routing between VLANs

hellosky

Weaksauce
Joined
Mar 28, 2010
Messages
111
I'm looking into getting the Cisco SRW2016 (Sg300 series) switch for my network.

Since this is not a layer 3 switch, can I hook it up to a computer and run a firewall distro to do the routing between VLANs? How would I go about doing this - do I just add the VLANs in the routing table?

Can I throw in 802.1q radius authentication for dynamic VLANs as well?
 
You'll need something that supports it (router on a stick), I think pfsense does, but not sure.

For the second question, you're talking about dot1x, not dot1q. You will need to look at the specs of your switch to see if it's supported.
 
The SG300 series definitely supports dot1x. I was thinking of running freeradius as the server within the firewall OS and use that to assign VLANs depending on MAC ID.

So any of the firewall OS such as pfsense, untangle, etc will be able to handle the routing between VLANs? for the desktop PC I assume I need to get a gigabit NIC that can handle VLAN tagging/trunk?.
 
you could get a router to do ROAS, as long as the nic on the router is fast ethernet you will be fine. 100 meg or gigabit, is what you need for router on a stick. But, i'm sure you already knew that.
 
The SG300 series definitely supports dot1x. I was thinking of running freeradius as the server within the firewall OS and use that to assign VLANs depending on MAC ID.

So any of the firewall OS such as pfsense, untangle, etc will be able to handle the routing between VLANs? for the desktop PC I assume I need to get a gigabit NIC that can handle VLAN tagging/trunk?.


So you are trying to run a NAC system as well I take it? You might be better off getting a old 2600 series or better router off EBAY that can do subinterfaces for Router on a Stick.

One thing to note, a program called PacketFence is a popular NAC solution that works with a lot of Cisco equipment.
 
So you are trying to run a NAC system as well I take it? You might be better off getting a old 2600 series or better router off EBAY that can do subinterfaces for Router on a Stick.

One thing to note, a program called PacketFence is a popular NAC solution that works with a lot of Cisco equipment.

best user name ever. lol
 
So you are trying to run a NAC system as well I take it? You might be better off getting a old 2600 series or better router off EBAY that can do subinterfaces for Router on a Stick.

One thing to note, a program called PacketFence is a popular NAC solution that works with a lot of Cisco equipment.

Yes. I am looking to run a router and NAC system. Unfortunately I want gigabit so I don't think the 2600 series has those...

PacketFence looks awesome. Is this a whole OS or does it need to run top of Linux? This looks better than pfSense or the other firewall distros...
 
Yes. I am looking to run a router and NAC system. Unfortunately I want gigabit so I don't think the 2600 series has those...

PacketFence looks awesome. Is this a whole OS or does it need to run top of Linux? This looks better than pfSense or the other firewall distros...

From what I remember when I set it up last year, PacketFence is a complete distribution. 2600 usually has one Gigabyte port built in and can easily add in cards with more. Just make sure if you go the PacketFence route, you get a compatible switch, which is a good amount of the popular ones.
 
Damn SG300 series aren't listed ... is this because they never tested it? Does the software require specific functionality inside the Cisco IOS?
 
From what I remember when I set it up last year, PacketFence is a complete distribution. 2600 usually has one Gigabyte port built in and can easily add in cards with more. Just make sure if you go the PacketFence route, you get a compatible switch, which is a good amount of the popular ones.

2600s don't have built-in gigabit ports, nor do they support any gig WIC/NM that I'm aware of. Even if they did, it would be pointless considering the throughput that router supports.
 
I think the only thing reasonable is the 2970G ... are the fans loud on this unit?
 
Back
Top