Silverlight 5: Back from the Dead?

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Microsoft should code name the latest Silverlight launch Yo-Yo seeing how it has been up and down so many times. One day it is pronounced dead and the next has it reborn. Conflicting views and mixed messages on the status and uses of Silverlight leaves many developers confused.

Yesterday, just over a month later, Scott Guthrie announced the “Firestarter” launch of the new Silverlight 5 beta under the slogan “the future of Silverlight starts now”. So what’s going on?
 
Maybe this is finally a response to the Netflix tearing issue? The lack of a Silverlight hardware decoder has destroyed v-sync for anyone using less than Win7 or Vista Pro Aero. The entire Aero desktop has hardware sync and automatically fixes the video playback.. This whole up/downgrade mess happened riiight around Win7 launch time a couple years ago.
 
as far as web development is concerned, I don't think Silverlight ever registered on the radar, and I don't think it ever will either...

One has to even wonder why MS is even bothering
 
Maybe this is finally a response to the Netflix tearing issue? The lack of a Silverlight hardware decoder has destroyed v-sync for anyone using less than Win7 or Vista Pro Aero. The entire Aero desktop has hardware sync and automatically fixes the video playback.. This whole up/downgrade mess happened riiight around Win7 launch time a couple years ago.

I can't use netflix (not living in the US), but on my own Silverlight video projects, I never had any problems with that.
Netflix does implement video in Silverlight in a different way, so maybe that's why.

About the original topic, it seems only the news media though Silverlight is dead.
MS employees like scott guthrie posted immediately about that (here: http://weblogs.asp.net/scottgu/archive/2010/11/04/silverlight-questions.aspx).

For me as a Silverlight and .net developer, I never thought the news had any basis.
HTML5 is just a UI platform. Silverlight is so much more.
 
silverlight is also one of the key elements now in windows phone 7 app development.

personally i think silverlight will be better than flash as soon as they get hardware acceleration. god knows it doesnt crash anywhere near as much on both windows and the mac.
 
Maybe they should rename name it Zombielight. Zombies are popular right now, certainly more popular than Silverlight.
 
I guess that author overlooked that silverlight was never declared dead. the article stating it was a short while back was corrected the next day when Microsoft clearified its statement that was misunderstood. Silverlight is still just as alive as it had been.
 
I can't use netflix (not living in the US), but on my own Silverlight video projects, I never had any problems with that.
Netflix does implement video in Silverlight in a different way, so maybe that's why.

I saw in the press release right there in the first sentence "support for GPU-based graphics and video handling" which is exactly what is missing. There have been several news stories about the dominant position of Netflix recently. Many of the comments on those articles were angry users focused on the lost quality since the change to Silverlight. Even though Flash has had it forever, MS said XP hardware decoding wasn't possible in Silverlight, but Windows 7 would fix the problem.. Reminded me of the Daniel_K thing.
 
Which is to say I'm hopeful this fixes it, and if it does, I'm happy. Just it's been a long battle for me using Netflix on the XP machine..
 
I've never installed it, and I don't think I've ever visited a site that required Silverlight.
 
I had to remove silverlight, it was disabling the attachment function in Hotmail.
 
This is what happens with Microsoft tries to copy GoG's marketing strategy. We're gone. Thanks everyone for using our service. Its a shame, drm free apparently is a model which will never work..

*2 weeks later*

We're back! We were just kidding. The new future of Flashlight/GoG.com starts now!
 
Back
Top