Solar Storm Threat Increasing

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Solar storms in the past were nothing much more that oddities since electronic technology had not developed, but today is another story altogether. The danger of disruption is much greater with the world wired together via cell phones, computers, GPS and massive electrical grids. Solar storms generally run in 11 year cycles, and we are overdue.


"Many things that we take for granted today are so much more prone to the process of space weather than was the case in the last solar maximum."
 
"This weeks FUD brought to you by..."

Yahoo News is turning into the online Weekly World News. We've been using GPS, cell phones, and computer networks worldwide for what, 20+ years? And it's not like electrical grids are a new invention. If the world is supposed to come to a grinding halt every time there's a solar flare, why hasn't it ever happened before? Sure, there may be localized problems, but this:

"Such a catastrophic event could cost the United States alone up to two trillion dollars in repairs in the first year -- and it could take up to 10 years to fully recover, the report said."

sounds to me like a few scientists trying to generate hysteria in the ignorant in the hope that it will generate some grant money. Welcome back to the Bush era "weapons of mass destruction" agenda for getting what you want. :rolleyes:
 
"This weeks FUD brought to you by..."

Yahoo News is turning into the online Weekly World News. We've been using GPS, cell phones, and computer networks worldwide for what, 20+ years? And it's not like electrical grids are a new invention. If the world is supposed to come to a grinding halt every time there's a solar flare, why hasn't it ever happened before? Sure, there may be localized problems, but this:

"Such a catastrophic event could cost the United States alone up to two trillion dollars in repairs in the first year -- and it could take up to 10 years to fully recover, the report said."

sounds to me like a few scientists trying to generate hysteria in the ignorant in the hope that it will generate some grant money. Welcome back to the Bush era "weapons of mass destruction" agenda for getting what you want. :rolleyes:

Nice job understanding what they are talking about. You've cracked the case.
 
sounds to me like a few scientists trying to generate hysteria in the ignorant in the hope that it will generate some grant money.

To those of us NOT ignorant about solar activity it's not hysteria. If the interplanetary magnetic field is polarized the wrong direction and, say, an X20 class flare erupts aimed at earth, then it's not a question of if it will wreak havoc but how much havoc it will wreak. The X-ray burst alone would be enough to shut down and probably damage satellites, and the resultant CME could overload electrical grids once it hits the Van Allen belts and triggers a geomagnetic storm. The recent X2 flare caused communication disruptions in China, and that's considered small on the X scale. We've had X20 class flares before, just none aimed square at the Earth. We'll have them again. The solar cycle is currently out of phase with the normal 11 year oscillation, which means there's an internal imbalance in the sun's magnetic cycle. It's been unusually quiet which leads to the possibility of the sun becoming unusually active again. If it does, it increases the possibility of severe flares significantly.

There's no guarantee that a large flare will be directed at earth when the sun hits peak maximum. Nobody's saying it's a guaranteed hit. The problem is that it only takes one direct hit to generate the potential for severe damage. If you think solar activity is not an issue, talk to NASA sometime. A friend of mine was involved in developing space-based computer systems for satellites, along with the inertial guidance systems used on satellites and cruise missiles. Protecting these systems from EM and particle radiation is extremely important, and the danger to non-shielded systems is well known. Ground-based power systems have absolutely NO shielding, and all it takes is one overload, blow out some of the high-voltage transformers, and you have a serious problem. This isn't alarmist thinking. It's a very real concern.
 
I thought this solar cycle's peak would be rather weak? Don't know where I picked that up, but anyway, I've always wanted to see some aurorae so that would be my chance ;)
 
To those of us NOT ignorant about solar activity it's not hysteria. If the interplanetary magnetic field is polarized the wrong direction and, say, an X20 class flare erupts aimed at earth, then it's not a question of if it will wreak havoc but how much havoc it will wreak. The X-ray burst alone would be enough to shut down and probably damage satellites, and the resultant CME could overload electrical grids once it hits the Van Allen belts and triggers a geomagnetic storm. The recent X2 flare caused communication disruptions in China, and that's considered small on the X scale. We've had X20 class flares before, just none aimed square at the Earth. We'll have them again. The solar cycle is currently out of phase with the normal 11 year oscillation, which means there's an internal imbalance in the sun's magnetic cycle. It's been unusually quiet which leads to the possibility of the sun becoming unusually active again. If it does, it increases the possibility of severe flares significantly.

There's no guarantee that a large flare will be directed at earth when the sun hits peak maximum. Nobody's saying it's a guaranteed hit. The problem is that it only takes one direct hit to generate the potential for severe damage. If you think solar activity is not an issue, talk to NASA sometime. A friend of mine was involved in developing space-based computer systems for satellites, along with the inertial guidance systems used on satellites and cruise missiles. Protecting these systems from EM and particle radiation is extremely important, and the danger to non-shielded systems is well known. Ground-based power systems have absolutely NO shielding, and all it takes is one overload, blow out some of the high-voltage transformers, and you have a serious problem. This isn't alarmist thinking. It's a very real concern.

This.

Just look at what happened in Quebec(Canada) couple years back due to a solar flare, and that wasn't all too large of one either!
 
Solar storms have been a threat to our technology for a long damn time..

No one has any idea when the next big one (like one observed in 1859) will hit.

A useless article that proves something we already know , the Sun can kick our ass whenever it fucking pleases.
 
Not really a useless article, it does remind us all of it, and tells the ones who don't know about it about it.
 
Sweet, it says the last one made those sweet looking Aurora in the Caribbean... fuck the internet and communication for that day, I'm going outside and checking out the Aurora instead :D
 
I can't remember when... but the last Solar Flare I heard of made an Aurora down to Texas or something.

It was at night or something so I completely missed it. Not to mention, they only predicted it to hit the upper United States... it was unexpectedly bigger.
 
Good lord. This would be VERY bad considering the colder then average weather that a lot of the US has been getting this year. Combine that with the power going down, and you have a rather high death toll. I guess it's not such a bad idea to have a wood burning fireplace in your home, even in this age.
 
Back
Top