SF Cracks Down On ‘Monkey Parking’ Mobile App

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
There is a "spank the monkey" joke in here somewhere.

Using an iPhone application to auction off your street parking space to someone circling the block might sound tailor-made for a tech-savvy, parking-space-starved, high-cost-of-living city like San Francisco. It might, except it’s illegal.
 
Just like with those Uber services and the like, the only reason its illegal is because its taking money out of the coffers of influential groups that bought off legislators. Yet for some reason we tolerate it.
 
Actually the reason why it is illegal is because YOU DON'T OWN A STREET PARKING PLACE. It's not saying you can't rent your garage or driveway space (if you have one) but the actual public street you do not own. I actually like this, it saves people saving spaces just for the sake of saving spaces, there's not enough parking in this city as it stands.
 
SF parking is terrible enough that a handicap advocacy group actually proposed removing any benefits placard holders have in parking at metered spots for free. Bunch of cheating bastards apply and its too hard to actually enforce if they're legitimately disabled or not - how is a random street cop supposed to override a doctor?
 
Heard of that app, but not the other 2...wow, one is offering $13/hour for people to drive around and snatch parking spaces just to then resell. Blech.
 
All they have to do is re-word their EULA.

You are NOT paying for the parking space, you are paying for my time in informing you that I am leaving. If you are here when I pull out then you've been informed. If you are not here when I pull out of the parking space, it of course goes to whomever happens up the spot. No refunds"

Something like that.
 
SF parking is terrible enough that a handicap advocacy group actually proposed removing any benefits placard holders have in parking at metered spots for free. Bunch of cheating bastards apply and its too hard to actually enforce if they're legitimately disabled or not - how is a random street cop supposed to override a doctor?

oh? I wouldn't think handicap advocacy groups would want to give up their rights like that. That said, I personally think it's complete bullshit that a handicap placard gives you the right to park for free while everyone else has to pay. I mean yeah ok you got a handicap parking spot, sure but free parking? Fuck that.
 
That said, I personally think it's complete bullshit that a handicap placard gives you the right to park for free while everyone else has to pay. I mean yeah ok you got a handicap parking spot, sure but free parking?
When I worked in downtown L.A., you'd see 90% of the street parking taken up by cars with handicap placards. They not only got to park for free, they got to park there all day long with no time restrictions. :mad:
 
All they have to do is re-word their EULA.

You are NOT paying for the parking space, you are paying for my time in informing you that I am leaving. If you are here when I pull out then you've been informed. If you are not here when I pull out of the parking space, it of course goes to whomever happens up the spot. No refunds"

Something like that.

Pretty much. I don't see how this is enforceable. They sent a C&D to this company, but the company is based in Rome. Last time I checked, the SF city attorney didn't have jurisdiction in Rome.

My guess? They ignore it. The burden will fall onto SF city to enforce this policy, thus they will have to have their parking enforcement use the app and then give citations to anyone who posts a parking spot.

BTW, wasn't this app parodied in the Amazon show "Betas"?
 
I dont see how people can snipe parking spots all day because as soon as they sell their spot, they have to leave. So now where do they go? All the other spots are taken right? I suppose they could buy low and sell high, but this seems like a lot of work. As far as I'm concerned if you know you landed a really good spot and are about to leave and feel like updating some cloud network with your location to make a few extra bucks, why not? In a place like SF I would gladly pay 5 bucks to get a great spot. If I dont pay it then I drive around aimlessly like I would be anyway, nothing changes.
 
Just like with those Uber services and the like, the only reason its illegal is because its taking money out of the coffers of influential groups that bought off legislators. Yet for some reason we tolerate it.

Your head is either stuck under the sand, or way above in the clouds for suggesting that private individuals are allowed to double-dip on the infrastructure that you and I paid to use out of our municipal taxes.

Before you say how that I proved you right, let me rudely remind you that municipalities aren't influential groups and are nothing to the eyes of the legislators and lobbyists.
 
All they have to do is re-word their EULA.

You are NOT paying for the parking space, you are paying for my time in informing you that I am leaving. If you are here when I pull out then you've been informed. If you are not here when I pull out of the parking space, it of course goes to whomever happens up the spot. No refunds"

Something like that.
I was just going to say that. you're not paying for the spot you're being paid for letting someone know when you are leaving. selling information is perfectly legal.
 
How is that possibly illegal?

You are selling INFORMATION about the fact you are parked at X, and are leaving, so the space will be empty. You are NOT selling the street. And the City gets paid regardless at the PARKING METER..... and ticket and tow trucks.

So FUCK YOU SF, you don't have a leg to stand on, best of luck and if you bother that business they will SUE the living shit out of you for Defamation, restraint of trade, tortuous interference, etc, etc ... and make $MILLION$ off the tax payer when your shitheaded moron of a City Atty learns from the court that the City's actions were themselves ILLEGAL.

See, it is not just redneck southern morons who are literally beyond stupid. Esp the ones with alleged Law degree's.
 
When I worked in downtown L.A., you'd see 90% of the street parking taken up by cars with handicap placards. They not only got to park for free, they got to park there all day long with no time restrictions. :mad:
What logic do they use that a person on crutches or a wheelchair shouldn't have to pay for their parking like someone that can walk well?

And for that matter, I find it rediculous who they consider "handicapped" these days. You go to your doctor and say doc I have back spasms, really killing me, and now voila you are handicapped. Or you say oh doc my knees are killing me totally inflamed, and whamo you are handicapped... of course they fail to mention that the reason behind it is obesity, and that light execise such as WALKING is very healthy. We have a guy here at our office that parks his C6 in the handicapped spot by the door and he has the hanger, but he doesn't use a cane, and fuck if you can get IN AND OUT of a Corvette (not easy), you can park just like the rest of us.

But this is liberal San Francisco with ueber victim-culture, so I imagine its ten times worse than even here.
 
Actually the reason why it is illegal is because YOU DON'T OWN A STREET PARKING PLACE. It's not saying you can't rent your garage or driveway space (if you have one) but the actual public street you do not own. I actually like this, it saves people saving spaces just for the sake of saving spaces, there's not enough parking in this city as it stands.
I actually thought it was for selling the parking spot by your house; need to lern2reed. As recently they were telling home owners they couldn't even rent out rooms in their house for major events because the hotel industry that loved gouging people pressured legistlators, and in the case of the social media services for sharing rides the unionized cabbies bitched.

But even so, they aren't selling a parking spot, they are selling information that they are leaving their parking spot soon. The new guy would still refill the meter, and it could be a valuable service as this way you don't have to drive for 15 mins looking for a spot as you can see on your GPS exactly where spots are opening up. The only way for that to work is if the person leaving the spot is rewarded for their effort.

They have something similar at some grocery store chains which I HIGHLY appreciate, where you basically rent your grocery cart and you get the money back if you bring it back and check it back in. That way when the wind blows you don't have ten grocery carts drifting through the parking lot denting up cars or using up spots, but the only way to make that work is a financial incentive for returning it. There will be some people that just leave it out anyway, but I'm sure the next person parking their car nearby will grab that cart so they get the 75 cents return reimbursement.

TL;DR: Paying for information is hardly illegal, and information can benefit the community.
 
They have something similar at some grocery store chains which I HIGHLY appreciate, where you basically rent your grocery cart and you get the money back if you bring it back and check it back in. That way when the wind blows you don't have ten grocery carts drifting through the parking lot denting up cars or using up spots, but the only way to make that work is a financial incentive for returning it. There will be some people that just leave it out anyway, but I'm sure the next person parking their car nearby will grab that cart so they get the 75 cents return reimbursement.

That is not remotely comparable.



I see this service/app or w/e you want to call it bad if you get a bunch of a-holes just sitting on good spots waiting for the highest bidder. That's when its crossing the line of passing off information to actually selling off public space.
 
When I worked in downtown L.A., you'd see 90% of the street parking taken up by cars with handicap placards. They not only got to park for free, they got to park there all day long with no time restrictions. :mad:
Technically they're not supposed to park all day, they're only supposed to park the maximum meter time and must move, however meterbitches don't often enforce that because that would require them to somehow remember which cars were where at a certain time. I was actually surprised to find out that handicap = free parking was a California state thing. But it is abused so much, with being able to buy handicap placards online, at flea markets, borrow your neighbors, use the one you legally got to ferry your old mom around even though she's not with you at the time. Scam


But even so, they aren't selling a parking spot, they are selling information that they are leaving their parking spot soon.
Yeah except that's hardly how it work, "oh I'm leaving in 5 minutes, here's my spot... anyone anyone?" more like "ah some guy got my spot, oops someone waiting for me to leave *text* shit that guy is not the person who paid for 'my information' I'll wave him by and wait until the other guy gets here" and you know people might snipe out spots just for the sake of selling them at critical times. Although, as expensive as parking it's not $5-20 expensive unless you're going to be there all day, and technically if it's a metered spot you can only be there the maximum time that you can fill the meter up once (you are legally not allowed to refill meters).

So FUCK YOU SF, you don't have a leg to stand on, best of luck and if you bother that business they will SUE the living shit out of you for Defamation, restraint of trade, tortuous interference, etc, etc ... and make $MILLION$ off the tax payer when your shitheaded moron of a City Atty learns from the court that the City's actions were themselves ILLEGAL.
Yeah except that's a fairy tale dream world you live in, defamation? no. restraint of trade? nope since it's a restraining order that an actual JUDGE approves, tortuous interference, keep dreaming... hell you actually sound like a lawyer who's just trying to make stuff up so that something will stick. Besides they only sent a letter that said cease and desist, there's nothing illegal about doing that either. ;)
 
They have something similar at some grocery store chains which I HIGHLY appreciate, where you basically rent your grocery cart and you get the money back if you bring it back and check it back in.
Oh and this is hardly something similar ;)

We had that for a while here, there were chains that attached each cart to one another, you put a quarter in the cart ahead of you and it released the chain allowing you to take a cart. Return the cart, plug the chain back in and the quarter pops out. Except someone figured out how to jam anything in there and make quarters pop back out, and that experiment stopped in a hurry.
 
Its just douche bags trying to sell something that is free. Fuck em, we don't need this kind of shit. Read the entire article and you will see that these companies are actually hiring people to hold hostage parking spots. That's why this shit is being made illegal, if it was really just I have a space I sell you the info buts its too easy for the companies to hire a large group and then they can rape everyone trying to go to any event that doesn't have its own regulated parking.

I can't believe anyone would defend this unless they are a total douche bag.
 
would be totally funny if people used the apps and report to the police everyone of the guys selling parking spots. Better yet the cops should just monitor the apps and do stings like they do with prostitutes/johns. Easier money than speed traps as they actually let you know exactly where they are.
 
Handicapped parking logic:
Going to Superwalmart/Costco/Home Depot/etc, where I will travel 1.5 miles to do my shopping.

Absolutely MUST have preferred parking to prevent from having to travel an extra 75 feet.
 
Sounds just like those liberal douchetards in SF. Screw capitalism - government knows whats best for you.

I was in a cab in SF a couple of weeks ago where the dispatchers was voicing concerns about Uber and saying, "did you hear? Google invented a self driving car that is going to steal all our business."

Next ban in northern commiefornia - uber and self driving cars.
 
Back
Top