Senhesser hd 558 meh

Pivo504

2[H]4U
Joined
Feb 18, 2005
Messages
3,381
Just received them today & Im pretty disappointed...For the price they sell for they do not sound that great...I actually own a pair of 20 dollar monoprice that sound better to my ears with music. Not sure what all the fuss was about considering how pricey they are.
 
I'm not crazy about them myself by any means. But give it some time to burn in. Also, you are use to the sound signature from the Monoprice, if you wore the 558s for a week and went back to Monoprice you might find other differences you preferred from the 558s over the Monoprice.
 
Maybe so but I just switched back and forth with both under the same music & the monoprice just sound better for some reason...Whats the point of spending over 100 dollars when something @30 sounds better lol I just felt I would be a bit blown away considering the hefty price tag & all the praise..I got them from amazon so I really only have so many days to test them out before I cant return.
 
Maybe something wrong with them. I love mine. Got them for $180 at Best Buy about a year ago and they're great. Not quite reference quality of course but still excellent. I use mine when tuning my car audio system as a reference and they work really well. They're a tad bright on the upper midrange but everything else is very good.
 
Well I dunno I bought them brand new & its a pretty noticeable difference from the monoprice to the sen
 
I'm going to go out on a limb and assume the Monoprice has more bass?
 
No its not about the bass but the overall sound. The sen just sound muffled and weak while the monoprice sound clear, powerful @ the same sound levels. I will test them out a bit more tonight but Im a bit surprised bc so many here praise the hd558 Again Im using the same sound card, same app (winamp), same eq settings etc, same song so...
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I picked up a HD558 yesterday at BestBuy and I am pretty disappointed with the sound as well. I am glad that I kept the receipt because they might find their way back. Although I must admit, I am using an integrated realtek sound card, but I am not sure if a dedicated sound card (the Asus DGX) can really do this headset justice.

I really wanted this pair to work out because I can not tell you how much I have come to despise Logitech for their G35/G930 headsets. I have owned both and the G35 suffered from driver/ sound card issues which would cause sounds to not come out of both ears and it would make sounds stutter and crackle in games like Minecraft (happened with 2 different headsets). I was able to swap them out for a G930 which is essentially a wireless equivalent, but this headset suffers from FREQUENT disconnects and Logitech blames Wifi interference. I managed to move my router half way across my house and the issue still persists (I have a friend who also has the same problem).

The only good thing I can say about the logitechs headsets is that when they both did work the audio was crystal clear and sharp. The highs were high and the lows were low, I do like things a little bassy so that worked in its favor. In comparison the HD558's sound very muffled and in CSGO specifically footsteps are very loud (which is good I guess) but I have noticed that my game sense has been completely screwed up due to the lack of virtual 7.1 surround. Someone can be at about 10 o'clock on my left firing an AK and I will perceive his positioning to be behind me at about 7 o'clock. I am also now confusing the distance of sounds, something can happen far away and I will think that it is happening close to me, I have confirmed this by using my in game radar/ map.


I apologize if I come across as hijacking this thread but I did not feel that it is necessary to create another HD558 thread when one was already made today. If anyone has any headphone advice for me, I would greatly appreciate it. I am currently eyeing the Corsair Vengeance 1500 V2.
 
XMasterMoronX: thanks for the backup! I really thought there was something wrong with my ears bc everyone praised these so highly! I admit the comfort & fit is awesome but the sound @100 dollars is not good enough nor worth it IMO The best way I could describe the sound was muffled as well compared to my monoprice set....also need some advice looking at the above linked.
 
Last edited:
I have the 558's and think they sound great. You really do need a dedicated sound card with a headphone amp to bring them to life. You must also do the 558 mod. Google it.

PS - I also have the Corsair 2100's, the Logitech 930's and Razer Carracias and the 558's are much better. Make sure you have a dedicated card with headphone amp!
 
Im using audigy2. The monoprice sound fine and they are 30 bux. A 100 dollar pair should sound a lot better without the need for an amp..just more $$$$$
 
Senn's tend to sound alot better with a DAC/AMP, and you pay more for overall better quality, but with that usually comes the need to be powered with better gear.
 
As much as I love Sennheiser (and I own a pair of HD 800s), I agree that the HD558 are not the best quality per dollar compared to some other options out there.
 
No its not about the bass but the overall sound. The sen just sound muffled and weak while the monoprice sound clear, powerful @ the same sound levels. I will test them out a bit more tonight but Im a bit surprised bc so many here praise the hd558 Again Im using the same sound card, same app (winamp), same eq settings etc, same song so...

I don't generally feel the HD 558's require an amp, it helps, but they still sound good out of most average powered audio players.

But in this case the bolded portion above is pretty much the textbook description of a headphone in need of more power. I would try them out of another source if possible, CD players are great if you happen to have one laying around. If they still sound muffled, return them as defective, it happens.
 
The way you are describing them makes it seem like you might need an amp to bring forward the sound as they may be alot harder to drive than your monoprice cans.
 
What onboard are you using? Although the 558's are pretty easy to drive, an older onboard might not have enough power to do it. When I got mine, I had them plugged into my front port, which was actually defective. They sounded cheap and muffled. Once I moved them to my back jack, they sounded awesome.

PS. I also came from the G930's and their annoying disconnects every 5 mins.
 
I left the 558's on a pink noise loop last night as now while im at work. I will be ordering the Asus DGX which does have an integrated headphone amp, which is nice. I want this pair to work. I will do the foam mod when I get home, thanks for the advice. What kind of microphone do you recommend for your 558? Modmic?

Edit: @Renapd My Asus P8Z77-V motherboard has a Realtek ALC892 integrated soundcard.
 
Last edited:
Maybe so but I just switched back and forth with both under the same music & the monoprice just sound better for some reason...Whats the point of spending over 100 dollars when something @30 sounds better lol I just felt I would be a bit blown away considering the hefty price tag & all the praise..I got them from amazon so I really only have so many days to test them out before I cant return.

If the monoprices are more sensitive it gives you an illusion that theyre better.
 
I have 515s, 555s, and 558s, and I'd say the 558s are not quite as good as my 555s in some ways, but they're both definitely better than the 515s. I'm not what I would consider an audiophile and I struggle to use the words others use to describe elements of sound, but I will say that the 558s sound more... "closed"...? than the 555s. They seem to have more bass to them perhaps. Works well for anything with some bump, but less so for classical or acoustic.

However, when plugged into my DAC/Amp, the 555s and 558s are definitely at their best. They both do ok when plugged directly into my Audigy 2ZS, or X-Fi Fatal1ty or Xonar DGX, but my little FiiO E10k makes 'em shine :)

Also, regardless of my subjective assessment of their audio quality, I really just get Senns because they are super comfy and work ok with my glasses :)

Also...

same app (winamp), same eq settings etc, same song so...

I dunno if you're using the default EQ in winamp, but it's my understanding that it's complete and total garbage.
 
I forgot what my 558s sounded like so I just plugged them in. They actually sound like shit. Why the hell does everything sound boxed in? The soundstage is completely unnatural.

To make sure I wasn't losing my mind, I plugged in my 650s and they sounded great. And this was using my DAC's integrated headphone out (which is supposedly shameful).
 
Damn, I fuckin' hate how magical the 650s are. I just meant to put these on temporarily but am still listening...
 
SirMasterL what would you consider best headphones for your $ that arent pricey? I put up a few links earlier in this thread, what does everyone think?. Ive never owned headphones over 40 bucks..I really dont want to get an amp just for a 100 dollar pair of headphones when a cheap 30 dollar pair of monoprice makes everything perfectly fine to me...I do not have the EQ turned on in winamp but anyways like I siad the monoprice/sen 558 were test with all the same software, music, hardware...Any recommendations bc Ill be returning the Sens before 30 days is up.
 
Last edited:
Do you have access to a home theater receiver with a headphone port? Then you could test them out using an amp.
 
I forgot what my 558s sounded like so I just plugged them in. They actually sound like shit. Why the hell does everything sound boxed in? The soundstage is completely unnatural.

To make sure I wasn't losing my mind, I plugged in my 650s and they sounded great. And this was using my DAC's integrated headphone out (which is supposedly shameful).

Sounds like a short or bad cable/solder contact. Sound out of phase.
 
Do you have access to a home theater receiver with a headphone port? Then you could test them out using an amp.
Not necessarily definitive. A lot of receivers source the headphone output through a biggish resistor, giving a high output impedance.
 
Any recommendations bc Ill be returning the Sens before 30 days is up.

Check out the Audio Technica AD-700s (not the 700X). $150, comfortable, easy to drive, and they don't fatigue my ears like Sennheiser headphones do. They are known for having 'lighter' bass response than other headphones, which can be good or bad depending on what you listen to. I love how they sound.

The 700X model has stronger bass, but I prefer the sound of the original model.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
SirMasterL what would you consider best headphones for your $ that arent pricey? I put up a few links earlier in this thread, what does everyone think?. Ive never owned headphones over 40 bucks..I really dont want to get an amp just for a 100 dollar pair of headphones when a cheap 30 dollar pair of monoprice makes everything perfectly fine to me...I do not have the EQ turned on in winamp but anyways like I siad the monoprice/sen 558 were test with all the same software, music, hardware...Any recommendations bc Ill be returning the Sens before 30 days is up.

Well for example I believe the Panasonic RP-HTF600-S are a better dollar per quality than the HD 558. I suppose they aren't as comfortable though.

I would say check out the 0-$75 and $75-$150 sections of this page.

http://www.head-fi.org/a/headphone-buying-guide

You really kind of have to know what you want for sound signature out of your headphones to know which to choose.
 
.Any recommendations bc Ill be returning the Sens before 30 days is up.

Well it would be nice to know what you would be using your headphones for mostly, music, gaming?

But just a quick recommendation, since you enjoyed the monoprice so much, I'm guessing you would prefer closed headphones. The go-to $100 range in my opinion are the NVX XPT-100 (same as the Brainwavz HM5, just rebranded).

Another thought, someone recently did this with the pads for the NVX XPT-100 (which you could buy for $20 new) is put them onto the Monoprice to improve comfort. If you enjoy the sound and just need something more comfortable that's a cheap option to consider.

Getting good (cheap) closed headphones can be difficult. There are a few other options, but unless you wanted to go upwards of $140, most might not suit your tastes if you weren't a fan of the Senneheiser sound.
 
I just received my Asus Xonar DGX PCIE w/ Headphone amp sound card and I feel that it has made a big improvement in sound. Sounds are now sharp when playing games. The card advertises 5.1 virtual surround sound but there is also a 7.1 setting as well (In the UNI Xonar 3rd party driver anyway).

The Asus sound card can be had for 28 bucks after rebate

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...32052&cm_re=asus_xonar-_-29-132-052-_-Product

Keep in mind that version uses PCI-ex1 and the regular DX uses the base PCI slot. The DX is 10 bucks cheaper after rebate as well. Although the regular DX does not include an amplifier, whether it is truly needed in the first place is debatable. I do not know enough to comment, all i know is that when changing the amp setting the volume is boosted.
 
These are the FOTM headphones now. Change the cable and they are amazing.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=1866192302&pf_rd_i=507846

As far as the HD558's for my 1st real pair of headphones I thought they were amazing. I would say a bad pair, but there quite a few stories here on not liking the sound. Move up to the 598's or 600's? You cant go wrong with either.

These are the little brothers:

http://www.amazon.com/Philips-L1-28...TF8&qid=1413495165&sr=8-1&keywords=fidelio+l1

Discontinued but still a well reviewed phone for the price. You can grab one at a steal right now.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I have a theory that if Senhesser purchasers would have tried on a pair of Audio Technica ATH-AD's first, that they would not be Senhesser users.
 
These will be used for everything: gaming, music, everyday stuff. Im thinking of not even shelling out a lot so all the 100 & up suggestions are not needed. I wonder if the monoprice can be modded to be more comfortable? Its mainly the ear & headband that start to be annoying...The monos are actually on sale for only 19 currently lol I dont see the point in paying 4-5 times more if the headphones arent going to blow me away as the senns didnt...Is there anything in the 50 range that sounds better & is more comfortable than the monos?
 
Back
Top