SATA DVD-RW, should I?

lgbr

Weaksauce
Joined
Mar 19, 2006
Messages
110
For the sake of advaning technology, I've been considering getting a SATA DVD-RW. Is this a good idea?

I don't do much with CD's or DVD's, just the occasional necessities. With the most important thing being accurate and reliable reading, what is a recommended DVD-RW drive?
 
Unless you're getting a 50x drive, I don't think it's a good idea. PATA may be slower but DVD writers aren't taking up the entire bandwidth yet. Maybe BluRay or HDDVD might, but frankly I'm not in the mood to spend 800 bucks on something that won't make that much of a difference since I'll have to pay 20-25 bucks per disc.

Suggest against the purchase.
 
The Plextor 716 has been the top of the line DVD burner for about 2 years now. It probably will be for a while longer. There is a PATA and SATA version of it. If there is a performance difference between the 2 it is probably negligable. But that isn't necessarily the only consideration.

Would you like to eliminate a big flat ribbon cable blocking airflow in your case? Would you like to have a drive you can use in 2 years when they start making mobos without PATA connectors? Would you like to hook it up (in an emergency maybe) to the external SATA connectors that come with new mobos?

No reason not to go SATA.
 
upriverpaddler said:
No reason not to go SATA.


The only reason I see not to get this particular model of Plextor is the product compatibility. Make sure your mobo SATA interface will work with this drive. Consult Plextor's compatibility chart and check other's experiences with your proposed drive/motherboard combination before purchase.

The Plexwriters are great, but the SATA still has a couple bugs that may stop you from having a great experience.
 
I'm in a similar situation as the poster, building a new PC and wondering to go SATA or not...


I decided not to go SATA. if you're worried about airflow, you can buy thin cables rather cheaply. One can easily get a reliable, tested DVD burner for a good price; might as well save the money and get an extra fan, a game, whatever.

Just my thoughts :)
 
You can always try those ide to sata convertors. I heard people have good sucess with those on nec drives.
 
Back
Top