Silverlight is worthless

Parmenides

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
6,578
I'd say silverlight is going the way of the dinosaur (as if it hasn't already) when HTML5 becomes more mainstream when it comes to rich web experience. BUT I will be working on a web application project (.net), and I have the option of investing time into silverlight. I think that C#/MVC and jquery are a solid combo as far as .net web work goes, and in this case it is more then enough to handle the requirements of the project.

But (again) I have an option to use silverlight. The web application isn't going to be public, so concern over what plugins users have installed is a non-issue. (just make the workers who will use it install silverlight). I'm just wondering if it's worthwhile investing some time into learning something new.

BTW, the thread title was more to get some people to jump in and defend silverlight. I don't want any controversy, but just seeking some informative 2nd opinion that differs from what I already have. Trying to be open minded and see if there is some merit to using it with intra/extranet scenarios. And it's fun to learn new things. Still, I'm most likely to pass on using it I just don't want to piss on an opportunity no matter how (un)valuable it might seem. Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
BTW, the thread title was more to get some people to jump in and defend silverlight. I don't want any controversy, but just seeking some informative 2nd opinion that differs from what I already have.

...

Thoughts?

Troll much?
 
Silverlight is FAR from worthless. Microsoft has clearly shifted direction of Silverlight away from being a cross platform tool to one targeted to Microsoft platforms and clearly Microsoft it promoting HTML 5 as hard, maybe harder than anyone right now.

But HTML 5 still has a was to go and Silverlight is simply easier to develop on though for web projects you do need to consider HTML 5 these days. I'm working on Windows Phone development and I have to say, SL is just clean and elegant and fun. Something HTML 5 isn't though it is the cross platform tool of the day.

Right now there's a bit of a controversy going on with SL as the SL development community was taken aback by Microsoft's touting of HTML 5 and JavaScript as the development tools for the new Window 8 UI, however it looks like SL will be there as well but that won't be set in stone until the Build Conference in September, but it looks pretty certain from all of the insider talk going on that SL will be a tool for the new Windows 8 UI as well.

But even beyond that if you think Windows Phone has a future, and I think it does, learning SL for that might come in handy. On the HTML 5 front, I'm curious to see what kind of tooling Microsoft has in store for the next version of Visual Studio. Microsoft development tools are awesome these days, and if HTML 5 and JavaScript are going to be first class development tools for the new Windows 8 UI, there are probably going to be some VERY slick tools from Microsoft.
 
BTW, the thread title was more to get some people to jump in and defend silverlight. I don't want any controversy,
Then why did you cause it?

Silverlight has problems, but it's far from worthless.
 
BTW, the thread title was more to get some people to jump in and defend silverlight.

I am disappoint, I wanted a brawl not a discussion.

The points you made are valid; yes silver-light is largely alleviated by HTML5, but its dug itself into some niche markets so it wont go anywhere (its also a harder spec, there's no if(Webkit){...} --actually im not entirely certain of that, now I'm gonna have to boot up moonlight and see how it interprets my silverlight....)

but yeah, as a bewildered student, learning C# {WPF, Silverlight} has been fun and rewarding. Programming for Microsoft's pre-packaged playground is a dream. As for its usefulness... maybe not so much. Options are good, and if you've got some spare time and you like your other experiences in .net land, then you might as well, but if you have no interest in doing it I'd say your right, dig in deep to HTML 5 and there's very little you wont be able to get done with it.

my .02
 
but if you have no interest in doing it I'd say your right, dig in deep to HTML 5 and there's very little you wont be able to get done with it.

my .02

And there's very little you can't do with .Net and SL. Pre-packaged? Not really sure what that means. HTML 5 is less pre-packaged how?
 
And there's very little you can't do with .Net and SL. Pre-packaged? Not really sure what that means. HTML 5 is less pre-packaged how?

as I was trying to imply, I would argue HTML 5 functionality is a subset of silver-light functionality, and silver-light and .net were engineered where HTML 5 are sort've organic (ie: a standards clusterfuck).

edit: I also don't like the 20XX trend of "now this product whose name is two words is now oneword". I'll say silver-light till I die.

and what I meant by pre-packaged was almost directly the jitter, sorry if I was being mysterious. If your target doesn't have the jitter your boned. Silver-light is great in MS land but if you're not in MS land its out --lets just switch our whole intranet infrastructure to Winserver 2008, IIS, Silverlight, and give all our employees WP7's, not an easy pitch to your boss-- . HTML 5 is a best-effort everywhere.

A friend of mine is working on some BI report intranet presentation stuff, he really wanted to do it in silverlight simply because the output is exact, where-as the menu implementation he had in CSS looked completely different from browser to browser.
 
One thing Microsoft got right and immediately showed they were going in the right direction was full implementation of HTML5 into IE9.

Silverlight may have had SOME issues, but its not the same program now that it was a year ago. Give silverlight a little more credit, at least its not going the way Flash is!
 
Yous trollin'! :p

I have nothing against Silverlight, but I don't see the point investing time to do anything significant with it right now. If you have the latitude to select it and want to, do it I guess. It's no worse in that way than Flash, excluding platform support.
 
I've attended a couple of WP7 training events, and SL seems to be the focus for mobile dev at this point, but SL devs are taking the whole Win8/HTML5 thing out of context. They just don't like sharing the playground with other HTML/JS.
This was a good overview I read last night
link
 
Last edited:
I've attended a couple of WP7 training events, and SL seems to be the focus for mobile dev at this point, but SL devs are taking the whole Win8/HTML5 thing out of context. They just don't like sharing the playground with other HTML/JS.
This was a good overview I read last night
link

I completely agree. Microsoft simply needed to appeal to as many developers as they could as the new Windows 8 UI is going to require a whole new generation of programs to be written for Windows with an entirely different UI metaphor compared to pretty much everything. Its a new approach from the ground up as far as the UI is concerned and its going to take a LOT of manpower to get the apps written.

I do imagine that most higher end applications will continue to be developed with traditional tools, C++, C#, Silverlight etc. but the $.99 stuff in the new Marketplace will be heavily HTML 5 based.
 
Last edited:
.NET is quite nice in development segments where it's mostly used. C# and the > .NET 2.0 frameworks are some of the best things coming out of MS in the past decade.

It's why there has been so much uproar about the possibility of dropping it and other APIs in the new Win8 experience UI. I can't see how it would be completely dropped, but the front end programming might disappoint many people, while making others ridiculously happy.
 
.NET is quite nice in development segments where it's mostly used. C# and the > .NET 2.0 frameworks are some of the best things coming out of MS in the past decade.

It's why there has been so much uproar about the possibility of dropping it and other APIs in the new Win8 experience UI. I can't see how it would be completely dropped, but the front end programming might disappoint many people, while making others ridiculously happy.
I actually quite like the C# environment, and I like how fast I am able to 'prototype' apps ( and by this I mean get an internal tool up and running, then never touch it again ).

Developers just hate change, and I don't blame them. Having to change out languages introduces a lower productivity period while I acclimatize myself to the new environment. That said, I actually enjoy learning new things, if not trying to be productive while I do so.
 
Thanks guys, interesting. With a asp.net/C# background is silverlight easy enough to just jump in and run with it? (or walk with it)
 
Last edited:
I'd say no. Silverlight is a presentation markup language like HTML only more complex. It would be like thinking knowing JavaScript gives you a lot of insight into HTML. While obvisously related they are two completely different things.
 
Back
Top