Rosetta Stone Sues Google

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Rosetta Stone, the popular language-learning software, is suing Google for trademark violation, according to Reuters. The suit revolves around Google’s AdWords program and how it allows third parties to purchase the right to use trademarks in the advertising program. Rosetta Stone sued some other companies for a similar issue last year.

Rosetta Stone's General Counsel Michael Wu said, "Google's search engine is helping third parties mislead consumers and misappropriate Rosetta Stone trademarks by using them as 'keyword' triggers for paid advertisements and by using them within the text or title of paid advertisements."
 
Google got sued for something like this before. I think it was framed differently, but it was essentially the same issue.

They won last time, I don't see why they won't this time.
 
Hmm they choose the name of a famous historical aritifact and then sue others when they try to use that name.

FAIL
 
They won last time, I don't see why they won't this time.
Sort of, but not for the same reason and google has caved several times to demands without going to trial. When google was sued a few years ago, the case was dismissed, but google also changed the policy that allowed others to buy copyrighted names without permission (i.e. now no one but Toyota could buy the adword for toyota). The Rosetta Stone lawsuit mentions a recent change in those terms to go back to allowing the purchase of copyrighted adwords. The twist is that RS isn't complaining about the use of "rosetta stone" or the names of its products (probably because buying those by others is still banned), but of very general terms like:

The company says it owns US-registered rights to terms such as "global traveler," "language library," "dynamic immersion," "adaptive recall," and "the fastest way to learn a language guaranteed." It also complains Google pawns terms that are "confusingly similar" to the Rosetta trademarks to third-parties and pirates on AdWords.

:rolleyes: I hope RS loses. Some of those terms are way too general and "confusingly similar" is just trying to claim anything they haven't registered.
 
I hope they lose too, how can you trademark such terms and even a complete sentence!
 
I could see going to court over terms that were legit, but that shit is fairly common language used to describe many things, but that's the U.S. patent/trademark/judicial/etc system for you.
 
People are cutting back on expensive items now, and Rosetta, although wonderful, is expensive. I would imagine sales are down, and perhaps this is a misguided attempt to score some extra cash. Maybe they're hoping google will settle or something. Who knows.
 
Obviously their overpriced language software is not lining their pockets with enough money so they need to go try and grab some more!
 
Obviously their overpriced language software is not lining their pockets with enough money so they need to go try and grab some more!

It's priced as such becuase it's a good product without peer.

That said, this suit smells fishy.
 
global traveler, how the hell did they manage to get rights to that! must of paid alot of people for that term.


And Rosetta is actually worth the money if you consider what it does.

Go find a spanish teacher and see how much it will cost you per lesson, for one that knows what they are doing.
 
global traveler, how the hell did they manage to get rights to that! must of paid alot of people for that term.


And Rosetta is actually worth the money if you consider what it does.

Go find a spanish teacher and see how much it will cost you per lesson, for one that knows what they are doing.

I'm not saying it's not worth it. I'm saying people are cutting back on expensive items they want but don't need. A lot of people would pick up a foreign language using Rosetta if they could afford it. I know people that do it as a hobby. But they wouldn't have bought the software for that hobby if they couldn't afford it. They would be using that money to buy food and pay bills! That was my point. Rosetta is amazing, from what I've heard.
 
I didn't even think you were allowed to trademark "global traveler", generic terms such as that.

As much as I dislike Google, I'm taking their side on this one though. Rosetta Stone is just looking for easy $$$. I think they have a valid case of losing money, but it's based off the fact they exploited a broken system (trademark office) in the first place.
 
It's priced as such becuase it's a good product without peer.

That said, this suit smells fishy.

Ive used it plenty of times, its ok at best, and it is way overpriced.

I had their wholesale numbers, it is insane the margins they rip people off for and/or let their resellers rip people off for. Even on the accessories like a cheap microphone and such :eek:
 
This isnt really adding to the discussion, just an FYI.

Whenver I searched on google for "Rosetta Stone" - the first news item that popped up was this story - linking to Hardocp.com :LOL: - very cool

Rosetta Stone Sues Google‎ - 14 hours ago
Rosetta Stone, the popular language-learning software, is suing Google for trademark violation, according to Reuters. The suit revolves around Google's ...
Hard OCP
 
Anyone notice the chick in the commercials in the maroon blouse now wearing a tight fitting blue dress. Now that I will pay for!!
 
Well, this will certainly blow the lid off of advertising if RS wins...
 
I'm not saying it's not worth it. I'm saying people are cutting back on expensive items they want but don't need. A lot of people would pick up a foreign language using Rosetta if they could afford it. I know people that do it as a hobby. But they wouldn't have bought the software for that hobby if they couldn't afford it. They would be using that money to buy food and pay bills! That was my point. Rosetta is amazing, from what I've heard.

i agree %100, money better spent elsewhere!
 
Ive used it plenty of times, its ok at best, and it is way overpriced.

I had their wholesale numbers, it is insane the margins they rip people off for and/or let their resellers rip people off for. Even on the accessories like a cheap microphone and such :eek:

As said, go find a German teacher in your area, spanish, french and check their hourly rate, now compare that to software you can use anytime, anywhere you want... no schedules, specific classes or times.
 
As said, go find a German teacher in your area, spanish, french and check their hourly rate, now compare that to software you can use anytime, anywhere you want... no schedules, specific classes or times.

I prefer to just hang out with my friends who speak english as a second language, sure it is lacking any structure, but I can learn a bit of street level talking and don't sound quite so mechanical as those who learn from computers.
 
Back
Top