Senators Decry Link Between Egypt, 'Kill Switch' Bill

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Politicians are upset over comparisons with what is happening in Egypt and the "kill switch" bill they are pushing. Gee, I wonder why. :rolleyes:

"Some have suggested that our legislation would empower the president to deny U.S. citizens access to the Internet," said the statement from Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.), Susan Collins (R-Maine), and Senator Tom Carper, (D-Del.). "Nothing could be further from the truth." Lieberman, an independent who caucuses with Democrats, is chairman of the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee.
 
With no judicial review of the Kill Switch authority, it's exactly like it is in Egypt. I get how this could be beneficial to us in some scenarios, but it's simply too much power for one person to have given the amount of enterprise and interpersonal communication is web-dependant today.
 
I honestly can't see a single scenario where the ability to limit the people's right to a free exchange of ideas is beneficial. If critical installations are targeted by cyber attack, you unplug those installations at their source, not the whole internet. This is simply another piece of legislation to assure the people in power stay in power, and the will of the people is denied. The people of Egypt have shown the world a very powerful lesson and we'd do well to learn by their example.

....or I could be wrong and this is the ultimate contingency plan in case chinese hackers manage to bypass the gmail spam filters, and we all get bombarded with WMD levels of viagra spam. :D
 
I'm trying not to soapbox but as I'm reading the article I'm noticing this exceeding typical slant in the news. All over the article it names both republicans and democrats specifically supporting the bill including introduction by both sides but when viewing ownership as a whole it keeps saying democrats, democrats, democrats. I never see the repubicans thrown under the bus like that in the news. I guess they just never do anything except vote for bad things the democrats introduce. weird.

on a related note I was just thinking. At my work I manage a large amount of point to point backhual traffic for business customers, bank/hospital internal rings and cellphone towers. That kinda stuff. Would the kill switch include internal network for MSO's or just make the backbone carriers shutdown their peer links to effectively kill internet traffic.

I wonder how long it would take for me to explain the difference to a politician.
 
I'm trying not to soapbox but as I'm reading the article I'm noticing this exceeding typical slant in the news. All over the article it names both republicans and democrats specifically supporting the bill including introduction by both sides but when viewing ownership as a whole it keeps saying democrats, democrats, democrats. I never see the repubicans thrown under the bus like that in the news. I guess they just never do anything except vote for bad things the democrats introduce. weird.

on a related note I was just thinking. At my work I manage a large amount of point to point backhual traffic for business customers, bank/hospital internal rings and cellphone towers. That kinda stuff. Would the kill switch include internal network for MSO's or just make the backbone carriers shutdown their peer links to effectively kill internet traffic.

I wonder how long it would take for me to explain the difference to a politician.

Unfortunately the way it is being worded is that the bill not only allows for the killing of internet service backbones, but that the federal government can take over and demand full access to any PRIVATE network as well, with no restrictions on how large or small (home network, corporate network, ISPs, etc).

There is NO reason for this other than to be used as a weapon against the very citizenry.
 
How can you guys not see that this is VERY different from Egypt!

Over there it took many people to shut down the internet...

Over here it will take one.



:D
 
The entire point of the initial infrastructural of the internet in the states back in the 40's and 50's was to prevent a disruption of the flow of information.

Additionally, I suggest reading this bill in it's entirety and you'll see that it's not what the news and pundits are making it out to be. It's also pretty scary to see how many politicians who are voting on it haven't taken the time to understand it either.
 
I don't understand why people are getting so riled up.
Like a President of The United States would ever abuse his power... :rolleyes:
 
They are preparing to cut off the population from communicating with the outside world when things get to the point in the U.S. as it is in Egypt now.

Overtaxed
Underpaid
Food to expensive to buy
Virtually Impossible to travel(People in Egypt I know say it is a real pain to try and get out of the country to travel)
Government abuses
No Right to Bear Arms
Government License to even run a business

Oh, and the Internet Kill Switch(nice test run Egypt)

Do any of these things ring a bell to those in the U.S. Wake up people Tyranny is coming home to roost. You will reap what They have sown in your name.
 
Unfortunately from experience the following is usually true..

"Nothing could be further from the truth" = "EXACTLY THE SAME THING"
 
Good. I hope there's a big shitstorm over it and enough people wake up.
 
I wonder if satellite internet gets cut off, we could all get a bunkered ISP in a mountain somewhere who forwards all the traffic to satallites. Bam- instant-counter-action to their bs powers!
 
Good! He and his cronies got spanked during his debacle to try and control video games back in the 90s, so he can cry me a fucking river for all I care. :D

He can't retire fast enough.
 
I wouldnt alltogether argue that in some VERY speicifc cases, for example electrical power grid networks, MAYBE. Although I think they would do better just regulating them from a compliance standpoint, not controling them. What gets me however, is the part of this legislation that, "prohibit(s) review by the court system." Really??? Why would you prohibit review by the courts? On the contrary it should MANDATE reviews by the courts! The only reason for them adding that is to allow them to abuse this power in any way they see fit. I'm glad the Egypt thing brought this issue to light, because now that people are looking more intently at it, it will get the review that it needs, or hopefully get thrown out.
 
Since the internet is a vehicle for press, speech and peaceful assembly, this bill is illegal.
 
Since the internet is a vehicle for press, speech and peaceful assembly, this bill is illegal.
Despite what shock jock talk shows are reporting it's perfectly legal. Nobody is stopping anyone from reporting the news, assembling, or restricting speech.
 
"electrical power grid networks"

These are not connected directly to the internet. Hence the reason Stuxnet had to be deliberately placed onto networks in Iran by US/Israeli covert infiltration.
 
Leave to Joe "Censorship, censorship, censorship!" Lieberman to continue to piss on your first amendment rights.
 
"Nobody is stopping anyone from reporting the news, assembling, or restricting speech. "

When you are threatened, beaten, jailed, or worse then YES those actions are restricted. Wake up and look around you. Merely looking at the G20 in Pittsburgh last year we can plainly see these things happening.
 
Despite what shock jock talk shows are reporting it's perfectly legal. Nobody is stopping anyone from reporting the news, assembling, or restricting speech.

Unless they run things into the ground enough and people take up the petition the government for a redress of grievances offer en masse. ;)
 
Like this bunch cares about any of that?



They are proving time and time again they don't care about the law. When the Federal judge ruled the moratorium on drilling illegal - they basically said screw you and kept the moratorium in place - putting tens of thousands out of work.

Checks and balances don't matter to this president.
 
They are proving time and time again they don't care about the law. When the Federal judge ruled the moratorium on drilling illegal - they basically said screw you and kept the moratorium in place - putting tens of thousands out of work.

Checks and balances don't matter to this president.

Yup.

Or how about a 2500 page bill no one bothered to read but had to ram down our throats because I'm sure we'd all love it after it passed.

On and on I can go.

If we're going by the Constitution, which sadly an increasing number of people seem to not care about and, boy, does it show... I've lost count how many acts of treason I've seen done in the past 10 years and especially the last 2-3 years at federal government level at least.

The Patriot Act and TARP alone should be enough examples I would think. Notice how I'm not blaming one party for any and all of it?

Oh well. Hope and change all that shit.
 
All over the article it names both republicans and democrats specifically supporting the bill including introduction by both sides but when viewing ownership as a whole it keeps saying democrats, democrats, democrats.
The Democrats control the Senate. They are the ones pushing for it. If they want it so bad they should get most of the credit for it. Obama wants it to, and he's also a Democrat. The article didn't even mention his support of it.

I never see the repubicans thrown under the bus like that in the news.
Were you in a coma all eight years Bush was president?

I guess they just never do anything except vote for bad things the democrats introduce. weird.
Yes, the Democrats usually vote for bad things the Democrats introduce, and it's usually bad.
 
They are proving time and time again they don't care about the law. When the Federal judge ruled the moratorium on drilling illegal - they basically said screw you and kept the moratorium in place - putting tens of thousands out of work.

Checks and balances don't matter to this president.
The administration never ignored the ruling, they simply revised the moratorium to appease the court's wishes and it subsequently held up in court. Apparently it's facts be damned when it comes to politics and conspiracy theories around here.
 
Sure give them the kill switch...I trust the government completely :D

lemmings.jpg
 
I just think it's amusing that most of the same people that say that the government imposing any law whatsoever on the internet is essentially a complete and utter affront to free speech. But if a company were to do the same thing, they'd say "perfectly acceptable".

Whats the point of complaining about alleged fascism in government, while standing up for the right for corporations to be fascist?

Anyway, I think the problem lies in the fact that the Internet is, essentially, now a largely privatized global network. Yet the fact is, it originally started out as a government network, envisioned to be a better way for the government itself to communicate. And a lot of this government network infrastructure is still connected, and is now globalized. Now we have to figure out how to deal with it.. But of course any way that anybody tries, somebody is just going to say "Kill Switch!" and immediately kill any debate on it.

And while we continue to bicker over it, we still have networks vital to our infrastructure connected to the world, without any centralized way to isolate them... And the knee jerk reactions will just assure none of them are ever secured.

Yet another way for the political right to have everything their way. If Democrats try to address the issue, they're branded as fascists that are trying to put a kill switch on your free speech, if they don't, they're branded as ineffectual and incompetent in national security issues.

Yeah, we're pretty much doomed. Start learning Chinese sooner rather than later.
 
I just think it's amusing that most of the same people that say that the government imposing any law whatsoever on the internet is essentially a complete and utter affront to free speech. But if a company were to do the same thing, they'd say "perfectly acceptable".

Whats the point of complaining about alleged fascism in government, while standing up for the right for corporations to be fascist?

I agree with you. To me what you've cited is all equally bad in my eyes.

I'm not sure anyone I've see anyone champion the corps around here.


Anyway, I think the problem lies in the fact that the Internet is, essentially, now a largely privatized global network. Yet the fact is, it originally started out as a government network, envisioned to be a better way for the government itself to communicate. And a lot of this government network infrastructure is still connected, and is now globalized. Now we have to figure out how to deal with it.. But of course any way that anybody tries, somebody is just going to say "Kill Switch!" and immediately kill any debate on it.

Why not sneak it into a 2500 page bill that no one reads and cram it through Congress and get it done? We'll all love it I'm sure after it passes. Or have some executive order or some czar handle it? Can't get in the way of progress, y'know.


And while we continue to bicker over it, we still have networks vital to our infrastructure connected to the world, without any centralized way to isolate them... And the knee jerk reactions will just assure none of them are ever secured.

Yet another way for the political right to have everything their way.

I figured this was coming.

Yeah, the political right has really had everything going their way for a while, especially since 2006. :rolleyes:

If Democrats try to address the issue, they're branded as fascists that are trying to put a kill switch on your free speech, if they don't, they're branded as ineffectual and incompetent in national security issues.

And that's all true. And there's plenty of Republicans I'd lump in the same boat.


Yeah, we're pretty much doomed. Start learning Chinese sooner rather than later.


Yup, and the policies the left are pushing are helping make it happen.
 
Back
Top