SFPD Accompanied Apple Security on ‘Raid’

Morality is relative, the law is not. whatever my personal opinion or your is on the number of people in jail on minor drug charges, it doesn't change the law.

claiming Hemp is illegal because it would harm the cotton and paper industries? that's pulling a Woody Harrelson! Hemp is Illegal because it is a socially unacceptable mind altering substance that is perceived to be dangerous. anything else at this time is not applicable, even if there are claims for that being why it was banned originally.

Implying your a moral crusader because "The Man" is oppressing your right to get stoned doesn't carry much weight with society I am afraid...

replace Hemp, with "weed" Hemp per se, is not the same anymore as the THC producing "Weed", but might as well be in the minds eye of the public.
 
I know the evidence and argument is overwhelming. I did some research a while back. My mom is a huge advocate of just the hemp products that could benefit everyone. This is a touchy subject with me though. I have delved into unproductive forum conversation before with much less intelligent and informed people so I appreciate your candor.

To completely derail the original subject, I almost want to exclude marijuana in my thought of drugs. I have been pretty convinced in the past already about its benefits pretty much outweighing the almost non existent downsides. I am sure you could write at length the reasons it isn't legal and I know my state is trying to legalize it every so often and in some capacities it is. Is that why there isn't more of an effort to legalize and just to discretely use? I don't want to open a can of worms.

For the same reason it was illegal to buy a beer in this country during prohibition. until people stop equating personal religious freedom with carte blanche to dictate morals to the rest of the country, the jails in this country will remain full of people that decided that getting stoned, or selling to stoners was worth the risk of getting caught.
 
@Moto, it is our job to change unjust laws that are based on nothing not just blindly follow them.

In our country's history alone it was illegal to free slaves, illegal for women to vote, illegal to have a glass of wine. In many other countries it is illegal for women to drive or get an education.

As I quoted already. "Do what's right and let the law catch up." Justice Thurgood Marshall.
 
@Moto, it is our job to change unjust laws that are based on nothing not just blindly follow them.

In our country's history alone it was illegal to free slaves, illegal for women to vote, illegal to have a glass of wine. In many other countries it is illegal for women to drive or get an education.

As I quoted already. "Do what's right and let the law catch up." Justice Thurgood Marshall.

To be honest, the whole legalize weed movement bothers me. For all intents and purposes, the vast majority of proponents merely want to get high. Now, I fully support their right to get as high as they want to, but I'd rather those efforts be focused on regaining personal liberty across the table rather than a single, largely inconsequential drug.

(Keep in mind, I've never once used recreational drugs)
 
Or the 4 cops can simply say... "the owner gave us permission to search, I have 3 other police officers who can testify to that"

Yep.

People don't understand. Even what we consider honest cops are under enormous pressure. They'll stretch the law to its very limit to try and catch the bad guy. They love coming up against a moron who will unknowingly waive their rights because they can get the job done and get home to their families more quickly.

If a cop shows up at your door without a warrant, you don't even open the door. If they want to ask you some questions, you refuse. It's really simple. You don't even have to talk to the police after being arrested. Why would you talk to them BEFORE? You can only talk your way INTO an arrest or further investigation, not out of one, so why talk at all?
 
To be honest, the whole legalize weed movement bothers me. For all intents and purposes, the vast majority of proponents merely want to get high. Now, I fully support their right to get as high as they want to, but I'd rather those efforts be focused on regaining personal liberty across the table rather than a single, largely inconsequential drug.

(Keep in mind, I've never once used recreational drugs)

There is a much larger issue that the MJ issue has brought to light and that is the States rights to make and enforce their own laws. The feds continue to crack down on what are legal operations at the State level.
 
"Mr. Madison, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I've ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response was there anything that could even be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul."

Really? Then explain the video I saw on some website from a person who used to be a cop and is now a security adviser telling people to never say a word to the police when questioned until you have a lawyer. Anything you say can and may be used against you.
 
There is a much larger issue that the MJ issue has brought to light and that is the States rights to make and enforce their own laws. The feds continue to crack down on what are legal operations at the State level.

we already fought one war about states rights.... the prize? we abolished slavery nearly as a side effect, but it was still about the states telling the Feds to go screw themselves.

truly a huge issue. If one state can legalize pot, then why can't another pass restrictive immigration laws?
 
we already fought one war about states rights.... the prize? we abolished slavery nearly as a side effect, but it was still about the states telling the Feds to go screw themselves.

truly a huge issue. If one state can legalize pot, then why can't another pass restrictive immigration laws?

In my book, the state should be able to.
 
I've recently won two cases because I didn't even answer the door and the cops eventually came in with no warrant and the evidence got tossed. The judge didn't even leave his bench to consider, he ruled immediately and we won the motion to suppress.

It was appealed by the State and we won in the State Appeals Court as well.

NEVER OPEN YOUR DOOR, if they have a warrant they will just kick your door in so opening the door does NOTHING for you.
This has already changed since your cases and the ability to depend on evidence being tossed will deteriorate even more in the near future.

Aside from that, if the police have cause to be there demanding that they secure a warrant will result in...them obtaining a warrant on your doorstep and then coming inside. It's not like they have to go to the courthouse and process a bunch of paperwork to secure a warranted search of the premises.

I don't disagree with people standing up for their rights, just make sure you know what you're fighting for and whether it's worth it. Some people believe it's worth it in the abstract but that may not be true for everyone.
 
Sounds like Apple just hired them for security, how is this any better then the original story. Apple still acted outside of the law. It's justified because Apple security had police on sceen? This story reeks of another viral ad scam. How could a corporation allow the same thing to happen twice and in the exact same way. I think they may have allowed it to go missing. It does create a lot of press and keeps iPhone in the headlines with no money going out.
 
I hope the guy that they searched really had it and sold it for a nice chunk of money.
 
This has already changed since your cases and the ability to depend on evidence being tossed will deteriorate even more in the near future.

Aside from that, if the police have cause to be there demanding that they secure a warrant will result in...them obtaining a warrant on your doorstep and then coming inside. It's not like they have to go to the courthouse and process a bunch of paperwork to secure a warranted search of the premises.

I don't disagree with people standing up for their rights, just make sure you know what you're fighting for and whether it's worth it. Some people believe it's worth it in the abstract but that may not be true for everyone.

You don't have to answer the door, hell you can wave at them from the window and never speak a word to them. If you do get a visit from anyone wearing a badge, call the responding office and ask for details for the visit, they have to tell you why they are there and is totally legal.

It seems that most people are afraid to ask for anything. For instance a cop's radar gun has to be calibrated and it has a log sheet the officer needs to keep with them. If you ask for it they will probably give it to you, but they don't have to. I got pulled over for doing 80 in a 75, officer claimed I was going 90, asked to see the sheet got denied, went to court and asked for the calibration schedule. When it wasn't produced my ticket got thrown out, and that took a whole 20minutes in court and 3 hours of waiting to do!

The cop never got his gun calibrated in the end. So its always good to arm yourself with as much info as possible, and express your rights.
 
What about the statement from the victim of the raid that the officers threatened the immigration status of his relatives ? That may well have been why he allowed the search,knowing he didn't have the phone. It's just the kind of Gestapo tactics I'd expect from "Apple Security" and their ilk.
 
You don't have to answer the door, hell you can wave at them from the window and never speak a word to them. If you do get a visit from anyone wearing a badge, call the responding office and ask for details for the visit, they have to tell you why they are there and is totally legal.

It seems that most people are afraid to ask for anything. For instance a cop's radar gun has to be calibrated and it has a log sheet the officer needs to keep with them. If you ask for it they will probably give it to you, but they don't have to. I got pulled over for doing 80 in a 75, officer claimed I was going 90, asked to see the sheet got denied, went to court and asked for the calibration schedule. When it wasn't produced my ticket got thrown out, and that took a whole 20minutes in court and 3 hours of waiting to do!

The cop never got his gun calibrated in the end. So its always good to arm yourself with as much info as possible, and express your rights.
That's all well and good but it doesn't relate to anything I wrote so I'm not sure why you're quoting me.

Suppressing evidence due to warrantless searches is quickly eroding so don't count on it. Waving a cop from your window, shutting the door in their faces, asking for radar logs, all of that is well and good and in many cases may even be your right to do. Just keep in mind that if you piss them off enough they have the ability to wreck your life and in many cases physically harm you without consequence.

I have permanent nerve damage in my left hand from exerting my rights. My friend currently has two broken hands from not answering questions. I've seen worse. Advocating theoretical rights on an internet board is one thing, but practically consider what your'e fighting for and choose your battles because it's literally your life at stake when you start pissing cops off.
 
That's all well and good but it doesn't relate to anything I wrote so I'm not sure why you're quoting me.

Suppressing evidence due to warrantless searches is quickly eroding so don't count on it. Waving a cop from your window, shutting the door in their faces, asking for radar logs, all of that is well and good and in many cases may even be your right to do. Just keep in mind that if you piss them off enough they have the ability to wreck your life and in many cases physically harm you without consequence.

I have permanent nerve damage in my left hand from exerting my rights. My friend currently has two broken hands from not answering questions. I've seen worse. Advocating theoretical rights on an internet board is one thing, but practically consider what your'e fighting for and choose your battles because it's literally your life at stake when you start pissing cops off.

I don't know what third world country you live in, but in the US the police don't generally break your hands for not answering questions. You were probably drunk and belligerent and got what was coming to you. There's the rare case of a cop going batshit, but that's the exception. Most cops are honest hard-working individuals who are just doing their job. Your part of keeping them honest is to hold them to the letter of the law, and not give them any shortcuts they can use against you.

Spreading some bullshit stories about "You better do everything the police say or they'll beat you." is despicable.

Your ridiculous assertion that the police are just going around beating information out of people is so far beyond reason that I wonder why you'd ever bother participating in a discussion.
 
I didn't write you better do whatever the police say or they'll beat you nor did I write my hands were broken.

But you better believe that if you piss the cops off they can wreck your day, including beating you. The "third world country" I live in is Southern California and beatings and even death are not so rare in the LA county jail and OC jails that you can google all the information you want instead of trying to insult me.

Although I will say that your statement that I'm spreading bullshit seems to contradict your point that it'd be ok for them to literally ratchet down the cuffs on a belligerent teenager, sober or not, until it causes pain and/or damage to the arrestee. You think that's ok? Apparently if I'm drunk it's ok for the cops to beat me since I'm just getting what I have coming to me but me warning people that if they're belligerent they may be beaten is spreading bullshit? You should probably make up your mind as to what your position is because apparently you're confused.
 
You don't have to answer the door, hell you can wave at them from the window and never speak a word to them. If you do get a visit from anyone wearing a badge, call the responding office and ask for details for the visit, they have to tell you why they are there and is totally legal.

I've watched quite a few cop shows/movies and in each one, the guy tosses the guy who opened the door a search warrant and they'll be scavenging the inside of the house before he's even unfolded it.

Only once did i see a guy tell the officer to wait, and then called the precinct confirming the warrant and even checked if the description matches the guy at the door. Only then did he let them in.

Can you actually do the latter? Were the cop shows wrong?
 
@mope, not sure if you read this whole thread but I explained my most recent case in pretty good detail.

Judges are getting really pissed at law enforcement for by passing the judicial branch. If you read the most current US Supreme Court 4th Amendment case, Kentucky v. King, you'll see the Supreme Court has no plans to further erode the 4th.

Exigent circumstances and inevitable discovery are two exceptions. But here's the thing, the officers MUST have already been in the process of getting a warrant prior to acting on exigency.

And whoever said it was easy to get a warrant... no it ain't. It took them four separate write ups and several different judges over a period of about four hours to get a warrant in my most current case - and they were already in my house!

My whole case, including what happened in the appeals court is online. I will glady let all the doubters read it for themselves and then tell me what judges think

We have three branches of gov't for a reason...
 
Officers do not have to be in the process of obtaining a warrant to act upon exigent circumstances. If you want to claim otherwise, cite the relevant authorities.

And while you're at it, explain to me how you interpret Kentucky v. King to support your argument. Your position directly contradicts the position of the Court (an 8-1 decision).

I said it's simple to obtain a warrant and it is. Your case, a sample size of one, is hardly sufficient evidence to be claiming otherwise. Nonetheless, I'll read over your filings. Post the citation...I'm not sure why you didn't in the body of your argument if you were going to offer it.

Since LexisNexis is not public, I can't post summaries here. I'll use this site instead: http://www.fourthamendmentsummaries.com/cases/post_2000_cases.html
You'll see the same general trend of degrading 4th amendment protections for the past few decades--particularly in response to drug offenses (i.e., the war on drugs). Protections will further erode now that the so-called war on drugs has been folded into a war on terror and multiple agencies have been folded under the umbrella DHS.
 
Comparing the two stories it seems like somebody at Apple called in a "request" for the police to change their story and prevent a lawsuit or more probably just mitigate the potential damage from one.

That's exactly what I thought. First, the SFPD says they have "no knowledge" of officers at that location or of a search, and now all of a sudden they do?

I'm guessing some cash-ola switched hands in here somewhere. :rolleyes:
 
I've watched quite a few cop shows/movies and in each one, the guy tosses the guy who opened the door a search warrant and they'll be scavenging the inside of the house before he's even unfolded it.

Only once did i see a guy tell the officer to wait, and then called the precinct confirming the warrant and even checked if the description matches the guy at the door. Only then did he let them in.

Can you actually do the latter? Were the cop shows wrong?

The cop shows cut out a lot of the "waiting" and get to the nitty gritty. If the cop has a warrant they don't actually have permission till you say they can enter, you can't actually say they "can not step foot on your premise" but you can confirm it with a phone call, which honestly takes 5 minutes. You don't have to say a word to them but the moment you hear any official saying they have a warrant to search your property and it is confirmed you are SOL.

You can fight for the conditions in which the warrant was issued which will be a losing battle, its a no win situation honestly. But you can stall them and make them do their job by waiting while you do your job as a citizen protecting your rights, wrong or no wrong doing.

Any lawyer will tell you its a good idea to confirm a warrant, an officer will most likely get a slap on the wrist or a small suspention (may be going harsher soon) for showing a document and "hinting" its a warrant. If the document is not a warrant you can still not let them in and do not let them in. If a cop has no business at your place theres no reason to let them be at your place.

Also I support my local police, I know a few and respect them greatly. I rarely hear anyone one of them complain about the job or bring their job into personal conversations.
 
While you are confirming how ever, the COP has every right to search the premise, thats if the warrant is good. IF the warrant is not good and you tell them they don't have permission to the search your personal belongings anything found afterwards is not permissable in court.

Cops have a lot of rights to search premises, but at the same time what they decide to "hook" you on is very limited. You have a decent amount of laws protecting your privacy which in the end if you are ever harrassed are very protected.
 
I didn't write you better do whatever the police say or they'll beat you nor did I write my hands were broken.

But you better believe that if you piss the cops off they can wreck your day, including beating you. The "third world country" I live in is Southern California and beatings and even death are not so rare in the LA county jail and OC jails that you can google all the information you want instead of trying to insult me.

Although I will say that your statement that I'm spreading bullshit seems to contradict your point that it'd be ok for them to literally ratchet down the cuffs on a belligerent teenager, sober or not, until it causes pain and/or damage to the arrestee. You think that's ok? Apparently if I'm drunk it's ok for the cops to beat me since I'm just getting what I have coming to me but me warning people that if they're belligerent they may be beaten is spreading bullshit? You should probably make up your mind as to what your position is because apparently you're confused.

Well I was quoting you because you didn't seem to confirm the warrant. The police can pose as much as they want with very very very little outcome in the end for them. For you, protecting your privacy is number 1. A cop is not your best friend, they are their to uphold the law and do the bidding of their superiors, but they can only act as far as the court can let them, which is governed by state and federal laws. Confirming is your right and the cop HAS to wait till it is confirmed, if you are going to resist the warrant the cop can knock down your door or anyway he/she sees fit to enter your house hold.

I'm sorry what happened to your hands, but if a cop un justifiably came in contact with you and caused unnecessary damage such as this its very much in your right to get compensation. A cop can only engage in a "perp" as much as the situation justifies. Also in court, the word of a civilian is held greater then the word of a cop, but the argument can go stale and forgotten, so it depends on how hard you want to fight it.

Cops are very unprotected by laws, but certain judges will protect cops in certain places. If the place happens to be in a somewhat lawful area the judge probably doesn't care or have any willing to stick up for anyone honestly... but in an unlawful area (gang land) the judge will always stick up for the police (causing corruption in the police!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

really though if you did come out of this with physical long term injuries caused by any federal employee I would get a lawyer fast.
 
I don't have memorized the numbers of people processed through the criminal justice system on a daily basis, nor do I know offhand the amount of people interacting with the police. But I do know we have roughly 350 million people in the US and we have 2 million people on active supervision (prisons, jails, and probation/parole). That means that roughly 1 out of every 175 people in the US currently live under 4th amendment waivers.

Two things: 1) you really need to be careful about dispensing inaccurate advice--especially advise that can result in someone's death (such as suggestion that police conducing a warrant search don't have the right to search something until you give them permission)

and 2) citizens should not assume they have a "decent amount of laws protecting [their] privacy" or that they are "very protected" from searches and seizures.

I provided a link to a slew of cases that are segmented by decade: 2000, 1990, 1980, and etc. demonstrating that 4th amendment rights are being eroded by the Court. For a more informed opinion, I suggest anyone interested read the history of the warrant and why it became necessary. I suspect many of you would be surprised to learn that our warrant requirement came about as a function to protect the police, not the citizenry. If you want to read a great synopsis, and one that would line up with a number of members' interests on this board (law and cyberspace), read Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace by Lawrence Lessig. http://www.amazon.com/Code-Other-Cyberspace-Lawrence-Lessig/dp/0465039138
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Apple is big business at it's worst. This time they crossed the line.

I smell lawsuit for unlawful search and seizure.
 
Officers do not have to be in the process of obtaining a warrant to act upon exigent circumstances. If you want to claim otherwise, cite the relevant authorities.

And while you're at it, explain to me how you interpret Kentucky v. King to support your argument. Your position directly contradicts the position of the Court (an 8-1 decision).

I said it's simple to obtain a warrant and it is. Your case, a sample size of one, is hardly sufficient evidence to be claiming otherwise. Nonetheless, I'll read over your filings. Post the citation...I'm not sure why you didn't in the body of your argument if you were going to offer it.

Since LexisNexis is not public, I can't post summaries here. I'll use this site instead: http://www.fourthamendmentsummaries.com/cases/post_2000_cases.html
You'll see the same general trend of degrading 4th amendment protections for the past few decades--particularly in response to drug offenses (i.e., the war on drugs). Protections will further erode now that the so-called war on drugs has been folded into a war on terror and multiple agencies have been folded under the umbrella DHS.

Did you read the reasons behind the 8-1 ruling, or listen to the oral arguments? The case was returned to the Kentucky Supreme Court (who ruled in favor of the defendants btw) in order for them to come up with a way the US Supreme Court to give a yes/no answer. In the body of the case the judges all seem to agree that they essentially agree with the Ky Court but couldn't rule on their side because of the way they presented their case. More of a technical ruling then a meaningful one.

Here is a link to my (still not technically resolved case yet) http://myclerk.myorangeclerk.com/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=6313110

It looks like a four year old did the transcribing but you can scroll down to the all caps judges ruling in the case.

In Florida you do need to be in the process of obtaining a search warrant for 'inevitable discovery' not 'exigency' that was a mistake.

The 5DCA court stuff is rather boring in comparison. http://199.242.69.70/pls/ds/ds_docket_search?pscourt=5
Put in 5D-09-3739
 
Back
Top