Should I give EVGA another chance?

sawyer1

n00b
Joined
Jul 5, 2005
Messages
11
Hey guys,I'm in a dilemma here.I need an honest opinion on something.. please read on.

2008 wasn't a good year for me as far as computing is concerned. It may be hard to believe but I haven't been able to have a reliable or long term stable system!
that makes me sad and frustrated at the same time. I first started off with an Intel Q6600 evga 780i based build last january. system was fast and had awesome gaming performance compared to my previous build which was based on an asus a8n-sli deluxe and an amd 3500. all was fine till about two months later when the motherboard took a dump! rma'd the board received replacement and three months later poof dump again. rma'd and received a new board but I never used it. So at that point I was puzzled on what my next step was going to be. I decided to upgrade to an evga 790i sli ultra thinking that it would maybe be more reliable. carried over my Q6600 and purchased 4 gigs of ddr3 1800 mhz corsair ram. oce'd to 3.6 ghz with an evga 9800 gx2 @720/1800/1115. at this point I was really impressed by this board, but sadly it only lasted about 1 month(random restarts,bsods,lock ups during gaming the whole nine yards).returned to the egg for a new board and bam doa! I was like wow this is getting old. I wanted to give up on computers for a moment but I'm addicted! returned to newegg for a refund, I was so frustrated I took a break for about a month( its frustrating and stressful breaking apart and putting together a system and not getting anywhere!).knowing that evga is an awesome company because of the quality of their products and unbeatable customer service I gave them another try... purchased a third 790i ultra. oce'd to settings above and purchased three evga gtx 280's ftw and oce'd to 738/1512/1300! best system I ever built. stable as a rock. vantage score was like 28560.. awesome right? wrong board went bad again! turmoil! i gave up on nvidia
based boards and upgraded to the evga x58 with an 920 and 6 gigs of corsair ram
oce'd to 3.3 ghz all on auto settings.awesome! not so fast bios corrupted in about three weeks and in turn corrupted my vista 64 install. tried to fix the issue by flashing to SZ1B and boom FATALITY! killed my board. got a refund from the egg.

EVGA motherboards have not worked for me and its sad because I love evga products, but its hard to deny that their motherbords need alot of work.

My asus board is still running strong after four years of abuse with the amd 3500 and two evga g92 8800 gts's in sli. my buddy's system I built for him with an asus board three years ago is still alive!

sorry for the long post guys but I just needed to vent..

So the point to this post is get some recommendations on a non evga motherboard
or to get an opinion about giving evga another chance.
from my experience asus makes top notch boards but their customer service and rma system are horrible but I have never had to deal with them!


please help..

sawyer1
 
Sorry to hear about your unpleasant experience. EVGA has always been good to me; in both motherboards and GPU. I've never overclocked so I've never had a major problem.

You sure your overclocks were stable? Kind of sounds like they're not. Then again, I could be wrong.

IIRC, EVGA rebrand their boards from Foxconn which uses the reference design so that might be a reason why.
 
I can't comment on EVGA motherboards since I have had Gigabyte Intel based boards in my systems for years now with great success. Now I haven't done any overclocking on them since my P4 days but even when I did I wasn't killing hardware.

Sorry I don't mean to be rude but I almost have to think you getting a bit carried aways with the voltage adjustments or something to go through so many boards so fast.

Also surprised Newegg refunded more then one dead board that was overclocked. Did things change over at the egg in that regard?

Anyway the only suggestion I can offer is to buy a made by Intel board and be happy with a stable system at stock speeds.
 
What power supply with these builds?

first of all thank you all for the replies

I used two different power supplys in these builds.

silverstone DA1200 1200 Watt model
PC Power and Cooling silencer quad 750

both of these power supplys are fine and are not the culprit.I've had isues overclocked and not overclocked.
 
after having a 680i board kill many sticks of ram and a 7900gt that did not like vista I have moved on from evga. If their support was truly stellar I would have stayed with them but I saw no reason to and don't believe that I get the same love that everyone else here has gotten from evga in the past.

I have had more boards that I can remember and the only one I have had a problem with is an evga board. I know it maybe nvidia's fault, but the support that I got from evga made it not worth my time to deal with them any further.

So my recommendation is any board that is not an nvidia chipset that is mid to high end. I do not have any exp with low end MBs.
 
i <3 evga. well i have the 790i mobo w/ overclocked cpu and never had any probs. well im sorry to hear your story though. but give it another chance!!
 
maybe it was your memory? It's hard for me to believe that so many motherboards were the suspect. perhaps memory was at fault?
 
I have had good luck with EVGA. My north bridge fan started whining so they sent me a new fan for free. Well it was the wrong fan so they sent me 2 more fans until they got it right.

You can't argue with a lifetime warranty, especially considering after 2 years or so the card you get back is much newer than what you send in.

My current EVGA board has a dead USB port on it though. The board is about 8 months old. However, the majority of problems is Nvidia chipsets, not the board manufacturers. I'm glad Nvidia is not making motherboard chipsets anymore.
 
Back
Top