Seagate LP drives fast enough for HD?

eatadonut

n00b
Joined
May 17, 2008
Messages
16
I'm putting together a Mini-ITX HTPC build, I have room for one 3.5" drive. I was planning on using the 5900RPM 1TB Seagate LP, but reading through the Newegg reviews :rolleyes: some people are reporting stupid low read speeds.

I'm interested in the quietest, lowest-power (really, lowest-heat), largest drive that's fast enough to watch high-quality HD. Is this it, or should I just opt for a known quantity in the AALS? I've got the AAKS in my desktop right now, and love it.
 
I have watched HD content off of a usb memory stick before. Bluerays are typically around 30Mbits per second. I would say if it isn't fast enough to play HD video, then it is defective.

I would be more worried about weather I had enough CPU to play HD. Or at least a known Hardware solution like a video card that will accelerate video. If you have that covered you should be fine for playback. Overall transfer speeds might not be that impressive and you may want a faster hard-drive for that reason, but it should certainly be fast enough to play HD.
 
High Def data rates are rather low so the file sizes aren't ridiculously huge. Over the Air HDTV is 20mbit mpeg2, and according to wikipedia 1x Blu-Ray speed is 36mbit/s or 4.5MByte/sec.

Any hard drive will handle this fine with tons of room to spare.

Modern hard drives are like 50-100MByte/sec.
 
Wow. Sorry guys, didn't have my coffee. Off the top of my head I knew (KNEW!) that some of my files were ~40 MByte/sec. Thanks.
 
you do mean Mbits right? Not Megabytes? because 40Megabytes a sec is rather excessive.
 
I used to always get seagate drives until they bought maxtor and now use their manufacturing facilities. i and numerous people i know had defective drives :(
 
I used to always get seagate drives until they bought maxtor and now use their manufacturing facilities. i and numerous people i know had defective drives :(

That was kinda random....

Seagate is fine, they still make awesome drives.
 
That was kinda random....

Seagate is fine, they still make awesome drives.

I know, but honestly yesterday I just shipped my 1.5TB Seagate back to Newegg. I have a 1.5TB WD now which is running like a champ.
 
I know, but honestly yesterday I just shipped my 1.5TB Seagate back to Newegg. I have a 1.5TB WD now which is running like a champ.

Wait. Why did you buy a Seagate drive if you don't like them? FYI, the only use the Maxtor facilities for Maxtor drives after they overhauled them. :rolleyes:
 
I know, but honestly yesterday I just shipped my 1.5TB Seagate back to Newegg. I have a 1.5TB WD now which is running like a champ.
The 7200.11 seagates are known to be problematic, and the 1.5tb size was the worst one. They weren't all bad but they def had a higher defect rate than normal. You just had rotten luck picking the wrong model. The newer ones don't have the same problem.
 
The 7200.11 seagates are known to be problematic, and the 1.5tb size was the worst one. They weren't all bad but they def had a higher defect rate than normal. You just had rotten luck picking the wrong model. The newer ones don't have the same problem.

I hope so because I always supported Seagate over WD before this.
 
Back
Top