Separate HD for OS = Longer lifespan?

craige4u

Weaksauce
Joined
Sep 3, 2010
Messages
102
I was wondering if I should get a 250GB separate HDD strictly for the OS & a few programs like MS office, Antivirus. The only reason to ask this question is to know if I can increase the life of both the HD if I go with this route OR i double the failure chances ?

As for the data I will connect another 2TB HD.

Please keep this discussion to lifespan only. No performance OR SSD talks plz!
 
If you want to improve reliability just get a few drives and set up raid 1, then if one fails you just replace it without downtime.
 
That's what I do, and so far only my OS drives have failed. Of course, since I expect them to fail, my OS drives tend to be older or of poorer quality.
 
I am not sure if you will help the lifespan or double your chance of failure.

Hmm. Drives I use in network raid at here work seem to have a higher percentage of failure then drives in a desktops but then also lightly used drives do die as well. I only have ~200 drives so I guess I can't really say much statistically.
 
I always keep the OS separate from data. Whether it's a separate drive, or just a separate partition. It makes restoring much easier if the OS needs to be rebuilt. I always image it once I'm done setting it up how I want so if the drive fails I can easily get the OS/config back. Data I always keep on raided volumes. Idealy raid for OS is a good idea too, but you need hardware raid, which can be expensive.

Any new machine I build from now on will have a SSD for the OS drive, so I would imagine those are also more reliable if they don't have too many writes. Disable swap file, etc.
 
I don't think the question has any answer.

I would have 2 drives. One a backup of the other. RAID is nice but that introduces the problems of a RAID failure.

Windows has reasonable backup software. That is good enough.
 
Drives fail sooner or later. What are you using the disks for?
 
Everybody here is talking abt Data backup via RAID1.. how u guys manage to think I wana do that ?
Read my question, What I am asking is – If I use separate OS HDD can I increase the life of my expensive 2TB HDD, as all booting and shutdown will be done by another cheap HD OR it doesn’t matter at all as maybe I reboot only once a day.

Why asking such a question? Seagate had decreased warranty of HDD to 1 year. So I want to try best to increase lifespan and if I could by introducing another HD for OS then I would like to give it a shot.

PS: If i go with this setup, i automatically introducing sum form of RAID ??
 
I always keep the OS separate from data. Whether it's a separate drive, or just a separate partition. It makes restoring much easier if the OS needs to be rebuilt. I always image it once I'm done setting it up how I want so if the drive fails I can easily get the OS/config back. Data I always keep on raided volumes. Idealy raid for OS is a good idea too, but you need hardware raid, which can be expensive.

Any new machine I build from now on will have a SSD for the OS drive, so I would imagine those are also more reliable if they don't have too many writes. Disable swap file, etc.

I do the same, 200gb partition for the os and some apps, and currently using the other 700 odd gigs for my games. Games used to be on their own 7200rpm drive but I sold it since the new motherboard had 1 less sata port.
 
Everybody here is talking abt Data backup via RAID1.. how u guys manage to think I wana do that ?
Read my question, What I am asking is – If I use separate OS HDD can I increase the life of my expensive 2TB HDD, as all booting and shutdown will be done by another cheap HD OR it doesn’t matter at all as maybe I reboot only once a day.

Why asking such a question? Seagate had decreased warranty of HDD to 1 year. So I want to try best to increase lifespan and if I could by introducing another HD for OS then I would like to give it a shot.

PS: If i go with this setup, i automatically introducing sum form of RAID ??

Start and stop are indeed what is the most taxing on hard drives, but then again OS drive or not, the 2TB will be started and shut down (maybe even more if it's not the OS drive, by default windows will start/stop it all day long).

I wouldn't use any kind of 250GB HDD as they're all old and slow.
 
I've had the same drives (2x 500GB RAID 0) for three years now. Up until a couple weeks ago they were my OS drives as well as storing EVERYTHING. I didn't hesitate to use them, either. I'd FRAPS every single round of every game I played just in case there was something I wanted to keep. 90% of the time I'd just delete it all after the round, but that is a TON of writes, and they're still going strong.

If you have a quality drive, I don't think you're going to kill it any faster by using it as both OS and storage.
 
Why asking such a question? Seagate had decreased warranty of HDD to 1 year. So I want to try best to increase lifespan and if I could by introducing another HD for OS then I would like to give it a shot.

I would not touch a drive with only a 1 year warranty. Remember that there are a lot of factors that go into what causes drives to die. Usage is one of them but not the only. I believe vibration is one of them. There is conflicting evidence about heat. I believe google said is better run your drives at 45C than 30C. Poor manufacturing is another.

For me at work it appears the problem with most drives that I RMA has something to do with the heads although I have no way to tell exactly. Out of the ~50 hard drives that I RMA'd (all 4 manufacturers included) in the last 4 years I would say 47 had the exact same symptoms. These symptoms were a daily increasing rate of UREs and bad sectors along with not being able to read back dozens of sectors written the day before. And I test heavily before an RMA. When I suspect a drive is experiencing difficulty by monitoring the SMART, I pull it from the raid (or desktop system making a backup in this case) and run an initial 4 pass badblocks read / write test. Before the test I note the # of UREs and bad sectors and then look at this when the test is done the next day. For a failing drive most of the time the drive goes completely offline in this test. Bad drives also will record up to several thousand bad sectors and UREs during this. If the drive becomes completely offline I give it to a coworker to run the manufacturer supported tool and see if it thinks the drive is bad.
 
Back
Top