SATA HD to PATA adapters

Stereodude

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 20, 2000
Messages
3,285
Has anyone tried any of the adapters that will let SATA drives be used on a PATA controller?

Long story short, I want to put a few larger IDE drives on my 3ware 7506-8 to replace the 2 320GB IDE drives I have now doing RAID-1 in my file server. I know 500GB IDE drives are still available, but that isn't a whole lot of extra space from where I am now, and 750GB IDE drives are crazy expensive (~$175). I looked into a basic PCI SATA RAID-1 card, but wasn't very thrilled with what a saw in the reviews at Newegg.

I guess that leaves me with SATA HD to PATA controller adapters. Something like this or this.

Thoughts?
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
no sorry... i've used plenty of the adapters to go the other way.. using ide drives in a sata controller
 
While king of it's day, that card is quite long in the tooth, and it might not like drives of that size. (the family does have a 3.6TB max even on the 12 channel card, and a 2TB/array max)

If you are just doing RAID1, I'd go with something like this, those adapters will run you $50 for two, and this card is only $10 more: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16816115040
 
While king of it's day, that card is quite long in the tooth, and it might not like drives of that size. (the family does have a 3.6TB max even on the 12 channel card, and a 2TB/array max)
Well, I wasn't planning to go any bigger then two 1TB drives and I might go with 750's, so it'll probably work.
If you are just doing RAID1, I'd go with something like this, those adapters will run you $50 for two, and this card is only $10 more: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16816115040
Isn't that's a software RAID card though?

Right now I'm contemplating replacing the guts of the server and moving to a SATA capable motherboard with a Core 2 Duo, keeping my RAID-5 array on the 3ware card, and going RAID-1 on one of the motherboard's controller with SATA drives. Later down the road I can use the ICH9R/ICH10R for RAID-5 with SATA drives when I have more cash. That's probably the better play.
 
Well, I wasn't planning to go any bigger then two 1TB drives and I might go with 750's, so it'll probably work.
Isn't that's a software RAID card though?

Right now I'm contemplating replacing the guts of the server and moving to a SATA capable motherboard with a Core 2 Duo, keeping my RAID-5 array on the 3ware card, and going RAID-1 on one of the motherboard's controller with SATA drives. Later down the road I can use the ICH9R/ICH10R for RAID-5 with SATA drives when I have more cash. That's probably the better play.

Well RAID 1 doesn't do any parity calculations, so you don't need a hardware card, the only benefit a hardware card would have is it's cache.

And you new idea is a better one, though ICHxR RAID 5 is software too and that does do a parity calc but software with the Core 2 might be faster than the old 7506.
 
I've used them before. They worked fine for me. In fact, I have a couple sitting in a box somewhere that I don't need anymore...would sell them cheap if you are interested. PM me for details...

EDIT: BTW, I used them with 1TB drives, although not the controller you mentioned.
 
Well RAID 1 doesn't do any parity calculations, so you don't need a hardware card, the only benefit a hardware card would have is it's cache.
I thought the hardware RAID-1 cards would give a RAID-0 like speed boost during reads due to interleaving.
And you new idea is a better one, though ICHxR RAID 5 is software too and that does do a parity calc but software with the Core 2 might be faster than the old 7506.
I went forward with this idea and bought a ICH10R powered mobo + E5200. :eek: For file serving duties software RAID-5 has come a long way from where it was when I bought my 7506-8 many years ago.
 
In fact, I have a couple sitting in a box somewhere that I don't need anymore...would sell them cheap if you are interested. PM me for details...
Thanks for the offer, but I ended up going forward with Plan B. :eek:
 
I thought the hardware RAID-1 cards would give a RAID-0 like speed boost during reads due to interleaving.

Theoretically, yes.. No card that I am aware of ever has done this.

I went forward with this idea and bought a ICH10R powered mobo + E5200. :eek: For file serving duties software RAID-5 has come a long way from where it was when I bought my 7506-8 many years ago.

What will you use to be your server OS? Because an actual software RAID 5 has advantages over ICHxR RAID, like being able to move the drives to any other hardware without losing the data.
 
What will you use to be your server OS? Because an actual software RAID 5 has advantages over ICHxR RAID, like being able to move the drives to any other hardware without losing the data.
Probably XP, which nixes software RAID-5.
 
Back
Top