SATA cable length.. need some opinions here

Cryptic1911

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jul 6, 2004
Messages
226
Ok here's the deal.. I bought a pci express sata / sas raid card for my server. It has an external sas (4x sata path), and an internal (4x sas / sata). I want to run my drives in a 2nd old pc case that i have since I am watercooling the server itself. I found some sas to sata converters that bolt into a pci slot for the "external drive" case, but my issue is that I can only find .5 meter external sas cables, and .5 meter internal sas to sata, meaning i'd be at 1meter in length once I hit the external case (not including cable inside to hdd's) when i'm using the internal port on the card, and I'm not talking eSata.. this is regular sata just getting gender changed basiclly, and I'm worried that I'll be at the end of the usable length and have speed / integrity issues... what do you guys think?
 
my first message wasn't too clear, but here's a retry:

I want to run an sas cable off of the external port, to an sas to sata bridge on the 2nd case. this should be fine as the ext cable is .5m, so i'd be within 1m length after running internal sata cables to the drives

the INTERNAL sas port, I can only find a .5m cable to go from the raid card to an sas-sata bridge (in the server) to .5m external cable, to sas-sata bridge in 2nd case. I'm already at 1m by the time I hit the 2nd case.. so on the inside to the drives is going to be over the 1m limit. will I be in trouble? or will it probably just work?
 
SAS uses higher signaling voltages (800-1600 mV TX, 275-1600 mV RX) than SATA (400-600 mV TX, 325-600 mV RX).

Because of its higher signaling voltages, SAS can use cables up to 8 m (25 ft) long, SATA is limited to 1 m (3 ft).

source - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serial_Attached_SCSI

the length is no problem from the first eSAS port to the eSAS to sata converter, the converter does a voltage drop on it which brings it back to normal voltage, so this bridge counts as an endpoint, so the drive will see it as proper voltage and work fine.

hope this helps answer your question

in my opinion it would work wonderfully, and I like your idea.
 
Thanks for the replies guys.

The sata multiplier is a cool idea, but with the card I have, I'd have to get custom cables made to use the eSata inputs

as for the higher voltages on sas, that does make sense, and now that I think about it, it should be running the higher voltage from the card to the converter board in the server case.

It would only be lower voltage for the .5m external sas cable, and whatever is inside the 2nd case with the drives.. so i'll be under the 1m anyways.

I'll post up pics of the project once I get the project going
 
Back
Top