sata card and hd, or ide?

Joined
Apr 10, 2002
Messages
3,306
ok, i think i am going to break down and buy a HD and a CD burner for my computer.. and i am asking to see if it is worth it to pay $30 for an sata controller then a few more bucks for the molex = power converter... or jsut get an ide drive..

will it make much difference? also, do some sata drives have ide connectors and sata on them, and/or both kinds of power connecters?

basically how fast is sata, and how fast is ide?
i don't know how foreseeable it is that i will actually upgrade to a computer that has sata in the near future.. is sata here to stay for a while? or will it be gone like rambus if i do decide to upgrade to a sata mobo a year or more down the road?

also... what other sata devices are there, or are there going to be? because some of the cards have external sata ports on them..

thanks

scott
 
Unless you plan on purchasing a Western Digital Raptor for your hard drive, i'd DEFINATLY stay with IDE. The speed difference is minimal if any at all with the majority of SATA vs. IDE drives (excluding Raptors). IDE is cheaper, you already have the ports on the mobo, no extra adapters, and the hard drives themselves are cheaper as well.

Now the WD Raptor SATA drives are faster because they are 10K rpm and had a 4.5ms seek time (74GB version). So unless you go all out and pick yourself up a Raptor, your wasting your time with SATA over IDE. Also, if you plan to upgrade motherboards in the near future, nearly all new mobo's come with SATA now anyway, and also if you do buy a Raptor, they utilise both SATA power or the standard 4-pin molex connector.

Edit: for comparison, the majority of other SATA drives and IDE drives are 7200 RPM and have about an 8.2ms seek time.
 
For the time being, if you don't have SATA ports on your mobo, I'd say you could do without SATA drives, unless you were looking at Raptors.

Most SATA and IDE drives are pretty similar in performance, even though SATA drives now are ATA/150 and the IDE drives are ATA/100 or ATA/133. That makes no difference though; both kinds of drives don't exceed ATA/66 MB/s transfer speeds anyway.

SATA drives don't have IDE connectors on them. You'd need to use a bridge to get them to use IDE cables. And similarly, they don't have both kinds of power connectors on the drive (unless they released drives that have recently, but I don't think so).

Also, SATA is the future. IDE is going to be phased out next year as mobos switch over to SATA. It's not like Rambus because SATA is going to be industry standard; it's not a proprietary technology.

Optical devices will probably be SATA sooner or later, but it'd be less useful for them since they only top about ATA/33 anyways.
 
ok, well.. i was looking and thought that sata and ide cost about the same..

so i guess i will modify my question now.

does an 8mb cache make much of a difference over a 2mb cache? and does brand name matter much? should i get a white label magnetic? or a WD, or Seagate?
i am probably going to get the most bang for the buck which seems to be about a 120 gig for $90 - $100.

and is a lower seek time or higher seek time better? 8.2ms, 9.2ms etc...

thanks

scott
 
Originally posted by scottatwittenberg

does an 8mb cache make much of a difference over a 2mb cache? and does brand name matter much? should i get a white label magnetic? or a WD, or Seagate?

and is a lower seek time or higher seek time better? 8.2ms, 9.2ms etc...


8 MB cache makes a big difference for a main drive, since the drive can store more data in cache for quicker access. 2 MB cache is fine if you're going strictly for a storage drive. But always try to get an 8 MB cache drive, the performance gain is worth the extra few bucks.

Brand name matters since the companies have proven records. I wouldn't trust my data to a generic drive maker. Western Digital makes one of the best 120 GB drives, the WD1200JB (8 MB cache version), and they're the hard drive company I tend to go with. Seagate makes quiet drives.

And yes, lower seek times are better.
 
ok, i just looked at the egg... they have a hitatchi 120 gig with 8mb cache and 8.2ms seek time..

they WD special edition is $5 more and has a 8.9ms seek..

will i notice a difference between the two??

how are hitatchi and ibm related? i had an ibm and never had a problem with it..
 
Back
Top