Seeking Advice on sub $200 upgrade

CmdrTallen

n00b
Joined
Oct 25, 2007
Messages
53
Greetings,

I currently have a 7950GT and I was thinking of upgrading to one of the new 8600 series cards (I need to upgrade another machine in the house so my 7950GT will be recycled into that).

Anyhow I was wondering if you VC gurus could give some input to which is the recommended sub $200 PCI 16x Express card with FPS gaming in mind.

I was looking at one of these;

XFX PVT84GYDQ3 GeForce 8600GTS 512MB 128-bit GDDR3 - $190 (before rebate)

BFG Tech BFGE86512GTOC2FE GeForce 8600GT 512MB 128-bit GDDR3 - $199

Any advice would be appreciated!

 
Greetings,

I currently have a 7950GT and I was thinking of upgrading to one of the new 8600 series cards (I need to upgrade another machine in the house so my 7950GT will be recycled into that).

Anyhow I was wondering if you VC gurus could give some input to which is the recommended sub $200 PCI 16x Express card with FPS gaming in mind.

I was looking at one of these;

XFX PVT84GYDQ3 GeForce 8600GTS 512MB 128-bit GDDR3 - $190 (before rebate)

BFG Tech BFGE86512GTOC2FE GeForce 8600GT 512MB 128-bit GDDR3 - $199

Any advice would be appreciated!

HD3870 or HD3850 would be much better than 8600GTS
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814241068
http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&DEPA=0&Description=hd3850
 
HD3870 or HD3850 would be much better than 8600GTS]

Any reason other than ATI vs Nvidia? Just wondering what makes you think that. Better benchmarks? Better Control Center? I presume its not just because you like ATI cards better than Nvidia.

 
Any reason other than ATI vs Nvidia? Just wondering what makes you think that. Better benchmarks? Better Control Center? I presume its not just because you like ATI cards better than Nvidia.


http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=3151&p=8

From anandtech review:

"Until NVIDIA actually releases a 8800 GT 256MB at $179, the closest competitor to the Radeon HD 3850 is actually the GeForce 8600 GTS. We don't need to show you too many numbers for you to understand the magnitude of this massacre:"

"The Radeon HD 3850 is so much faster than the 8600 GTS at a very competitive price."
 
i might go for the 8800gt 256mb when it releases. it performs as well as the 3870 512mb at 1680x1050 and below.

go here expreview to see how it performs in games such as enemy territory: quake wars, half life 2: episode 2, fear, call of duty 4, unreal tournament, bioshock
3dmark06_01.png

3dmark06_02.png
 
"The Radeon HD 3850 is so much faster than the 8600 GTS at a very competitive price."

So am I comparing apples-to-apples when I look at these specs?;

HD3850 320 stream processing units

8600 32 stream processors

I mean I realize I am not a VC expert but one would see just that spec and wonder why the 10 fold difference.

So far I am leaning towards the HD3850 based on the reviews I have found. Thanks for the heads up on that.

 
I'd wait a bit and save up a couple of more bucks and buy a 512MB 3870 when you can find it available for $220.
Or wait for a 512MB 3850 which should sell for around $200 US.

A 256MB 3850 isn't a good choice since a lot of the newer games don't work well with only 256MB of memory when using the "high" setting for textures.

Don't bother with the Nvidia 8600 series cards. The HD38xx ATI based cards are a much better choice for not that much more $$$.
 
I'd wait a bit and save up a couple of more bucks and buy a 512MB 3870 when you can find it available for $220.
Or wait for a 512MB 3850 which should sell for around $200 US.

A 256MB 3850 isn't a good choice since a lot of the newer games don't work well with only 256MB of memory when using the "high" setting for textures.

Don't bother with the Nvidia 8600 series cards. The HD38xx ATI based cards are a much better choice for not that much more $$$.

GECUBE HD3850 512mb - $209.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814241068

VisionTech HD3870 512mb - $214.99 Currently OUT OF STOCK
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8636666&st=3870&lp=1&type=product&cp=1&id=1194053242087
 
as has been mentioned a few times... the new 512mb 3850 is only $210 shipped on newegg. MUCH MUCH better than 8600... or anything else in that price range
 
So am I comparing apples-to-apples when I look at these specs?;

HD3850 320 stream processing units

8600 32 stream processors

I mean I realize I am not a VC expert but one would see just that spec and wonder why the 10 fold difference.

Unfortunately, video card design has become so damn complex that you cannot compare the number of shader units directly.

EXAMPLE: the old 8800 GTS (96 shader units, 1200 MHz) is roughly equal in performance to the Radeon HD 2900 XT (320 stream units at 740 MHz) in many games. It is very hard to compare the two cards based on stream processor count alone, because the basic functions offered by these stream processors differ. The differing architectures have their own strengths and weaknesses, which only come out clearly in real-world tests.

This is why you should rely mostly on game benchmark results to make your purchasing decisions. Comparing raw specs is rather useless.
 
Any reason other than ATI vs Nvidia? Just wondering what makes you think that. Better benchmarks? Better Control Center? I presume its not just because you like ATI cards better than Nvidia.


Simple, because the performance of Nvidia's sub $200 cards is SHIT and ATi's 3850 is not. The 3850 is weak compared to the 8800GT, but in the under $200 price range there simply is no competition for it, nothing else even worth looking at.

EDIT: Oh, I'm not an ATi "fan" by any means, my last few video cards in reverse order: 7900GT, 6600GT (PCIe), 6800GT (AGP), 6600GT (AGP, RMA for 5900 "Golden Sample" which died), 5900 AGP "Golden Sample", 4600...

The only ATi cards I have are a 7000 I bought for a non-game PC and some other old ATi card I got free.

If I could find an 8800GT for under $250 I'd get that, otherwise I'm looking at an ATi 38x0 card, not sure which one, maybe a 512MB 3850...

When the 256MB 8800GT comes out, if there's ample supply, it should be under $200 and THEN there will be a non-ATi under $200 card to consider, prob. drive down ATi's prices...

edit: check here: http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=3151&p=8
 
Back
Top