SLI vs Dual Card (295)?

eddie500

Gawd
Joined
Jan 23, 2003
Messages
1,009
is there any drawbacks to using SLI that would not be a factor in a dual card like the Geforce295?

I've heard people hate SLI. What are some of the problems?
 
There are no drawbacks in one case that aren't there in the other. Same goes for ATI. This because the GTX 295 is just SLI on a single PCIE connector (single board/product), and the 4870x2 is just CrossfireX on a single PCIE connector (single/board product). It's the same thing.

People don't hate SLI so much as they hate issues with multi-gpu in general (both SLI and Crossfire included).

Multi-gpu introduces a tremendous amount of complexity to graphics drivers, and there are a lot of things that can go wrong. Basically the fundamental problem is that games are all coded under the assumption that 1 GPU will be used in a given machine, and as a result multi-gpu only works (as a bit of a hack) by pretending that all GPUs are the same GPU. This introduces problems since it obviously isn't true.

Some common complaints about multi-GPU:

-Waiting on ATI and NVIDIA to deliver drivers that have multi-gpu profile support for newly released titles in order to see any improvement with multi-gpu over single gpu.

-Micro-stutter (every odd numbered frame is very fast, i.e. 3ms, while every even numbered frame is much slower, so frametimes are lop-sided and while you get a higher reported framerate, the framerate functionally "feels" slower, defeating the purpose of increasing the framerate with multi-gpu in the first place)

-Corruption issues are more common with multi-gpu due to its' complexity in the drivers. Also, sometimes multi-gpu profiles are overly aggressive in their efforts to stop transfers between gpus (transfers hamper scaling) and they stop transfers which are required to generate a correct image.

-Multi-gpu has a fraction of the marketshare that single GPUs do, so single GPU issues are more likely to be fixed faster/have higher priority. So you probably get less priority support with multi-gpu.

-Often you get poor scaling with multi-GPU if a game is very CPU-bound (especially/typically at lower in-game settings) . Theres nothing you can do to change it.. it's just a fact of life. If a system can't spit out any more frames per second for GPUs to process because the CPU is bottlenecking it, all the GPU power in the world won't speed your game up. This means at lower resolutions multi-gpu is often pointless, and can actually slow your game down vs. single GPU due to some typical CPU overhead associated with multi-gpu (which is hidden at higher settings).
 
Thanks, lots of information. Very helpful.

IS this micro-stutter noticable in all games?
 
theres "the file drawer" problem with microstuttering.
no competent hardware reviewing website has ever run into it, so every time sli or crossfire is reviewed and works fine, no one specifically mentions how no microstuttering took place, ie, they put that information in a metaphorical file drawer.
this first and only site that mentioned microstuttering was some german site that reviewed a 3870x2, and jumped to conclusions.
 
Sigh, microstuttering is real. I've been particularly sensitive to it. The 3870x2 in quad was the worst configuration in terms of microstuttering, followed by 9800GX2 in quad. With the GT200 and 4870 GPUs microstuttering is barely noticable if at all, at least to me.

To the OP's question, a GTX 295 still uses SLI, still uses the same game profiles and AFR methods to scale performance. The big "drawback" to dual cards in SLI vs a single card-dual GPU configuration is the requirement of an SLI-compatible motherboard.
 
theres "the file drawer" problem with microstuttering.
no competent hardware reviewing website has ever run into it, so every time sli or crossfire is reviewed and works fine, no one specifically mentions how no microstuttering took place, ie, they put that information in a metaphorical file drawer.
this first and only site that mentioned microstuttering was some german site that reviewed a 3870x2, and jumped to conclusions.

It's not jumping to conclusions. Do a fraps run when you're CPU bound running SLI some time. You'll be shocked to see the sawtooth pattern from your own PC.

I myself have seen it in Call of Duty World at War on both ATI and NVIDIA hardware. It was varying by about 15ms (3ms, 18ms, 3ms, 18ms, etc). It should be known that this was VERY noticeable, which is how I thought to run fraps in the first place.. my framerate said it was running very high, but it felt pretty sluggish somehow.. because you definitely feel the slow frames, but technically it is processing all those frames, you just don't get to much of every other one.

It's a very real issue, though some are not as perceptive as others, and some might have their settings configured in a way that they don't run into it often.

I love how you basically attack the story of microstutter kind of illogically, without any real counter-evidence, and you needlessly crap on the source... it was just "some german site" (as if that has any relevance) that "jumped to conclusions". What other conclusion is there? When it's there it's there.
 
The big "drawback" to dual cards in SLI vs a single card-dual GPU configuration is the requirement of an SLI-compatible motherboard.

Note that this is true up until recently, where on most x58 motherboards, you can run SLI, Crossfire, or multi-gpu boards.
 
Note that this is true up until recently, where on most x58 motherboards, you can run SLI, Crossfire, or multi-gpu boards.

So you don't need a motherboard that supports SLI? :rolleyes: I didn't say you needed an nVidia chipset, but rather a board that supports SLI. There are a lot more boards that do not support SLI than do.
 
Back
Top