shortened aluminium sg05

pchacker

n00b
Joined
Mar 16, 2011
Messages
23
Would silverstone sue me if I took the essential sg05 design shortened the height by a few centimeters ( about 3 or 4) and made it aluminium, then produced it on a small scale for sale?
 
Looks like the myth about SilverStone holding the patent on 90 degree cases and waiting to pounce on anyone making the same design is spilling over to include other designs now? :)

The SG05's basic layout is a derived/downsized version of SG01 MIcro-ATX case launched in 2005. Which itself was inspired by Falcon Northwest's Fragbox 2 launched in 2004. There have been many variations of this design built by not just SilverStone, but by many others since then. So no, I don't think anyone will have a problem with what you wanted to do.
 
Lol didn't know the 90 degree patent was a myth. Waiting for the Ft05 to come to the U.S.!
 
Would silverstone sue me if I took the essential sg05 design shortened the height by a few centimeters ( about 3 or 4) and made it aluminium, then produced it on a small scale for sale?
I think the most you'd want to take off the SG05 design is 20mm, and even that's pushing it. You need the height for the PCIe power connectors, and for example in the M1 which is 160mm wide, they can still be a little tight. I personally wouldn't go below that, but you could get away with 155mm, or maybe 150mm if oriented like the SG05 and allowing the PCI bracket to stick out from the bottom of the case a little.

Looks like the myth about SilverStone holding the patent on 90 degree cases and waiting to pounce on anyone making the same design is spilling over to include other designs now? :)
Well, you didn't exactly try to dispel that myth :p So are you saying you wouldn't attempt to enforce it now?

Come to think of it, LL has the PC-Q30 now, which has a vertical-ish motherboard orientation. As do the IN WIN D-Frame chassis.
 
The myth is that Silverstone would sue anyone who dares to turn their motherboard.

However there is a Silverstone patent for the 90 degrees. Wahaha360 linked it I think; it describes the method of design and production of a case with the motherboard mounting upwards, which is different to the Intel / Formfactors spec. But as far as I'm aware it only applies in Taiwan. It's one of the few countries that isn't a member of WIPO, so the patent protection doesn't automatically extend to the rest of the world.


I'm not a patent lawyer and don't speak Chinese so could be wrong about some of that ;)
 
Looks like the myth about SilverStone holding the patent on 90 degree cases and waiting to pounce on anyone making the same design is spilling over to include other designs now? :)

The SG05's basic layout is a derived/downsized version of SG01 MIcro-ATX case launched in 2005. Which itself was inspired by Falcon Northwest's Fragbox 2 launched in 2004. There have been many variations of this design built by not just SilverStone, but by many others since then. So no, I don't think anyone will have a problem with what you wanted to do.

ok thanks that's good to know, back to cad mockups then.
 
Back
Top