SAS vs VRaptor vs SSD

sdlvx

Gawd
Joined
Dec 9, 2007
Messages
567
Hey guys, I've been lusting for a little more IO performance on my O/S drive.

I have some money from amazon gift cards and I was thinking about putting that towards an upgrade for my hard drives.

I have an Asus p6t deluxe, so I have an SAS controller. I've been torn between a Cheetah 15k.6 73GB (when it shows up on amazon), a Fujitsu MBA(forgot the numbers), and a Velociraptor.

SSDs would like to be avoided because I think they're still too expensive and I don't think it's mature enough. It's too new of a technology on the whole for me to want to dive into.

I just need it for the OS disk. I'd like to keep it under 300 dollars total for the update (I am considering RAID as well, with 2 15k.6s. Right now my Vista x64 is sitting on a Spinpoint F1 1TB drive. Is this upgrade even worth it?

Thanks.
 
I'm curious about this as well, especially since I also own a P6T Deluxe.
 
I don't think the VRaptor would be worth it. Faster access time than your F1, but that's about it, and not enough to justify the price, for me anyway. The SAS drive would from a speed standpoint, but not as far as space per dollar. If I were doing it that would be the option I would go with though. I agree with you on the SSD, too immature at this point. Doesn't flash memory still have a limited lifespan for rewrites?
 
I'm not overly concerned about the price per dollar. I have over 2TB of total HD space. I just want enough space for Vista on a really fast device.
 
SSDs, say an OCZ Vertex. Everything else (Velociraptor/Cheetah) can't catch up.
 
Doubt you'll be able to get 2 15k.6 drives for under 300. You can easily get 2 15k.5 for under 300 on ebay.
 
You really cant go wrong with the raptor's. I've had my two 74gb's in raid 0 for the last 4-5 years and they are running perfectly with no signs of stopping anytime soon.
 
You really cant go wrong with the raptor's. I've had my two 74gb's in raid 0 for the last 4-5 years and they are running perfectly with no signs of stopping anytime soon.

Raptors, especially the 74's have been amazing drives. WD really was ahead of the game.

I still love mine, all 8.

That being said, the new VelociRaptors or high end SAS drives crap all over our old ones.
 
The durability of the HDDs over SSDs makes me want to stick to HDDs. SSD still has some problems and I don't want to be stuck with something that isn't what it used to be in two years.

I'm guessing Fujitsu MBAs are just as good as the 15k.6s, right?

I've been poking around, for anyone following this thread. It seems like RAID 0 gives an increase of usually 10-50%.

The 15k.5 in RAID 0 would then be pretty similiar to a 15k.6.

And for the SSDs, I know they are faster but I'm pretty concerned about their lifespans as well as performance degredation. Also I remember reading about Vista and SSDs not playing well together. Is that still the case? I know I'll probably catch some flack, but I'd like to stay with Vista.

EDIT:

Also, a 147GB 15k.6 is cheaper than 2 15k.5s, and they're about even if you ebay the 15k.5s and you buy the 15k.6 new from google product search.
 
Can you SSD guys recommend some SSDs for me that would be competitive with a 15k.6 and similar in price?
 
Current SSD to look at:
Intel X25-M 80GB ------------ $363.00 --------- 250 Read/70 Write
Vertex 60GB ------------------- $245.00 --------- 200 Read/160 Write
Samsung SLC 32GB -------- $149.99 --------- 100 Read/80 Write
 
What are you using the drives for?

SSD's are the future, but after seeing the [H]ard video review of the Intel X25-M SSD, the future is not now. Especially for the price tag.
 
current ssds that are mentioned in this thread are no more reliable than hard drives because the ssds break down over time too

go check the mtbf on a velociraptor and compare it to the mtbf on an ocz ssd, I dare you
 
current ssds that are mentioned in this thread are no more reliable than hard drives because the ssds break down over time too

go check the mtbf on a velociraptor and compare it to the mtbf on an ocz ssd, I dare you
The MTBF on my SSD is 2 million hours. Not even the highest end enterprise drives are that high. It really depends on what you get. WD doesn't list the MTBF on the Velociraptor by the way.
shake your vraptor when it's running.

I dare you.
Won't really do much. The drive should park the heads before any damage is done.
 
You kids, always gotta stir up shit. I have a bunch of hard drives sitting here that are connected to any given machine using a Kingwin USB to SATA/ATA converter keeping the drives external. I've got a Velociraptor here beside me and I just shook it, as if it would do anything... seriously, find something better to do if all you're planning is posting something from a negative perspective.

There are SCSI drives out there, 15K rpm, and they've been in operation for 10 years in some machines, I've owned a few myself and they stayed running 24/7 for 8 years in one server, without one issue, and to be honest they're probably still running today with the new owner(s).

Don't start even trying to spread FUD about hard drive technology "just because" SSD is the new kid on the block. SSD hasn't proven itself to be reliable long term - that means decades, kids, not the barely 2 years they've been on the market. Hard drive technology has matured over the 50+ years it's been out, and it's actually still improving, especially in the past 2-3 years. Look at the WD 640GB models, lightning fast, almost up to par with the Velociraptors and they're only 7200 rpm.

Imagine what one of those could do if it ran at 10K rpms...

But seriously, if your intention is to lambast physical hard drives, move on. You're in the wrong place for it...
 
I'm staring to lean towards a 30gb x2 Vertex system. I just read that SSDs have linear scaling in RAID stripes, is that true?

vertex 30GB is 150 on amazon with 20 dollars off (but it's out of stock, I don'tknow if it's one of those lame marketing tricks they're doing). I have 50 dollars in an amazon gift card.

I could pull this off for a little over 200.

Would it be possible to shrink my Vista partition that's 75GB to 60GB, and copy it over to the SSDs? ICH10R will work fine with these two in RAID with a bunch of other HDs on the SATAs?
 
Vista can shrink/expand the system volume, sure, it's one of the things you can do now with that OS or Windows 7 without needing third party partitioning tools to do it. But 60GB for Vista, or Windows 7... that won't last long as both OSes grow over time just from updates and constant backups made of system files whenever a change is made to one (in the WinSxS folder, there's plenty of info about it easily located through Google searches).

Even if you didn't install anything on the 60GB system partition except the OS itself, a clean install of Vista/Windows 7 would probably end up using most of that space in a few months time, so, if you're planning to move towards SSD hardware, plan for the future, not the immediate present. Think of whatever you believe you'll need for space and double it, and that's what you should be shooting for with an SSD, so a 128MB model (or two) would be the ticket...
 
Thanks for all the help Joe and everyone else. I really appreciate it.

It looks like I'm going to be best off with two 15k.5s in RAID 0 given my budget. I could pull it off and end up with about 150GB of total storage, which should be more than enough for Vista (I would hope).
 
My advice, since this appears to be a luxury purchase and not a need-to-have, is to wait six months if those gift cards don't expire. The market is changing so rapidly. I too am a little nervous about SSD at this time, mostly due to the almost weekly "discoveries" about SSD configuration, optimization, OS-integration, and so forth. Nonetheless, I'm fully expecting those qualms to disappear within six to nine months. I know that if I were to buy either a SSD or a 15k spinning disk today, I would regret either purchase 12 months from now.
 
Thanks for all the help Joe and everyone else. I really appreciate it.

It looks like I'm going to be best off with two 15k.5s in RAID 0 given my budget. I could pull it off and end up with about 150GB of total storage, which should be more than enough for Vista (I would hope).

I'd still say go with two Velociraptors, actually. Contact FLECOM here at this forum, he's one of the Mods, and see if he's got any 80GB Velociraptors left or expecting any sometime soon. I got 2 from him and I love 'em. And they typically outperform most anything out there, including a lot of 15K SCSI hardware:

http://www.storagereview.com/Testbed4Compare.sr

Hit that and check the results for the 300GB Velociraptor and realize the 80GB models like these I have are faster because of their shortstroked nature. Slap 'em together in RAID 0 and you get superior performance for one helluvalot less money than those 15K SCSI drives will end up costing you (and don't even get me started on the controllers, unless you've already got one you're looking at even more moolah).
 
I'd still say go with two Velociraptors, actually. Contact FLECOM here at this forum, he's one of the Mods, and see if he's got any 80GB Velociraptors left or expecting any sometime soon. I got 2 from him and I love 'em. And they typically outperform most anything out there, including a lot of 15K SCSI hardware:

http://www.storagereview.com/Testbed4Compare.sr

Hit that and check the results for the 300GB Velociraptor and realize the 80GB models like these I have are faster because of their shortstroked nature. Slap 'em together in RAID 0 and you get superior performance for one helluvalot less money than those 15K SCSI drives will end up costing you (and don't even get me started on the controllers, unless you've already got one you're looking at even more moolah).

I was hoping to stay on amazon.com because i have 50 dollars in gift cards.

Got the controller, but it's the marvel one built into the Asus P6T Deluxe motherboard. I know that adaptec makes the best controllers (why Asus loves to throw Marvel crap on their boards in unknown to me), but I don't know how this marvel one stacks up.

I found some 15k.5s for cheap, I think as a price/performance ratio I can't beat it provided I'm not getting ripped off.

And of course I know that things will be way better on the SSD front in a few months, but I have a major boner to upgrade (I feel like my I7 is just waiting for data to crunch all the time).

Not to mention SSDs don't make noise and I like to hear my computer make noises because it makes my internet penis feel really, really big.
 
I was hoping to stay on amazon.com because i have 50 dollars in gift cards.

Got the controller, but it's the marvel one built into the Asus P6T Deluxe motherboard. I know that adaptec makes the best controllers (why Asus loves to throw Marvel crap on their boards in unknown to me), but I don't know how this marvel one stacks up.

I found some 15k.5s for cheap, I think as a price/performance ratio I can't beat it provided I'm not getting ripped off.

And of course I know that things will be way better on the SSD front in a few months, but I have a major boner to upgrade (I feel like my I7 is just waiting for data to crunch all the time).

Not to mention SSDs don't make noise and I like to hear my computer make noises because it makes my internet penis feel really, really big.

Ok, that explains the leaning towards the 15K SCSI then, no problem. As for the:

"Adaptec makes the best controllers" - Areca owners would have issues with that statement... even some Highpoint owners depending on the specific piece of hardware in question, and other brands too. :) And...

"why Asus loves to throw Marvel crap on their boards in unknown to me" - Marvel works, gets the job done, and doesn't nearly double the cost of the entire mobo as putting an actual Adaptec chip on one can do, as past history has shown. A decent mobo without SCSI at all, a given price. Slap an Adaptec chip on it for SCSI capability, bam, literally 80% markup on the entire mobo... seriously. It's sad but that's what happens when people put your products on top. :)

Good luck...
 
yeah, I wouldn't consider using anything less than 100gb for an OS hdd nowadays.
 
*sigh* yes, obviously I messed that up.

My actual point still stands, a HDD has physical moving parts - it is inherently less robust than an SSD.

Does that make SSD's perfect? No. Would I swap out my 9 TB of HDD's for SSD? Not at today's costs.

For the record I would go with the 2x30g Vertex as first choice, and 2x80g vraptors as second choice. That's my personal choice. If the OP can get the vraptors from flecom that might push it up to first choice.
 
Are there any decent and cheap SAS controllers - just something to run 1 or 2 drives without bottlenecking it ?
 
current ssds that are mentioned in this thread are no more reliable than hard drives because the ssds break down over time too

go check the mtbf on a velociraptor and compare it to the mtbf on an ocz ssd, I dare you

MTBF doesn't mean much, trust me.
 
You kids, always gotta stir up shit. I have a bunch of hard drives sitting here that are connected to any given machine using a Kingwin USB to SATA/ATA converter keeping the drives external. I've got a Velociraptor here beside me and I just shook it, as if it would do anything... seriously, find something better to do if all you're planning is posting something from a negative perspective.

There are SCSI drives out there, 15K rpm, and they've been in operation for 10 years in some machines, I've owned a few myself and they stayed running 24/7 for 8 years in one server, without one issue, and to be honest they're probably still running today with the new owner(s).

Don't start even trying to spread FUD about hard drive technology "just because" SSD is the new kid on the block. SSD hasn't proven itself to be reliable long term - that means decades, kids, not the barely 2 years they've been on the market. Hard drive technology has matured over the 50+ years it's been out, and it's actually still improving, especially in the past 2-3 years. Look at the WD 640GB models, lightning fast, almost up to par with the Velociraptors and they're only 7200 rpm.

Imagine what one of those could do if it ran at 10K rpms...

But seriously, if your intention is to lambast physical hard drives, move on. You're in the wrong place for it...

SSDs have existed since the 1970s..

Also only on a consumer level has it gone mainstream in the past few years. SSDs have been used for a long time.

http://www.ramsan.com/products/ramsan-5000.htm Enterprise/Datacenter level.
 
I'm staring to lean towards a 30gb x2 Vertex system. I just read that SSDs have linear scaling in RAID stripes, is that true?

vertex 30GB is 150 on amazon with 20 dollars off (but it's out of stock, I don'tknow if it's one of those lame marketing tricks they're doing). I have 50 dollars in an amazon gift card.

I could pull this off for a little over 200.

Would it be possible to shrink my Vista partition that's 75GB to 60GB, and copy it over to the SSDs? ICH10R will work fine with these two in RAID with a bunch of other HDs on the SATAs?

If you do go with Vertex (either a single 60gb or 3x30GB RAID 0) you would be best off doing a clean install (and a lot of reading on the OCZ forum). This is a fun project, but there are a few things involved. You need to delete the partition that comes on the drive indisk managment, align your partition using diskpart (128k for single SSD), format using 4096 byte allocation unit size in disk management console, then do a clean install of vista onto the partition you created in your other OS without deleting it. Once you are all loaded up and happy, you need to disable defrag (super critical step) for that drive (and indexing too). If you don't do it this way you will have problems. There are also many other registry and services tweaks that will give you varying levels of results (like disabling superfetch etc).

RAID is even more complicated and there are lots of different combos of alignment, allocation unit, and block sizes to worry about, so read up first and you won't have to repeat. Also don't forget to flash to firmware 1199 first thing (assuming your new drive won't come with it) there is a huge performace increase in writes.

My Vertex Thread
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1401287
 
Back
Top