SATA drives faster than IDE HDD's ?

wolf2009

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Messages
1,767
i have a WD IDE 250 GB HD . would a SATA drive be faster ?

how do i find what speed is my HDD . like 7200rpm or what ?
 
Go into Control panels, System, Device Manager tab. Under disk drives it will show your HD model. Google to model it will show you the specs. SATA hard drives are faster than IDE hard drives
 
1. Literally ALL consumer-level desktop drives for the last several years have been 7200 RPM. That's not really an issue, and the platter speed actually has little to do with it anymore (look at the WD Raptors, which at 10k RPM, have little performance gains for the reason I'm going to discuss below).

2. There is a speed difference between SATA (both I and II) and IDE, which comes from them being different protocols. IDE is a parallel interface, which like PCI and old-style parallel (printer) interfaces, is slower than the newer Serial standards. IDE gives at max 133 MB/s (about 1 Gbit/s) of transfer bandwidth. SATA I (the older SATA standard, of which, for instance, Raptor is a member) offers 1.5 Gbit/s and SATA II (the newest standard; almost all new SATA drives are SATA II) offers 3.0 Gbit/s, almost 3x the theoretical transfer speed of PATA.

Now, the biggest hurdle in hard drives today is seek time, which is usually the same for identical models independent of the connection. Also, cache can help increase performance.
 
at first, IDE and SATA had almost no diff, i remember it was a bit slower due to SATA implentation. But now, the drives are all developed for SATA2, so it will be faster.
 
1. Literally ALL consumer-level desktop drives for the last several years have been 7200 RPM. That's not really an issue, and the platter speed actually has little to do with it anymore (look at the WD Raptors, which at 10k RPM, have little performance gains for the reason I'm going to discuss below).

2. There is a speed difference between SATA (both I and II) and IDE, which comes from them being different protocols. IDE is a parallel interface, which like PCI and old-style parallel (printer) interfaces, is slower than the newer Serial standards. IDE gives at max 133 MB/s (about 1 Gbit/s) of transfer bandwidth. SATA I (the older SATA standard, of which, for instance, Raptor is a member) offers 1.5 Gbit/s and SATA II (the newest standard; almost all new SATA drives are SATA II) offers 3.0 Gbit/s, almost 3x the theoretical transfer speed of PATA.

Now, the biggest hurdle in hard drives today is seek time, which is usually the same for identical models independent of the connection. Also, cache can help increase performance.

Actually, there is almost no difference in a single drive configuration between sata and eide performance wise except the often nearly meaningless "burst" benchmark. Just what the hell are you bursting from cache anyway? And the fact that it takes the IDE drive 1/3 of a second to burst what tiny little is there as opposed 1/20 of a second for sata. Supposing that both drives are essentially identical except for the interface of course. Modern eide 133 drives are barely, if at all, slower when it comes to sequential reads/writes than sata drives are. Not really noticeable. Going from a 500gig seagate eide to the otherwise identical sata version would be hardly noticeable.

EIDE drives can loose performance, in some situations, when there are two drives on the same cable, (large read from one drive and write to the other on the same cable will be slower than drives on separate channels for instance).

The change to sata came about for reasons not wholly focused on performance. Possibility for very high speed external connections(e-sata), smaller cheaper connectors, thinner cheaper cables, less complicated (cheaper) circuit patterns on mobos and controller cards. While at the same time increasing the data rate far, far beyond anything the drives themselves can actually use, or the pci bus many controllers sit on can even transfer, currently (great for marketing).
SATA is better imho, but it is still not that much faster right now than eide 133 given a typical single drive config with a modern drive.

OP: if your WD is a modern eide/ata133 drive you will see virtually no improvement speed wise by switching to a 250gig WD sata drive.
 
^He's correct. Also consider that many people running Intel P35 boards and aren't using ACHI drivers from setup are usually running in DMA mode 5 -- that would be IDE emulation not true SATA which will give you mode 5. True ACHI SATA will give you mode 6 or mode 7.
 
When I got my new 500 gig 7200.11 a couple of months ago, it came configured for SATA 1 for compatibility reasons. I ran HDTune on it, and the burst speed was slightly faster than the peak sequential speed at around 105 MB/SEC. When I pulled the jumper to allow SATA II operation on my drive, the burst speed jumped to almost 190 MB/SEC.

Since Sata 1 is supposed to be 150 MB/SEC, and ATA133 is supposed to be 133 MB/SEC, we are finally seeing drives that can swamp the EIDE channel. And, by definition, SATA 1 is also nearing obsolescence, since it is only a bit faster than ATA133. Sata 1 was limiting my drive in real world performance to "ONLY" 105 MB/sec

Now, 100 MB/sec is still pretty good speed for current hard drives. If you already own the PATA drive, the performance increase to going to a SATA II drive in real life uses would be minimal. Not hardly worth the cost to upgrade.

When building a new rig, only buy a SATA II drive, period. A lot of the newer MOBOs only have 1 IDE channel. There is finally a good number of Sata optical drives out there, and they don't cost any more than the IDE models. I think the IDE channel will go away in another year or 2.

Don
 
Actually, there is almost no difference in a single drive configuration between sata and eide performance wise except the often nearly meaningless "burst" benchmark. Just what the hell are you bursting from cache anyway? And the fact that it takes the IDE drive 1/3 of a second to burst what tiny little is there as opposed 1/20 of a second for sata. Supposing that both drives are essentially identical except for the interface of course. Modern eide 133 drives are barely, if at all, slower when it comes to sequential reads/writes than sata drives are. Not really noticeable. Going from a 500gig seagate eide to the otherwise identical sata version would be hardly noticeable.

EIDE drives can loose performance, in some situations, when there are two drives on the same cable, (large read from one drive and write to the other on the same cable will be slower than drives on separate channels for instance).

The change to sata came about for reasons not wholly focused on performance. Possibility for very high speed external connections(e-sata), smaller cheaper connectors, thinner cheaper cables, less complicated (cheaper) circuit patterns on mobos and controller cards. While at the same time increasing the data rate far, far beyond anything the drives themselves can actually use, or the pci bus many controllers sit on can even transfer, currently (great for marketing).
SATA is better imho, but it is still not that much faster right now than eide 133 given a typical single drive config with a modern drive.

OP: if your WD is a modern eide/ata133 drive you will see virtually no improvement speed wise by switching to a 250gig WD sata drive.

Agreed. I also wonder how many people are unknowingly running in IDE emulation mode anyway. If you didn't load AHCI or RAID drivers, then your drive will be running emulated IDE, so no speed increase for you. Not that it would make much difference, as has already been stated. My first 7200 rpm drive was 4GB. I'm willing to bet my current drives will read 4GB much faster than the 4GB drive could have transferred the entire drive. Platter density is much more important than spindle speed. I'm sure a lot of the reason for the interface change was to force people to have to buy a new hard drive with that motherboard upgrade. And it will happen again.
 
When I got my new 500 gig 7200.11 a couple of months ago, it came configured for SATA 1 for compatibility reasons. I ran HDTune on it, and the burst speed was slightly faster than the peak sequential speed at around 105 MB/SEC. When I pulled the jumper to allow SATA II operation on my drive, the burst speed jumped to almost 190 MB/SEC.

Since Sata 1 is supposed to be 150 MB/SEC, and ATA133 is supposed to be 133 MB/SEC, we are finally seeing drives that can swamp the EIDE channel. And, by definition, SATA 1 is also nearing obsolescence, since it is only a bit faster than ATA133. Sata 1 was limiting my drive in real world performance to "ONLY" 105 MB/sec

Now, 100 MB/sec is still pretty good speed for current hard drives. If you already own the PATA drive, the performance increase to going to a SATA II drive in real life uses would be minimal. Not hardly worth the cost to upgrade.

When building a new rig, only buy a SATA II drive, period. A lot of the newer MOBOs only have 1 IDE channel. There is finally a good number of Sata optical drives out there, and they don't cost any more than the IDE models. I think the IDE channel will go away in another year or 2.

Don


You realize though, that burst speed tests are practically useless. If the data isn't in the hard drives cache, then you won't benefit from that 105MB/s much less 150 or 300. 16mb to cache 500GB isn't a whole of lot of space when you take into account the fragmentation that occurs within a filesystem.

And when you're transferring more than the cache size (if the data just so happens to cached that is), then you're limited to the how fast the drive can find, read, and analyze the data, which on a good drive is 60-80MB/s.
 
Agreed. I also wonder how many people are unknowingly running in IDE emulation mode anyway. If you didn't load AHCI or RAID drivers, then your drive will be running emulated IDE, so no speed increase for you. Not that it would make much difference, as has already been stated. My first 7200 rpm drive was 4GB. I'm willing to bet my current drives will read 4GB much faster than the 4GB drive could have transferred the entire drive. Platter density is much more important than spindle speed. I'm sure a lot of the reason for the interface change was to force people to have to buy a new hard drive with that motherboard upgrade. And it will happen again.

If they really wanted you to buy a new hard drive, why would "THEY" allow the MOBO manufacturers to continue to put IDE connectors on MOBOs?

Ok, take off the aluminum foil hats for a second. ;)

Sata was developed because it was becoming increasingly difficult to increase the speed of the parallel architecture of the IDE bus. It is the same reason they went from the parallel AGP bus to the serial based PCI Express bus. It is easier to scale up the speed of a serial connection. You do not have to synch all of the data lanes.

The only failure I see in SATA was not wiring in a few more data paths for future expansion in the original spec. While todays drives are just beginning to max out IDE 133 and Sata I, who knows what will be available in 10 or 20 years.

Ok, you can put your foil hats back on.

Don
 
If they really wanted you to buy a new hard drive, why would "THEY" allow the MOBO manufacturers to continue to put IDE connectors on MOBOs?

Ok, take off the aluminum foil hats for a second. ;)

Sata was developed because it was becoming increasingly difficult to increase the speed of the parallel architecture of the IDE bus. It is the same reason they went from the parallel AGP bus to the serial based PCI Express bus. It is easier to scale up the speed of a serial connection. You do not have to synch all of the data lanes.

The only failure I see in SATA was not wiring in a few more data paths for future expansion in the original spec. While todays drives are just beginning to max out IDE 133 and Sata I, who knows what will be available in 10 or 20 years.

Ok, you can put your foil hats back on.

Don

That and people wanting more drives (for raid, storage limitations, etc) meant that more IDE channels had to be added to the motherboards. A single IDE channel require around 28-40 PCB traces (depending on how they connect the ground pins), two require 55-80 traces and that only gets you 4 devices. With Sata, you can get up to 16 ports with the same trace count as two IDE channels.
 
If they really wanted you to buy a new hard drive, why would "THEY" allow the MOBO manufacturers to continue to put IDE connectors on MOBOs?

For legacy support - they don't want to put people off upgrading by forcing them to upgrade every component. Many people will want to get a new mobo/proc/mem but not change their HDD or opticals.

OP: changing to a SATA drive of the same capacity would see only a tiny performance increase. If you want a HDD upgrade and have SATA ports, i'd recommend a WD6400KS, which would be faster.
 
sata's interface is a big advance.

Agreed.

I'm almost tempted to go out and buy a freakin' Sata DVD writer. My current IDE drive is perfectly fine but having this large and cumbersome cable traveling down my case is a little annoying. :/
 
Agreed.

I'm almost tempted to go out and buy a freakin' Sata DVD writer. My current IDE drive is perfectly fine but having this large and cumbersome cable traveling down my case is a little annoying. :/


I know what you mean :D
that's why I only connect my drive when I have to, when I install Windows once a year.
 
If you want better performance and you've got alot money to throw around, go SCSI. Nothing says fantastic like SCSI drives. Unlike IDE and SATA, SCSI can read and write at the same time. Plus, all SCSI drives are 15k RPM so they'll have fast timings. The bad thing is they are crazy expensive and are mostly used in corporate servers.
 
It is the same reason they went from the parallel AGP bus to the serial based PCI Express bus.

Just to nitpick, and I saw this a lot back when PCIe was first coming out: PCIe is designed to replace PCI, not AGP, though it had the added bonus of being more powerful (in 16x mode) than AGP, hence why graphics card manufactures started using it :p

As to the HDDs stuff, I acknowledge my mistake after doing some more reading.

If you've got IDE drives already and they're doing you fine, don't bother upgrading. If you do upgrade though, get SATA.

If you want better performance and you've got alot money to throw around, go SCSI. Nothing says fantastic like SCSI drives. Unlike IDE and SATA, SCSI can read and write at the same time. Plus, all SCSI drives are 15k RPM so they'll have fast timings. The bad thing is they are crazy expensive and are mostly used in corporate servers.

SCSI, no. SAS, yes. SAS is Serial Attached SCSI, and it's the new generation of SCSI. It uses the same connectors as SATA and is backwards compatible so SATA drives work perfectly with SAS controllers. The drives are 15k RPM with lower seek times and much longer lifetimes. But they are expensive as fuck. Don't go with the old-school ribbon SCSI, it's worthless compared to the new stuff ;)
 
Actually, there is almost no difference in a single drive configuration between sata and eide performance wise except the often nearly meaningless "burst" benchmark. Just what the hell are you bursting from cache anyway? And the fact that it takes the IDE drive 1/3 of a second to burst what tiny little is there as opposed 1/20 of a second for sata. Supposing that both drives are essentially identical except for the interface of course. Modern eide 133 drives are barely, if at all, slower when it comes to sequential reads/writes than sata drives are. Not really noticeable. Going from a 500gig seagate eide to the otherwise identical sata version would be hardly noticeable.

EIDE drives can loose performance, in some situations, when there are two drives on the same cable, (large read from one drive and write to the other on the same cable will be slower than drives on separate channels for instance).

The change to sata came about for reasons not wholly focused on performance. Possibility for very high speed external connections(e-sata), smaller cheaper connectors, thinner cheaper cables, less complicated (cheaper) circuit patterns on mobos and controller cards. While at the same time increasing the data rate far, far beyond anything the drives themselves can actually use, or the pci bus many controllers sit on can even transfer, currently (great for marketing).
SATA is better imho, but it is still not that much faster right now than eide 133 given a typical single drive config with a modern drive.

OP: if your WD is a modern eide/ata133 drive you will see virtually no improvement speed wise by switching to a 250gig WD sata drive.
I came to this threading hoping someone had pointed this out.
Another thing to note when you see anecdotal reports of "I upgraded to SATA and it's so much faster!!!!!1" is to keep in mind a couple things.
1) Often just doing a clean install of windows will speed things up.
2) The specs of the new drive are likely better than the old one, which is the reason for increased performance, not the change in interface. If you took a WD1500ADFD Raptor, the fastest SATA drive available, and some how connected it via IDE, no one would be able to tell a difference without the help of diagnostic software.
 
If they really wanted you to buy a new hard drive, why would "THEY" allow the MOBO manufacturers to continue to put IDE connectors on MOBOs?

Ok, take off the aluminum foil hats for a second. ;)

Sata was developed because it was becoming increasingly difficult to increase the speed of the parallel architecture of the IDE bus. It is the same reason they went from the parallel AGP bus to the serial based PCI Express bus. It is easier to scale up the speed of a serial connection. You do not have to synch all of the data lanes.

The only failure I see in SATA was not wiring in a few more data paths for future expansion in the original spec. While todays drives are just beginning to max out IDE 133 and Sata I, who knows what will be available in 10 or 20 years.

Ok, you can put your foil hats back on.

Don

But I like the hat. :p

Anyway, they are all still limited to the PCI bus bandwidth in most cases. And when they get faster, there will be a different interface. I think the connectors suck. They need something that fits together better, especially on the drive end.

AGP sucked. That's why they replaced that. Duh, what aperture size should I use? Duh, the AGP bus has a latency of 255, and it is choking my pci bus. You notice that pcie has eliminated questions and comments like that.
 
Back
Top