Some thoughts on my build?

yeahthatsme

Weaksauce
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
96
so I'm trying to build a good gaming computer. I'll be playing all of the new fps's and rts's and a few mmorpgs. also, I'd like to do some air-cooled over clocking and whatnot. so far i have this as a parts list, but I'm very open to suggestions. my max budget is around $3000 but spending less is ok :) . i realize that the speakers are crappy but they will be mostly for day time/weekend movie viewing, as I'll be using them in the dorms next year. thanks!

edit:
Just to give you some more information i decided to go with the E6600 over the Q because of over clocking capabilities and the fact that there isn't really any quad core programs out right now. I'll probably pick one up when the price drops.

updated list
 
'Looks good. I wouldn't get that CPU cooler, though. Have you considered getting a Tuniq Tower or Thermalright Ultra-120, instead?
 
Looks good. You don't need the HZ sticks with an E6600. An E6600 will reach 3.6Ghz on good air, and 9 * 400 = 3.6Ghz already. The HZ sticks are only good for overclocking (the ram), which you won't really need to do with such a high CPU multiplier. The 2GBNQ sticks will suffice, and can even OC a bit to 425-450Mhz, in case you want that extra UMPH.

The Ninja is a good choice. Its much lighter than the Tuniq and Ultra 120, and still performs just as good... its also cheaper, lol. The Tuniq is good for high airflow cases, and the Ninja is good for low airflow cases. I have both, and ran my own personal tests. Even though I have a high airflow case, my ninja still cooled better than my Tuniq by a couple degrees. Maybe I need to lap my Tuniq, lol... the base didnt seem all that smooth to me. But alas, I'm too lazy to lap, so I just kept the Ninja on. My E6400 at 3.6Ghz 1.5v idled at 37°C and reached 56°C on load. At 3.2Ghz 1.33v, it idled at 30°C and reached 50°C on load. The Tuniq numbers are similar, just a few degrees higher, moreso when idle, less during load. My homie had an Ultra 120 that I tried, and it was similar to both the Ninja and Tuniq. Though, the Ultra 120 is TALL, lol.
 
Did I read that right, 3 memory sticks? If you want 3 GB of ram, do it with 4 sticks, 2x 1GB + 2x 512 GB. That would be my only recommendation.
 
The build looks to be good. Here are a few suggestions to make it better:

1) I agree with the above post about the RAM. If you're going with 3 Gigs, don't buy three 1 gig DIMMS. This will cause all of your RAM to run in single channel mode, significantly reducing their speed. Buy a 2x1Gig set and a 2x512Meg sit instead. I also agree that getting overclocked RAM is a waste of money for an E6600, although with the 680i you can run that RAM at overclocked speed w/o worrying too much about dividers and timings.

2) Get the EVGA A1 model instead of the AR. The A1 is a newer revision which eliminates the kinks found in the original AR model. The A1 is a fantastic board that has worked flawlessly for me.

3) For such a high end system, I must say I'm not too much of a fan of that Cooler Master case, although this is all personal preference here. Granted, the 830 is a beast, but in my experience I've found it to be lacking in build quality and in features. I feel that a grand system deserves the best in case build and design, and if you're already planning to spend over $200 on a case, I suggest you look at Silverstones (specifically the TJ-07 or TJ-09) or Lian Lis instead.

Enjoy,

Mark.
 
Hm... I find the build quality of Cooler Master cases pretty damn good, lol. Though, I havent checked out the Stacker 830. I do have the original Stacker and a couple Centurions, and they're all great cases of good build quality. Now, my Antec P160... that thing is junk compared to any Lian-Li or Silverstone case, lol. I also think any case over $100 is a waste of money, lol (got the stacker for $85 on cusa liquidation). I would hope you could get a nice case for $100, so you could spend the rest on more important stuff, lol. The stacker may be overpriced, but I highly doubt its of mediocre build quality -- compared to all the other choices out there. I agree though, the Silverstone Temjin series is by far the sexiest case line out there, lol.
 
Haha, let me reiterate: In my evaluation of the Stacker 830, I found it lacking in build quality and features for a $250+ case. (When building my PC, I actually went to J&R and played with one in person.) Compared to similarly priced Silverstones and Lian-Lis, the Stacker felt, while not cheaply made, perhaps not worthy of the high price. I was also peeved that the Stacker included almost no fans... just tons of fan mounts. While my Silverstone didn't come with fans for the two optional top mounts, it did supply everything needed for the mid-section graphics card airflow (including a nice 120MM fan sitting in front of the hard disks.) At the $200+ price point for cases, everything is subjective. For $250, the 830 felt (to me) to be too common, or perhaps, "mass-produced" for the price. Heh, seriously though it's a fine case.. It's expensive, but obviously it'll prove to be a bigger, better made case than those that are far cheaper.

Mark.
 
ok so here is an updated list. i DEFINITELY like the lines on the TJ-09, very clean. i also changed it to the 4 sticks of ram instead of 3. thanks for all of the suggestions!
 
oh ok. yah... comparing it with other cases in its price range, its not as... high-class, i guess is the term. i'd definately pickup a TJ-09 over the 830, lol. though, i think the 830 is mainly for GTX's in SLI, lol, with its 4x 120mm side fan mounts. the original stacker came with all fans except the sidepanel mount fan (80mm).
 
Everything looks good to me except for the games. Buy those games at Amazon.com. No tax and free shipping on most items.
 
Since we're, kind of, on the topic of Stackers and enginurd mentioned the Ultra-120, i have a question: does anybody know of the Thermalright Ultra-120 would would fit in the Stacker 830 with 4 fans on the side?

Is everybody of the opinion that the TJ09 is a better case than the Stacker 830? I'm undecided as to whether i get the TJ09 or Stacker 830 Evolution when i build a new rig next month. I think, if the TJ09 had an extra mount for a 120mm fan above the existing one aimed at the graphics card, i'd get it. I just like the idea of having a couple of 120mm fans on the front of the Stacker to blow more air across the whole of the motherboard, rather than the single fan in the TJ09 which just cools the graphics card(s).
 
Is everybody of the opinion that the TJ09 is a better case than the Stacker 830?

My opinion is that the TJ-09 is a higher-class case -- not necessarily better. However, I believe both are overpriced, lol. In the end, the decision is yours. The entire motherboard does not need to be cooled, btw. See which features you value the most, and decide from there. For instance, I love slide-out mobo trays, mechanisms to quiet down the HDD vibrations, and clean lines. Unfortunately, to me, the 830Evo just looks like the stacker on steroids -- but some people want that look. I'd much rather have the clean lines of the TJ-09 for that much money. If water cooling is your thing, I believe both are good at accomodating radiators.
 
Back
Top