Security Chip That Does Encryption in PCs Hacked

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
You know you are a bad mofo when you hack a Trusted Platform Module chip with a needle, some acid and rust remover. Thanks to Henrico D. for the linkage.

Deep inside millions of computers is a digital Fort Knox, a special chip with the locks to highly guarded secrets, including classified government reports and confidential business plans. Now a former U.S. Army computer-security specialist has devised a way to break those locks.
 
If it can be encrypted by humans, it can be cracked by humans.

Seriously, who didn't see this coming?
 
He's not cracking crypto. This is basically a physical attack tapping the internal signal lines that carry unencrypted data. An obvious, though difficult attack, and one that's pretty much impossible to completely guard against. At the end of the day, sufficient time with the physical machine means you're pwned no matter what you've done.

If it can be encrypted by humans, it can be cracked by humans.
Mathematics would disagree.
 
He's not cracking crypto. This is basically a physical attack tapping the internal signal lines that carry unencrypted data. An obvious, though difficult attack, and one that's pretty much impossible to completely guard against. At the end of the day, sufficient time with the physical machine means you're pwned no matter what you've done.

Exactly, this is entirely non-issue. Nothing was "hacked". I was excited until I read the article. Far more impressive physical attacks have been done, such as using compressed air to quick freeze the RAM sticks, pop them out of the computer, and dump the contents of the sticks up to an hour later - THAT was impressive and cool. What this guy did is sort of a "no shit, sherlock".
 
Exactly, this is entirely non-issue. Nothing was "hacked". I was excited until I read the article. Far more impressive physical attacks have been done, such as using compressed air to quick freeze the RAM sticks, pop them out of the computer, and dump the contents of the sticks up to an hour later - THAT was impressive and cool. What this guy did is sort of a "no shit, sherlock".

True but you have to give him props for persistance, in taking the time to figure out exactly how to make it work.
 
Exactly, this is entirely non-issue. Nothing was "hacked". I was excited until I read the article. Far more impressive physical attacks have been done, such as using compressed air to quick freeze the RAM sticks, pop them out of the computer, and dump the contents of the sticks up to an hour later - THAT was impressive and cool. What this guy did is sort of a "no shit, sherlock".

well actually going into the IC and tapping lines on the die itself is pretty sick imho, I have not heard of anyone doing something similar that I am aware of
 
where does he buy his "needles", yikes! he's got serious hardware. this is a hack that very very few could pull off.
 
What a great way to get some publicity for his business! I dislike how a 3 page article only dedicates 2 measly paragraphs to detail the hack.
 
Exactly, this is entirely non-issue. Nothing was "hacked". I was excited until I read the article. Far more impressive physical attacks have been done, such as using compressed air to quick freeze the RAM sticks, pop them out of the computer, and dump the contents of the sticks up to an hour later - THAT was impressive and cool. What this guy did is sort of a "no shit, sherlock".

The difference here is that someone with as much technical knowledge as you or me could probably successfully run a cold boot attack. Hell, all you need to do is freeze some RAM sticks with liquid nitrogen, boot to USB & dump their contents and run a few utilities easily found on the internet to find the password (assuming we're either dealing with TrueCrypt, BitLocker, or FileVault). Absolutely no skill required.

The biggest difference, though, is that a standard cold boot attack requires the user to already be logged in by the time you have access to the hardware. His attack does not. The amount of knowledge and skill required to execute something of his magnitude is absolutely huge.
 
The difference here is that someone with as much technical knowledge as you or me could probably successfully run a cold boot attack. Hell, all you need to do is freeze some RAM sticks with liquid nitrogen, boot to USB & dump their contents and run a few utilities easily found on the internet to find the password (assuming we're either dealing with TrueCrypt, BitLocker, or FileVault). Absolutely no skill required.

The biggest difference, though, is that a standard cold boot attack requires the user to already be logged in by the time you have access to the hardware. His attack does not. The amount of knowledge and skill required to execute something of his magnitude is absolutely huge.

The article isn't super clear, but it sounds like his attack requires physical access to the machine for him to install a wiretap (more or less) and then for somebody to log into the system for him to then actually get the keys. The freeze the RAM trick is far more damaging because I can grab an already booted computer and bolt out the door - its just not practical for somebody to break in, do some serious EE work, leave, and come back later to grab the results.

It sounds like he basically created a keylogger for the TPM module.

well actually going into the IC and tapping lines on the die itself is pretty sick imho, I have not heard of anyone doing something similar that I am aware of

Sorry, poor choice of wording on my part. I meant far more *clever* attacks. His attack took some wicked skill, but its a pretty obvious and well known attack. Infineon even stated that they knew about this potential attack when they were designing the chip.
 
Pfft, if he can do it while my Boxer chews on him whilst dodging buckshot, then Ill worry. Until then, my redneck security system seems pretty safe ;)
 
He just might. said guy with the hardware to get such needles might have the hardware to take you out a mile away so that you can never fire the buckshots...

not clever, but takes wicked skills if you use a mosin-nagant.
 
Back
Top