SAS Controller/HBA Card for Home Server upgrade

Joined
Jul 24, 2017
Messages
6
Hi all,

I'm looking to upgrade my old home server (built circa 2008), for two reasons:
1) Support for larger HDDs >4TBs
2) Improved processing power for PLEX transcoding that runs on the server

As the title suggests, my main question right now is on the SAS controller. Most of the threads I've seen are older and reference the same cards IBM M1015/1115, LSI 9211/9240/9260, Supermicro SAS2LP-MV8, etc. Has not much changed in the past 8-10 years or is it that my requirements are so low it doesn't really matter? I don't need RAID, and this is a home environment so cache seems to be an unnecessary expense. Really I want something that supports 16 drives on my Norco backplanes (so likely 2 cards), works with larger drives so I can upgrade in-place, and doesn't have bandwidth/throttling issues.

Ultimately I'll be replacing the core components on the server...current specs are below if you're interested. I'm pretty much starting from scratch so any thoughts you have are welcome. It's been a long time since I researched all this so my knowledge is a bit dated.

Thanks in advance!

Current Rig:
OS: WHS 2011 (reuse)
Case: Norco RPC 4220 (reuse)
HDDs: 20 drives of varying sizes, with one SSD for the OS (reuse)
Motherboard: ASUS P5BV-M (replace)
Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo (replace)
RAM: 8GB (replace)
PSU: 650W Antec Earthwatts (replace)
SAS Card: 2x Supermicro SASLP-MV8 w/SFF 8087 connectors to the Norco backplanes (replace?)
 
I have been using LSI 9211-8i+ HP SAS Expander combination in my 2 servers + 2 x Norco RPC 4224... @ PC Hardware level everything has been running really smoothly and those parts i can recommend ^^
 
I'm still new to working with "professional grade" drive enclosures on servers myself. (Posted a question in here myself about issues getting an LSI SAS card working properly with FreeNAS on an HP MicroServer.)

But from what I've been able to determine so far? The "latest and greatest" technology in SAS controllers is irrelevant for products like FreeNAS, Nas4Free or really, most Linux server environments. That's because the features you pay more for and which change regularly mainly have to do with on-board RAID support, which you're better off disabling in these environments. (Zfs file systems are best at handling "raw" access to drives, without some hardware controller trying to manage them independently.)

The most important feature seems to be whether a given card handles 3gb/sec, 6gb/sec, or 12gb/sec transfer speeds to keep up with whatever drives you're planning on attaching to it. (Plus, it looks to me like a lot of the hardware only capable of 3gb/sec is old enough so it has other chipset limitations preventing it from using drives larger than 2TB - which rules them out as usable in many modern scenarios.)
 
I have been using LSI 9211-8i+ HP SAS Expander combination in my 2 servers + 2 x Norco RPC 4224... ^^

I have heard good things about the 9211 series, or that due to price people were buying the IBM M10151115 and flashing their firmware to 9211. Is there any merit to getting a newer model, assuming price is close enough? For example, I can find the 9211-8i on Amazon for $90. 9240-8i for $100, and the 9260-8i for $140.

As an aside do you have any pics of your setup? Are you running the second 4224 off the cards in the main server or running two identical machines?

Zfs file systems are best at handling "raw" access to drives, without some hardware controller trying to manage them independently. The most important feature seems to be whether a given card handles 3gb/sec, 6gb/sec, or 12gb/sec transfer speeds to keep up with whatever drives you're planning on attaching to it.

This is exactly it. I'm going the ZFS route and windows home server has software duplication so I'm as protected as I need to be...as my critical docs are backed up via AWS offsite. The fancy features seem unnecessary to me, but maybe there is something to warrant a specific variant...such as ongoing support or compatibility? Once WHS goes away for good I'm not entirely sure what I'll use for the OS.
 
the dell perc H310 and H200 are both LSI cards and can be flashed with LSI firmware. and support 6gbs and large drives.

when using ZFS, make 100% sure that the firmware you load on the card matches the driver version that you are using on the systems OS.
 
the dell perc H310 and H200 are both LSI cards and can be flashed with LSI firmware. and support 6gbs and large drives.

Can you help me understand why use something like the H310 or H200 and flash IT mode rather than using the LSI equivalent? Is this just a cost thing or are there other features? Based on a quick search they both flash to LSI SAS 2008, (9211-8i ) If this is the case, whats a 'good' price on the Dells?

thanks!
 
Can you help me understand why use something like the H310 or H200 and flash IT mode rather than using the LSI equivalent? Is this just a cost thing or are there other features? Based on a quick search they both flash to LSI SAS 2008, (9211-8i ) If this is the case, whats a 'good' price on the Dells?

thanks!

you're not going to get an LSI card for 35 dollars that's why.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Dell-PERC-H...troller-Dell-P-N-HV52W-w-Cables-/382175199139
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
As an aside do you have any pics of your setup? Are you running the second 4224 off the cards in the main server or running two identical machines?

Heya.. Sorry for late answer! Here is couple of old pics from my servers.. atm i have 2 different systems.. in the future i am planning to use 3 boxes in 1 OS.. 1 master box with 2 slaves.. :)

http://imgur.com/vnVc0rk My first norco :)

http://imgur.com/Bo3xHWH Second norco :)
 
yeah i have had 2 h310's online for about 3 solid years in a home built VM system with freenas in passthrough for the storage. and the write/read rate at my house is higher than some medium duty enterprise systems i manage at work. i use the h310 simply for the cost, it is 1/4th the cost and when you flash the firmware it is identical to the LSI part. i have a 3rd h310 card in a drawer as a spare, i have never needed it but i did use it one time to shorten my firmware upgrade cycle on the server. i got all 3 for the cost of 1 real LSI card.

also if you need a chassis, find a used chenbro, they are way better quality than the norco stuff. (not ragging on norco, it is a great platform.)
 
The card in my signature has been working flawlessly with 16 mix of 2TB and 4TB drives for the last 3 years.
 
Looks good -- Here's my setup: https://imgur.com/a/Vdb6p

I envy your extra HDD -- I only had 4 SATA ports on the board that came with my case -- so I was capped at 20 drives rather than 20+1.


We all have to start from somewhere and build little by little ;) I and many more once started from bottom and start growing bit by bit ;) some even lost few screws down the road and got crazy ;) :D

You have nice build to start with!
 
Back
Top