverts back to 60 Hz processing, so it's going to have the typical LCD artifacts (motion trails, and pixilation of moving images). In its regular modes (with 120 Hz processing on), the picture quality is nice, but (again, for gaming) there is some lag between issuing controls and seeing the result on the screen. If you buy it, make sure you get it locally at a place with a good return policy in case the lag issues are a problem for you. They might not be.

I've got a dumb question though, why don't more people use 1080p plasmas for gaming? The new 1080p Pioneer Kuro models are incredible, burn-in is not an issue any more and image lag is pretty negligible from what I've seen so far. Motion reproduction and black levels beat any LCD I've seen yet.

Is there some reason why plasmas are not used as often as LCDs (other than size, of course, since you can't buy a plasma below 42 inches)? I guess price is probably an issue as well ($4K street price currently for the least expensive 1080p Kuro - a 50-incher).

-CB
 
As MrBoylan stated, there are heavy motion trails. I honestly don't see it when I'm playing games, but some movies are absolutely horrible in this area.

The other thing I notice is that when I plug in my computer to the TV via HDMI, the picture gets cut off on the edges. I haven't tried the VGA port though.

Overall, it's not a bad TV, (very little input lag), but don't expect miracles.
 
What do you think about the Pioneer Kuro PDP-5080HD. It's not 1080p but still has amazing picture quality and it's a 50in screen. The main reason I was looking at LCDs over plasmas is that I've heard plasmas can leak and over time loose their sharpness. I would like this TV to last me at least 10 years and from what I've heard an LCD would be a better choice for that. Granted though, the people I've heard this from know very little so I would much rather get some advice from people on here.
 
What do you think about the Pioneer Kuro PDP-5080HD. It's not 1080p but still has amazing picture quality and it's a 50in screen. The main reason I was looking at LCDs over plasmas is that I've heard plasmas can leak and over time loose their sharpness. I would like this TV to last me at least 10 years and from what I've heard an LCD would be a better choice for that. Granted though, the people I've heard this from know very little so I would much rather get some advice from people on here.
There is no such thing as "plasma leakage" - it's a myth. Also, modern plasma designs have close to zero risk of burn-in (particularly if they're calibrated properly), minimal image retention and have 60,000 hours or more lifespan to half-brightness. That works out to about 27 years watching 6 hours of TV a day. Your brain will rot before the panel does.

Even after that time (assuming the electronics hold up), the panel would still be watchable; you'd just need to recalibrate the brightness, contrast, color levels, etc. in order to get an optimized picture.

As for the Pioneer Kuro 1365x768 panel (PDP-5080), I'd take it over any LCD I've seen, personally (1080p or otherwise). And from 8 feet away, it's really tough to tell the difference between the Kuro 1080p and the 1365x768 Kuro panel. Just like with digital cameras, the number of pixels is only part of the story. Other factors have much more influence over picture quality. The black levels of the Kuro plasma are what set it apart from just about anything else on the market.

Later,

-CB
 
There is no leakage of the gases, but the gases do lose reactivity and viberance with usage.
 
There is no leakage of the gases, but the gases do lose reactivity and viberance with usage.
Everything wears out. Even LCDs. The most common bulbs used to illuminate an LCD panel have about the same (or lower) life expectancy as current plasmas' rated half lives. And they begin getting dimmer from the moment you turn them on. Is it noticeable? In most cases, no, not for years, so it's not worth worrying about. But most flat panel LCD assemblies do not support bulb replacement, so once the bulb goes, buh bye!

Plasma gasses do internally dissipate very slowly over time. After 2000 hours of use, they may have lost 5% of their overall brightness, but this is easily compensated for in calibration. So the image will look just as bright, clear accurate and vibrant years after you buy it as long as you recalibrate the display every year or two. You can do this by eye with a test disc like "Avia guide to home theater," or use a colorimeter and software package like the SpyderTV package which sells for around $200.

You should do the same with an LCD flat panel. As LCD backlighting bulbs wear out, they don't always do so in a "spectrally neutral" fashion. In other words, some colors in the light spectrum may dim quicker than others, and this means color levels need to be adjusted in the set to compensate. In most cases, we're talking about miniscule, barely measurable differences in the color spectrum, not visible by the naked eye so, again, not worth worrying about, but over time these can affect color accuracy and image quality.

Reaching 50% brightness after 27 years of use means that the longevity of current plasma TVs is actually better than that of CRT, and as good as LCD, and that's good enough for me.

-Chris
 
Back
Top