Soldering Iron

fenton06

2[H]4U
Joined
Mar 28, 2003
Messages
2,140
What is everyone's perferred solding iron? I need to buy a new one and I want one that had the little station. Any suggestions?
 
How much you looking to spend? A basic ok soldering iron can be 50 bucks or so that will handle most peoples needs but a real nice one can be over a grand easy.
 
My thoughts on irons:

- I'm a pleased Hakko 936 ESD owner. We use these on the assembly line at work too, and they've very good and very reliable.

- We've also had Weller WES58's on the line, but they started dying. They don't seem to like being on and in constant 8-to-5 use, but for regular electronics hobby work they're a fantastic iron.

- Pace is the next closest thing to Metcal. Wonderful equipment, but pricy. We've got a Pace SMD rework station at work, which is a great piece of machinery.

- Metcal is a justifiable reason to sell a kidney. I've used one, and the temperature regulation on them is fantastic and instant. You can solder unbelievably big joints using a small tip.
 
I'm a fan of my Weller WES50. It has automatic temperature control, and does a nice job of soldering even surfacemount components, not that I recommend doing so unless you have a very steady hand.

It's a station style iron, with a spring-style rest and a sponge for cleaning the oxydization off the iron tip prior to soldering.
 
I feel so...low...for using a Home Depot branded soldering gun, and a RadioShack soldering iron.

I AM CHEAP!
 
gee said:
My thoughts on irons:

- I'm a pleased Hakko 936 ESD owner. We use these on the assembly line at work too, and they've very good and very reliable.

- We've also had Weller WES58's on the line, but they started dying. They don't seem to like being on and in constant 8-to-5 use, but for regular electronics hobby work they're a fantastic iron.

- Pace is the next closest thing to Metcal. Wonderful equipment, but pricy. We've got a Pace SMD rework station at work, which is a great piece of machinery.

- Metcal is a justifiable reason to sell a kidney. I've used one, and the temperature regulation on them is fantastic and instant. You can solder unbelievably big joints using a small tip.

I used a PACE SMD rework system at work also.. PRC-2000?
 
My next purchase will probably be a Hakko because it's in my price range.
If I had the money to spend, I'd get a very nice Metcal station, and a few irons.

Unfortunately for a hobby, it's too much to invest at this time. In the mean time I'll
be living with my cheapie ratshack special until my next major project. That will give me
enough reason to upgrade. With nothing in the wings I have no reason to get new tools.

-Jeff
 
If you need a decent inexpensive soldering station, chack out this $39.99 one at Circuit Specialists. It's not too much, and is much preferable to any of the Rat Shack offerings or the bottom line Wellers.

[edit]
Never underestimate the value of a good tool. It's amazing how much easier the job can be if you use the proper equipment. I've got a ebay'd XYtronic 168 that I'm very happy with, but I've always seen the Hakko's suggested by many people. I think Hakko and XYtronic must have some connection, many of their models share the same tips.
 
hignaki said:
I feel so...low...for using a Home Depot branded soldering gun, and a RadioShack soldering iron.

I AM CHEAP!


Im lame as well. Ive been modding consoles for years with a ratshack butane elcrapo iron for years.


People here listed some serious hardware, and I have used many of the tools described, and they are better. But their is not much they can do, that I cant do with my cheap crap, as long as their is no air moving in the room. ( I use my breath to control my temps, Im OLD SCHOOL)

You too can learn to blow lightly to control temp, and can get by with a much cheaper iron. But its NOT perfect, and it does take practice.

NOW, with that said, the 39.99 temp controlled station looks like great deal
 
There's no doubt you can do a lot with one of those el-cheapo irons. And if you're just soldering wires to some switches, leds and the like you probably don't need much more. The adjustable temp irons are great not so much because you can cool them down (which is important), it's that they also have the beef to hold their temp when you solder to heavy items, like jacks and lugs or desoldering. (how many tips have I bent wtih cheap irons trying to work on a heavy part).

BTW - I've also got one of those Rat Shack butane torch / irons - they kick ass! Great portable million-in-one tool. From what I've read I wouldn't touch one of those cold heat things with a ten foot pole.

[edit]

FWIW, beyond the unit itself, one of the first things I noticed when I stepped up to a decent station was that the quality of the tips alone was a huge improvement. I used to try to keep my tips clean and tinned, but they always got nasty very quickly. The tips (and variety!) of decent stations are by themselves a great step up.
 
*drool*
Its time for me to replace my $7 radioshack iron. Its taking forever to warm up. My soldering gun is kinda screwed up too... I have a special temperature control system.. its my super surge supressor switch.... turn it on and off depending on if the circuit starts to melt.

So, its time to get a new iron...
It seems that the biggest benefit of these irons is the temperature control. Possibly better tips...
Time to research these neat soldering irons.


Yes, the Cold Heat is crap... it stays cold.. shoulda purchaed the butane one instead. Thought it would be good for the quick solders... switches and junk... nope..
 
I once bought a $2 cheapo 25W from Fry's. Its power cord was only 3' long, with a plug slipped out easily from wall outlets and power strips and stayed snug only in extension cord sockets. It also ran uncomfortably hot, and its barrel turned blue, but it didn't seem to deliver much heat to the tip. It burned out in a month.
 
fenton06 said:
What is everyone's perferred solding iron? I need to buy a new one and I want one that had the little station. Any suggestions?

weller wtcpt
 
Weller with out a doubt. It is the best. If you spend over a grand, you are an idiot. unless it has a solder sucker as well
 
Back
Top