Small upgrade on current system or new Dell?

CarNut

n00b
Joined
Jun 28, 2006
Messages
55
Hey guys, great forum here, I've been reading as much as I can here and been learning quite a bit. I've got a question that maybe you guys can help with. My current system is as follows:

Intel Pentium 4 2.2GHz
Crucial 512MB PC2100 DDR RAM
nVidia GeForce4 Ti 4400 128MB RAM
Intel D845BG Motherboard
IBM 80GB Deskstar EIDE ATA100
Western Digital Caviar Special Edition EIDE ATA 100
Plextor CD-RW 40/12/40
Toshiba DVD-ROM 16/48
SoundBlaster Audigy 5.1 Gamer Sound Card

I had originally planned to add another stick of 512MB memory to help hold me over until DirectX 10 and the new line of nVidia cards come out, but I've been looking at Dell's website and and they have some pretty cheap and decent systems for around $400-$600 including a monitor.

I would like to hear your opinions on which would be a better path to take and why. If it's to upgrade my current system, which video card should I go with (I believe it has to be AGP due to my motherboard)? If it's to buy a Dell, which one would be the best bang for the buck? Keep in mind that I would like to have this system next to the new system I will be building once the new DX10/nVidia G80 cards come out.

Thanks in advance.
 
Depends, if you're going to build a system as soon as the DX10 cards come out, you don't really have that long to wait it doesn't seem. I think most people expect them to start hitting this fall. Your system is pretty far back on the tech curve, so it should be pretty easy to get alot more performance than what you're getting now for relatively cheap.

Let me interject this...if you plan on doing much upgrading, I really wouldn't advise getting a dell. Dell uses lots of parts that are proprietary and make upgrading a royal pain. I'm going through just that right now. Ventialtion issues and an insufficient powersupply have turned a $350 upgrade into over twice that, due to having to replace nearly everything.

I wouldn't reccomend replacing a videocard on an AGP system if you're planning on upgrading again soon, since your next upgrade you're almost definitely going to need a new processor/motherboard, and it likely won't support AGP, thus rendering your videocard useless.

If you don't plan to do much upgrading, and I'm understanding your situation right, I would reccomend holding off on the upgrades to your current rig, as you'll still be heavily bottlenecked by your videocard or cpu in most games, and putting any money you wuold spend on that into a new main computer once DX10 cards hit. Going this route, if you plan to keep both comps, i would keep your current computer as is for office aps, since it's still A-ok for that, and your new computer for gaming/other power hungry programs.
 
Hmm, I did not know that about Dell's... very interesting.

As far as upgrading, I think I should have been a little more specific. What I hoped to get out of upgrading the video card and RAM was an improvement in performance that I would notice. I know I won't be able to play most new games at their highest settings, but for example I can play Half-Life 2 at medium or so settings right now just fine, and that is ok with me. I usually build a computer and try to use it for as long as I can (seems to be around 5 years) and then start from scratch and build a new one.

If I upgrade this computer now (which I guess would cost around $150-$200), I will not be upgrading it again when the DX10 cards come out. I would be building a completely new system from scratch and keeping this current one along side to maybe play some older games.

I guess to put it simply, I'm asking if it's worth it to upgrade the video card and RAM, and would I notice a significant improvement in speeds.

Thanks for the reply :)

WHOAguitarninja said:
Depends, if you're going to build a system as soon as the DX10 cards come out, you don't really have that long to wait it doesn't seem. I think most people expect them to start hitting this fall. Your system is pretty far back on the tech curve, so it should be pretty easy to get alot more performance than what you're getting now for relatively cheap.

Let me interject this...if you plan on doing much upgrading, I really wouldn't advise getting a dell. Dell uses lots of parts that are proprietary and make upgrading a royal pain. I'm going through just that right now. Ventialtion issues and an insufficient powersupply have turned a $350 upgrade into over twice that, due to having to replace nearly everything.

I wouldn't reccomend replacing a videocard on an AGP system if you're planning on upgrading again soon, since your next upgrade you're almost definitely going to need a new processor/motherboard, and it likely won't support AGP, thus rendering your videocard useless.

If you don't plan to do much upgrading, and I'm understanding your situation right, I would reccomend holding off on the upgrades to your current rig, as you'll still be heavily bottlenecked by your videocard or cpu in most games, and putting any money you wuold spend on that into a new main computer once DX10 cards hit. Going this route, if you plan to keep both comps, i would keep your current computer as is for office aps, since it's still A-ok for that, and your new computer for gaming/other power hungry programs.
 
CarNut said:
Hmm, I did not know that about Dell's... very interesting.

As far as upgrading, I think I should have been a little more specific. What I hoped to get out of upgrading the video card and RAM was an improvement in performance that I would notice. I know I won't be able to play most new games at their highest settings, but for example I can play Half-Life 2 at medium or so settings right now just fine, and that is ok with me. I usually build a computer and try to use it for as long as I can (seems to be around 5 years) and then start from scratch and build a new one.

Yes, you could absolutely get more performance out of your coputer with a few "small" upgrades. My friend has a computer similar to yours. He bought a gig of ram and an x1600pro and can run most relatively recent(HL:2, Far Cry, etc) games at full settings with pretty good performance(ie:definitely playable) at good resolutions. I haven't actually seen his comp since he did the upgrading so I can't say exactly how good the performance is. He was coming from a geforce4mx, so i'm not sure what exactly his definition of "good" performance. If I go over and see anytime soon i'll update my reply or send you a pm if this drops off the main page.
If I upgrade this computer now (which I guess would cost around $150-$200), I will not be upgrading it again when the DX10 cards come out. I would be building a completely new system from scratch and keeping this current one along side to maybe play some older games.
Ok, that sounds good. What timeframe are you looking to build a new computer in? If you're just waiting for the dx10 cards to hit the market, you really won't be waiting all that long it doesn't seem. If you plan on waiting for prices to fall, you'll probably be waiting a bit longer.
I guess to put it simply, I'm asking if it's worth it to upgrade the video card and RAM, and would I notice a significant improvement in speeds.

Thanks for the reply :)

It all depends on the time frame and how much longer you can stand to be at the performance level that you're at. If you want my personal opinion, I would use the money you would have spent on upgrading your current computer to alleviate any guilty feelings of spending more to get something a little better/earlier than you had originally planned on doing once the dx10 cards do hit, but that's all personal preference. Honestly though, when the UE3 games and Crysis start hitting, I think you'd be happy knowing you're near the top of the heap as far as performance goes, though.

But like I said, it's really a matter of what you want to do.
 
If you do get another stick of ram and a new video card, run at 1024x768 or above, due to cpu limitations.
 
Please do not believe the fact that dell uses all propriatory parts. Whilst this is true in some systems it is not always fact.

Dell themselves now make a hefty profit upgrading peoples systems and they understand that it is part of the consumers expectations and the natural life of a PC... buy.. upgrade.. final upgrade... give to your sister!

I, and my family have owned Dell systems for either personal or business use. I have managed to change any component I have found in them... this was from the dimension 8300 to todays Dells... PSUs, RAM, GPUs HDDs have all changed and changed well.

The down side with a Dell is that their copy of windows is very bloated and it can take a while and some googling to kill off the unwanted processes.

All in all Dell is not that bad, I am not a Dell f4nboy either (if such a thing exists).. just trying to balance the arguement with my own real life experiences.

Personally I would always build my own machine with gaming in mind.. a Great system does not have to cost the earth especially if you look for deals.. good luck dude.
 
Thanks for the replies :)

I saw the ATI deal in the HotDeals section and decided to jump on it (I ordered the X800XL). I also bought a stick of 512MB memory. All together it only cost me about $150. I think that's an okay price to pay for a small upgrade. I just hope i will be able to feel the difference and not be tooooooo bottlenecked by my CPU :p
 
BlastRadius said:
Please do not believe the fact that dell uses all propriatory parts. Whilst this is true in some systems it is not always fact.

Dell themselves now make a hefty profit upgrading peoples systems and they understand that it is part of the consumers expectations and the natural life of a PC... buy.. upgrade.. final upgrade... give to your sister!

I, and my family have owned Dell systems for either personal or business use. I have managed to change any component I have found in them... this was from the dimension 8300 to todays Dells... PSUs, RAM, GPUs HDDs have all changed and changed well.

The down side with a Dell is that their copy of windows is very bloated and it can take a while and some googling to kill off the unwanted processes.

All in all Dell is not that bad, I am not a Dell f4nboy either (if such a thing exists).. just trying to balance the arguement with my own real life experiences.

Personally I would always build my own machine with gaming in mind.. a Great system does not have to cost the earth especially if you look for deals.. good luck dude.


Not to derail the thread, but the problem with dell isn't that they use all proprietary parts. Infact I think only the motherboard and powersupply have unique designs. It's that if you don't want to pay through the nose to buy the components they put out, then changing one part often means swapping out lots of other parts. Dell isn't all bad, but certain upgrades can be much more of a hassle than they are worth due to their parts.

Carnut, coming from a geforce4, you'll definitely notice a pretty solid difference.
 
Back
Top