Seagate 2TB $110 + shipping ... good?

LTek

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 1, 2007
Messages
1,402
There seem to be many mixed reports with this drive... anyone know if this is really a problem drive?

I'm considering getting 2 of these to use in a mirror with Win7 x64.

thx


http://www.frys.com/product/5975474

Seagate Barracuda 2TB Serial ATA/5900-RPM 3.5" Hard Drive - ST320005N4A1AS-RK
 
Price online has an additional $10 savings, so $100 + shipping... Good find, OP!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
You should read the reviews on the 7200.

What's up with these drives
 
this is what I'm wondering... the reviews are really mixed but Seagate must have sold millions of these. are we only hearing about the bad ones?

I'd run them in a RAID 1 (mirror) so at least if one dies the other will be a backup.

I will probably get these.
 
this is what I'm wondering... the reviews are really mixed but Seagate must have sold millions of these. are we only hearing about the bad ones?

I'd run them in a RAID 1 (mirror) so at least if one dies the other will be a backup.

I will probably get these.

there are other 2tb drives on sale all the time, notably the western digital green drives. slickdeals has them for $100 shipped like every other week.
 
I havent had any good experiences with barracuda LP drives, and its not like i am anti Seagate(just picked up a 7200.12 1tb from them when newegg had them for $59.99).
 
i like western digital drives better but it is really all luck with different companies in getting bad or good drives.
 
I think it was just the .11 drives that had issues... but other than that I have never had problems with Seagate. A friend of mine had gotten this drive from Fry's and returned it after the endless clicking to get a Hitachi.
 
Stay away from these shit drives.

This morning, I may not have said the same...

But I have a 1.5TB 5900rpm drive that I've been running in my gaming PC (being demoted just this afternoon to a file server, as my new machine's coming on-line now...) for a few months now, constantly monitored, no problems, etc etc etc... Was just watching a movie last night that was stored on the drive...

Turn the ol' gaming machine off, move it four feet across the desk to make way for the new gaming machine...

and...

The 1.5TB drive makes some nasty clicking noises, etc etc, computer doesn't want to boot, as the drive's there, the not, then there...

Few more reboots...

drive's dead...

Four hours earlier that drive hadn't ever even burped...

More it four feet, and it dies...

System also had WD and Sammy drives in it... They're all fine... So, I didn't somehow cause catastrophic damage when I moved it four feet across the desk...

To think this weekend I was going to be setting up a RAID for redundancy of my data, now that the ol' gaming PC is now a file server...

I'm kinda pissed... Drive never gave any hint anything wrong with it, and it just dies...

(It's still all plugged in right now, but to the computer it's completely dead, it doesn't even pause for it anymore...)
 
I've got drives now from every manufacture except Hitachi and have had a dead drive from every manufacture. Had a dead Maxtor/Seagat 80gb, dead WD 500g Green, dead Samsung 1.5tb. I really do thing it's luck of the draw more then anything.
 
I've got drives now from every manufacture except Hitachi and have had a dead drive from every manufacture. Had a dead Maxtor/Seagat 80gb, dead WD 500g Green, dead Samsung 1.5tb. I really do thing it's luck of the draw more then anything.

I have had pretty bad luck with Samsung drives. But great luck with both Seagate and WD. I usually go for the drives rated with the lowest heat output, which are the WD Green drives right now I think.
 
Back
Top