Seagate Momentus XT 750? Or something else?

Joined
Mar 5, 2008
Messages
45
I am looking for a nice fast hard drive in the 500GB to 1TB range for a desktop with 6GB SATA. I am primarily looking for speed and cost is not a major concern....but I don't want to drop major coin on a large SSD. I was thinking about getting a Seagate Momentus XT 750GB drive since it seems to give me a nice boost and a decent amount of storage.

Is there any other drives I would want to look at?

Thanks for any input!
 
Well, I guess another question on this subject would be how much management do you want to do with the drive? For instance, I put a 120 GB SSD in my system as an OS and limited program drive, then a larger drive for mass storage. I handle all of the management myself and it works fine. For my son, I bought him a Z68 board and setup the 60 GB SSD as cache for his WD Black drive, so there isn't much management there, much less than mine, but more than none. On my wife's system, where I can't really rely on her to manage the space at all, I bought her the 750 GB seagate hybrid. All three work fine.
 
OCZ Revo hybrid has bigger SSD cache and same storage size, but will cost more. Otherwise a Z68 mobo with the SSD caching feature, but that may cost too much. Otherwise, a SSD for boot/games/apps and mechanical drive for mass storage seems to be the best performance/price route.

I'm in the same boat, I'm looking for SSD speed and at least 250GB in size and there's no really inexpensive SSD or hybrid with a largish SSD cache out there.
 
I have heard nice thing about the 750 GB XT drive is it caches the writes unlike the previous 500GB XT drive. The cache is also double the size. Although I suspect the cache is still more like USB stick / laptop hybrid than an SSD / desktop drive hybrid just like the previous version.

I am primarily looking for speed

I know your experience with this drive will vary. I do not see the speed in my usage of the 4 500GB XTs I have at work. However I have to tell you that I am a programmer and I have 100s of thousands of small files (generally less than 32K each) on these drives that change often. Perhaps that is the reason these drives are not faster (most of the time slower) for me than regular current generation 7200 1TB desktop drives let alone velociraptors that some review sites show it beating.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I am lazy. I would rather just have one drive since I don't want to hack where applications go, data files, etc. I am primarily on my laptop which has a Crucial C300 256gb. I don't use the desktop a lot and most of it is just work related stuff (Office suite) and some encoding in Handbrake for iPhone videos. I only use about 250gb right now so it's not like I need a ton of space....just more than a well priced SSD!

I think I'll take the plunge on a 750GB Momentus XT. MacConnection has it for $203 shipped.
 
I have not read a bad review on the new 750gb Momentus XT. The only negative that people mention is the cost. I just wanted to see if there was another product I didn't know about before buying.

No programming here. Just Office applications and copying 100-700mb video files around. I have a feeling that might be the Momentus' "sweet spot."
 
Back
Top