Should I upgrade my videocard?

Prentice

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 1, 2007
Messages
209
I have a X1900XTX that is still pretty good on the games I play... The card can sale for around 150 easy which would make me pay around 50-70$ more for a 8800GT or 3870. Would it be a good idea to upgrade now or just wait for another year.

I mostly play CSS and TF2. I will be getting into Crysis and the other cool games once I read enough reviews to buy it hehe!
 
Depending on how important eyecandy is to you. I am sure your current card can run Crysis, but it probably won't look like it does in the promos.
 
x1800xt still handles crysis on a good 18~20 FPS 1280x1024 Most high to medium no AA no AF.

I don’t see WHY x1900xtx would struggle with crysis... but it depends what res u play your games on.

If its above 1280x1024... well even 1680x1050 crsysis should still be fine on your card... but if its higher then yeah, get yourself a new card.
 
I was also thinking of upgrading to the 8800GT from my 6600. My main concern is that the card is quiet, does anyone know if the 8800GT runs quietly? This, more than anything will determine what card I purchase.

By the way, I have been reading the forum forever, always finding good advice, but this is my first post.
 
I was also thinking of upgrading to the 8800GT from my 6600. My main concern is that the card is quiet, does anyone know if the 8800GT runs quietly? This, more than anything will determine what card I purchase.

By the way, I have been reading the forum forever, always finding good advice, but this is my first post.
The newer 8800 GT's are quieter, but still loud at 100% fan speed. You can use rivatuner though to program custom fan speeds.
 
I was also thinking of upgrading to the 8800GT from my 6600. My main concern is that the card is quiet, does anyone know if the 8800GT runs quietly? This, more than anything will determine what card I purchase.

By the way, I have been reading the forum forever, always finding good advice, but this is my first post.

How quiet is quiet? Are you talking mainstream, Tt "quiet"? SPCR quiet?
I have my RivaTuner maxing the fan out at 45% (which isn't that much). It's enough to hear over case fans/psu easily, as I'm running 7V and 620HX. OTOH, if it's not doing 3d loads, then you can't hear it (threshold is ~39% where it blends into ambient case noise). I have it running @ 34% minimum, which is at or below my AC64.

I consider the AC64 reasonably quiet, but that's just me. My AC64 isn't running @ 100% either tho...I think it's around 78% (or 1700RPM vs. standard 2100RPM). Whatever decibel level that is - is around what the 8800GT seems to be at idle for me.

*and to the guy playing TF2 - you'd gain more OCing your CPU, unless you're at a high-res. I barely gained anything at my default res (1280 or 1440 w/ no AA) since I'm extremely cpu-limited with an A64. But the minute I went to 1680 (with 4AA) the difference was considerable.
 
How quiet is quiet? Are you talking mainstream, Tt "quiet"? SPCR quiet?

I'm talking SPCR quiet. The people at GPUReview http://www.gpureview.com/GeForce-8800-GT-card-544.html give it a 9.4 silence rating, but as aldamon said in his reply, "That's subjective." I wouldn't mind hearing the fan occasionally, but for the most part, I don't want to know it's even there.

Would it be silent when I'm not doing anything graphically intense? Would any decently performing card, or am I being naive, unreasonable and annoying?
 
I'm talking SPCR quiet. The people at GPUReview http://www.gpureview.com/GeForce-8800-GT-card-544.html give it a 9.4 silence rating, but as aldamon said in his reply, "That's subjective." I wouldn't mind hearing the fan occasionally, but for the most part, I don't want to know it's even there.

Would it be silent when I'm not doing anything graphically intense? Would any decently performing card, or am I being naive, unreasonable and annoying?

It might be worth it to invest in an Accelero S1 - LINK

Good luck!
 
If you're talking SPCR quiet, an aftermarket cooler such as the Accelero really is your best bet. I lurk over there a fair bit, and when SPCR says quiet, they really mean silent.
 
I sold my X1950XTX for 202 Euro and within two weeks I got my new HD3870 @ 198Euro, never been happier.
 
I have a X1900XTX that is still pretty good on the games I play... The card can sale for around 150 easy which would make me pay around 50-70$ more for a 8800GT or 3870. Would it be a good idea to upgrade now or just wait for another year.

I mostly play CSS and TF2. I will be getting into Crysis and the other cool games once I read enough reviews to buy it hehe!
If you can actually sell it for $150 and upgrade it within $70 to a 8800GT(thats $220 after taxes?) I'd say go for it.
But speaking as an an ex-X1900XT owner till recently, the X1900XT(X) is still a strong performer, especially if its mainly for TF2 CSS it shouldn't be a problem at all.
Its always fun to jump between greater perfoemance cards so waiting for the next "8800GT type price/perfoemance deal" wouldn't hurt you.
 
I'm talking SPCR quiet. The people at GPUReview http://www.gpureview.com/GeForce-8800-GT-card-544.html give it a 9.4 silence rating, but as aldamon said in his reply, "That's subjective." I wouldn't mind hearing the fan occasionally, but for the most part, I don't want to know it's even there.

Would it be silent when I'm not doing anything graphically intense? Would any decently performing card, or am I being naive, unreasonable and annoying?

those ratings are crap. You don't even have to register to use em.
 
The asus En8800GT with the big fan is very Quiet. Its always run @ 100% and I cant hear it and its stays cold. Its a bit more pricey but its come with CoH
 
I went from a Sapphire X1950 XT to my HIS 3850 ICEQ3. In terms of noise, it's like day and night; the 3850 is almost silent even when my clockings are cranked in 3D mode. In terms of performance, I went from just above 6K score in 3DMark06 to 10.7K with the new card, everything else equal. Cooling is vastly superior, with 100C peaks on the old card, and 70C on the new one. 1920x1200 is finally playable so it's been completely worth the $230 from ncix.com that I spent for it.
 
Back
Top