Six HDDs - Raid 0, 1, 5, or 10?

Seraphic

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 5, 2007
Messages
2,258
I have six hard-drivers in my system, three being WD6400AAKS and other three WD6401AALS. Due to the 2TB limit, I had being using three WD6401AALS in a raid0 and the other three WD6400AAKS in their own raid0. Works out well as total size for each raid comes out to just about 1.75TB. Used onboard ICH9R controller for six months now with zero issues and get around 290/310 mbits read/write per raid.

Had been using x32Vista, but moved to x64Vista ultimate few weeks ago. For my work, I do SD and HD video/audio recording and editing. So need speed and storage space. And noticed Vista gives you an option to format a partition using a vista only GPT when working with over 2TB.

The onboard ICH9R controller has Raid 0, 1, 5, or 10. What would you suggest?
 
i would suggest raid5, but how much space exactly do you need?
GPT will let you go over that 2TB limit.

how about raid0 for 2 drives and put the rest in raid5?
use the raid5 array for storage.
 
My one concern was mixing WD6400AAKS and WD6401AALS drivers in one raid.
In a raid 5, how much would four 640GB (596GB usable) net in total disk space?
 
What are you trying to accomplish? The different levels of RAID serve very different purposes...

RAID 0 is designed to split the load evenly across multiple drives.
RAID 1 is designed to mirror a drive for data protection.
RAID 10 is just a system using 1 and 0 to split the load while mirroring drives.
RAID 5 uses parity calculations to provide both load balancing and data protection.

If you want the fastest setup possible, put all the drives in RAID 0. This will split every disk access across the drives, essentially allowing it to handle different sections of the file simultaneously on the different disks. RAID 1 can provide 0-like speed increases on reads, since it can simultaneously read from the multiple copies on the different disks, but each write is duplicated across the disks so it's the same speed as writing it to a single disk. For RAID 10 you need at least 4 disks - two disks striped, plus two more to mirror those. With RAID 5, you'd have one disk of the three doing parity - you'd only get 2 drives' worth of space usable, but the accesses would be spread across 3 drives and you wouldn't lose data if one drive died.

I really don't know if you could use a 6400AAKS and a 6401AALS in the same RAID. It might even depend on the type of RAID. I don't think you'd want to mix the different speeds into a RAID 5 where everything is kind of working together all at once, but you might be able to pull it off in a RAID 1 where it's basically just making a backup copy. You might need to think of these as two different groups of three matching drives, as opposed to one group of six drives.
 
I don't think you are able to put all six drives into a raid0.
You need at one drive less then 2TB to install Windows Vista x64 too, don't you?
Never tried using all six drives in one raid, but I don't think it will show up if it is over 2TB when vista install asks you to select the install location.
 
Optimal Configurations:

RAID5 - 4+1P + Hot Spare (Odd Man Out drive.) - 5 * Capacity * 80% - 4 * Single Drive Performance
RAID6 - 4+2P - 4 * Capacity - 4 * Single Drive Performance
RAID0+1 and RAID10 - 3 + 3 - 3 * Capacity - 3 * Single Drive Performance

For all RAID configurations, set segment size to 64K or lower (when available), then use a Vista recovery CD and diskpart to create an aligned partition using the same block size as RAID segment size PRIOR to installing your OS.
 
Optimal Configurations:

RAID5 - 4+1P + Hot Spare (Odd Man Out drive.) - 5 * Capacity * 80% - 4 * Single Drive Performance
RAID6 - 4+2P - 4 * Capacity - 4 * Single Drive Performance
RAID0+1 and RAID10 - 3 + 3 - 3 * Capacity - 3 * Single Drive Performance

For all RAID configurations, set segment size to 64K or lower (when available), then use a Vista recovery CD and diskpart to create an aligned partition using the same block size as RAID segment size.
I would get another drive just for the OS.

Then I would chose the R10 option if I were you, because on the ich9 Raid5 sucks.
I had 4 of those WD6400aaks in R5 on my ich9r and I would get around 13MB/s writes...the reads were great, but writes would bring it to its knees.

If you need the space that R5 will give you over R10 then spend some money on a decent controller.
 
On onboard? No RAID, IMO, except for maybe RAID 1. If you want RAID 5's minimal storage overhead and redundancy, get a hardware RAID card.
 
Yeah, I missed the Matrix RAID. Matrix RAID isn't really RAID. It creates a file system overtop, which is why you can do things like half the disk RAID0 and the other half RAID1.
 
Back
Top