Smaller PCs Cause Worry for Industry

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Are mini-PCs and UMPCs really as bad for the industry as this New York Times article makes them out to be?

“We’re sitting on the sidelines not because we’re lazy. We’re sitting on the sidelines because even if this category takes off, and we get our piece of the pie, it doesn’t add up,” said Paul Moore, senior director of mobile product management for Fujitsu. “It’s a product that essentially has no margin.”
 
Nothing's as bad for the industry as far as profits (read that again, as far as profits) as the PS3.
 
haha they are just worried that their gravy train is drying up
more and more powerful laptop's arn't needed if all you do is browse the net or write emails/letters
 
more and more powerful laptop's arn't needed if all you do is browse the net or write emails/letters

But really, isn't this actually a failure on the part of Microsoft? If more and more powerful laptops aren't needed if all one does is browse the net or write emails/letters, obviously someone needs to introduce a more resource intensive operating system so more powerful laptops are necessary. Efficiency for the end user is bad for business.
 
Well, clearly it makes sense to Acer, Asus, MSI, HP, Dell and to all the people buying these things.

For now.

My advice to Fujitsu: leave it alone.

Let the market decide, if they are too cheap, the prices will come up, if there is only limited demand, it will dry up and so will these units.

Complaining that customers are happy is not a good way to win sympathy.
 
I don't see how their crying makes any sense whatsoever.

Currently, subnotebooks with tolerable specs cost a $50-250 more than budget laptops with significantly higher capabilities. That certainly sounds like a much higher profit margin to me.
 
...obviously someone needs to introduce a more resource intensive operating system so more powerful laptops are necessary. ...
I'm have every confidence that MS will "tweak" the next OS to do just that.
This time, it will require a Blue-Ray disk to install instead of some "wimpy" DVD. :D


... :cool:
 
I'm have every confidence that MS will "tweak" the next OS to do just that.
This time, it will require a Blue-Ray disk to install instead of some "wimpy" DVD. :D


... :cool:

Yeah... I'm still not entirely sure if I was writing satire or a business case.
 
Of course they don't like them. Anyone notice how HP/Dell are slowly trying to creep up the prices of these things? It started at $250, then it was $300, then $400, now it's approaching $500. :mad:
 
I picked up my wife the 2G Surf. Honestly, if it is just for email and surfing and light music and video why would you need more? I know they gotta make a dime but really.
 
But really, isn't this actually a failure on the part of Microsoft? If more and more powerful laptops aren't needed if all one does is browse the net or write emails/letters, obviously someone needs to introduce a more resource intensive operating system so more powerful laptops are necessary. Efficiency for the end user is bad for business.

What kind of stupid argument is that? Computers are supposed to advance to higher speed, not recess to slower ones. It's certainly not Microsoft's fault hardware manufacturers are backwards. The MSI Wind is proof that UMPC's CAN be small, cheap and fast.
 
Well past $500 you mean.

“It’s a product that essentially has no margin.”

Once they shift the price back to 500, your back to the entry level 14 inch screen size laptops, which kind of forces one to go back to the bigger laps and kill off this "no margin" useful product depending on what they throw in.
Years ago when laptops first came out that was what sold them,small size, take your computer anywhere, idea. Then the industry convinced you that bigger is better and higher margins is even better. Whats happening now is that reality comes into play, it takes a few years. When you go to Starbucks are you wanting to take a gaming machine or something small enough to be able to read the latest on the web or for email.
At my age my eyes are having trouble seeing the smaller fonts, but I also don't like to increase the size and get less on a page and do alot more scrolling. At 250 to 300 I can see myself scrolling text more and throw in some reading glasses to boot.:D
 
Lets face it. Average joe does not play non java based games. MSN, Facebook, Ebay and the ability to do word processing is what composes 90% of there activities. All the average user needs hardware wise is 512ram, 1k mhz+ processor, and some storage running XP. Most of my business clients are cloud computing already, or store all there files server side. Using my crystal ball I see mainstream users treating PC as a disposable commodity, much as cell phones are.

Cheers!
 
I would think that addons/upgrades would be the money making forte for those things but maybe not.
 
They are useful for someone on the go at an airport or on a commuting trip on a bus, but not for a more intense computing experience, he said. “It’s a good 30- to 90-minute experience.”

That's funny. I use my EEE 4G a lot more than 30-90 minutes, especially when watching movies. When I'm not using it on the go or on vacation, I have it hooked up to my home theater as a networked MP3 player. I've also bought a GPU puck and software for it. I've even caught my wife using it instead of her 17", dual-core Vista laptop on occasion, especially while lounging in the back yard.
 
Yes, they really are that bad for the industry. As owner of a small family run computer store I know that these products will eventually drive us completely out of the new PC business. They do in fact have no margins and aren't worth the trouble to sell. Worse yet, they will be mostly impossible to make money repairing. So unless it's a Windows problem, RAM, or a hard disk, we won't be able to make any money repairing it.

We are already having this problem with notebooks. Repair is impractical a good deal of the time. When a screen or motherboard goes bad in today's units, it's going to be a minimum $300 job to fix it and we are well aware of the fact that may be more than half the cost of the notebook. The better solution for the customer? Throw it away and buy another one from some online retailer that tries to survive on no margins.

The PCs will be throw-away cheap and plentiful, but HELP will be impossible to find.
 
As owner of a small family run computer store I know that these products will eventually drive us completely out of the new PC business.

I honestly didn't think there were small family run PC stores anymore. I thought Dell and co. had already killed that.

I've been surprised for years that this trend toward super cheap PC's hasn't already happened. Web browsing, music, document authoring were all done on P133's and that's what most people use computers for. Shoot, WinAMP had a release that could push a 256kbit MP3 on a 486! Couldn't do much else on it at the same time though...

The industry is just going to have to accept that this is the way things are going to go and if they aren't going to produce/sell them, someone else will.
 
I don't see how their crying makes any sense whatsoever.

Currently, subnotebooks with tolerable specs cost a $50-250 more than budget laptops with significantly higher capabilities. That certainly sounds like a much higher profit margin to me.

What does "tolerable specs" mean? Tolerable if you force Vista onto the poor machine? Tolerable for playing GPU-happy games (that publishers only want to make for consoles anyway)? Video editing? There aren't many jobs that take much more than 1GHz of Pentium 3 CPU power, and plenty aren't as suitable for portable use anyway.

Even if you are [H]ard enough to still need the power of a real desktop (or lapburner) these things make great handy toys. The reason that the companies are crying is that most people won't see a good reason to upgrade the main machine, but might want to replace the zero-margin auxiliary machine.

PS. Don't tell anyone about these. Even peguinistas should realize the importance of maintaining the gravy flow of cool chips. Don't you want to see if AMD is really trying to make a bulldozer? Don't you really want a Nahalem? Don't tell anybody about the EEE!
 
The industry will just have to adapt like it always had. If cheap PCs become more popular ('netbooks') then bump up prices in response to demand. Since these PCs are treated as disposable then they can sell more of them. There's your profit (in theory anyway).
 
Back
Top