Seagate, HGST 4TB HD $153

dammit! how reliable are these drives?

How blue is the sky? No large scale study has been done so there is no rational answer to this question. Loudmouths screaming 1-star reviews on Newegg and elsewhere are worthless because the countless masses having no problems aren't compelled to go online to discuss the fact.

The only real answer to that question is "as reliable as your backup".
 
How blue is the sky? No large scale study has been done so there is no rational answer to this question. Loudmouths screaming 1-star reviews on Newegg and elsewhere are worthless because the countless masses having no problems aren't compelled to go online to discuss the fact.

The only real answer to that question is "as reliable as your backup".
I like that, reliable as your back up.

The thing is I am looking for 2 x 4 tb hard drive so my back up will probably the same as the primary, so I guess again how reliable are these drives.

I will have 1 x 2tb hd204ui OG samsung green as the backup for the backup. And I have had 1 drive fail out of 8 for the past 3 years so I know the reliability of those drives. I guess nobody can really answer my question.
 
And I have had 1 drive fail out of 8 for the past 3 years so I know the reliability of those drives. I guess nobody can really answer my question.

1 failure in 8 drives is statistically meaningless, no offense. FWIW about 135 million harddisks shipped in 2012 globally. You'd need large scale studies of hundreds of thousands of drives to even begin to make assumptions on how reliable a make/model is.

And a bunch of randoms on a forum with anecdotal testimony about "Well I have a Seagate and its still going strong knock on wood but I got a WD from Newegg and it wasn't working out of the box so WD suxxx" -- all this noise is statistically meaningless unfortunately.

That said, I've had nothing but good experiences with HGST, maybe I've been lucky, maybe its a good brand, I dont worry about it because I buy the cheapest drive with the longest warranty and keep backups.
 
Last edited:
Jumped in for 15 drives. Figured it's a nice jump from my current 2TB drives (30TB -> 60TB) :D
 
1 failure in 8 drives is statistically meaningless, no offense. FWIW about 135 million harddisks shipped in 2012 globally. You'd need large scale studies of hundreds of thousands of drives to even begin to make assumptions on how reliable a make/model is.

And a bunch of randoms on a forum with anecdotal testimony about "Well I have a Seagate and its still going strong knock on wood but I got a WD from Newegg and it wasn't working out of the box so WD suxxx" -- all this noise is statistically meaningless unfortunately.

That said, I've had nothing but good experiences with HGST, maybe I've been lucky, maybe its a good brand, I dont worry about it because I buy the cheapest drive with the longest warranty and keep backups.

I hear you man. Thank you for the your input
 
The thing is I am looking for 2 x 4 tb hard drive so my back up will probably the same as the primary, so I guess again how reliable are these drives.

If you're setting up a RAID 1 array, both of these should be fine. It's not common for both to fail simultaneously unless caused by some outside influence.
 
http://www.extremetech.com/computing/170748-how-long-do-hard-drives-actually-live-for

So, there you have it: If you buy a hard drive today, there’s a 90% chance that it will survive for three years. If your drive makes it to the three-year point, you would be wise to back up your data, as there’s a 12% chance per year that your drive will die. It’s worth noting that these figures are for internal hard drives: External hard drives, for a large number of factors, may not last as long (though if you only plug it in every few days to back your data up, it might last longer). It’s also worth mentioning that Backblaze’s drives are spinning constantly — these failure rates are for drives that are turned on 24/7. Your home computer probably isn’t powered up 24/7, and thus the drives may last longer.

Because there’s a 5.1% chance that your drive will die in its first year, you should either back up your data regularly — or, if you’re feeling dangerous, not keep any valuable data on that drive until it’s worked out any kinks and survived to the 18-month mark. After 36 months, though, you should definitely back up your data, or copy the data to a new hard drive. (Backblaze, at $5/month for unlimited backup space, is a remarkably good deal.)

Hard drive failure rate after four years: 80% are still alive.
 
Back
Top