Romania Targets Moon with Balloon Launch

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Yeah, you read that right, Romania is trying to get to the moon using a balloon with a sphere shaped lunar lander attached. These guys have balls, I’ll give them that… knobby rubber balls.

Once the balloon soars above 11 miles (18 km), the three-stage rocket slung below will fire and boost itself into low Earth orbit. ELE will then travel to the moon and deploy its Lunar Lander, which resembles a knobby rubber ball that uses its own rocket engine to ensure a soft landing.
 
Last edited:
I always wondered why they didn't do more stuff like this. I mean it seems the big burden of energy usage is getting from the ground to the outer edges of the atmosphere, why not use a plane or something that can use the advantages of aerodynamics to get up there, then toss a rocket off the back and fire it into orbit... *shrug*... I'm sure there's a pretty good reason why they don't.
 
Sounds like something out of a Jules Verne novel.I'll give them credit for inventiveness.
 
Sounds a lot more economical than using a huge massive rocket. Less fuel usage, less change for exploding on takeoff, less technical stuff to worry about on takeoff, etc.

It actually makes sense. It may take a bit longer to get up to orbit, but for the huge money savings, who cares about a small amount of time.

Maybe NASA will take a hint.
 
wasn't NASA working on a high altitude launch platform off the back of a jumbo jet? I guess the budget cuts aren't helping
 
Sounds a lot more economical than using a huge massive rocket. Less fuel usage, less change for exploding on takeoff, less technical stuff to worry about on takeoff, etc.

It actually makes sense. It may take a bit longer to get up to orbit, but for the huge money savings, who cares about a small amount of time.

Maybe NASA will take a hint.

I highly doubt it's as easy as it sounds. Plus, don't you think they've probably thought such a thing through? We have a more advanced space program...
 
As crazy as it sounds, the benefits are clear - launch from a higher altitude point, consume less fuel to get into space, then just coast it to where it needs to go. It may take more time, but the savings will be more than worth it.
 
Somebody at the Romanian Space Agency musta read the book "loona baloona" as a kid. It's about a bunch of cats that use a baloon to go to the moon.
 
As crazy as it sounds, the benefits are clear - launch from a higher altitude point, consume less fuel to get into space, then just coast it to where it needs to go. It may take more time, but the savings will be more than worth it.

The problem is when you're dealing with larger payloads. You might be able to carry something as large as the space shuttle on the back of an airplane, but its still going to need a shit ton of fuel to get to orbit, which may not be feasible to carry.

For lighter payloads/smaller vehicles assisted launches are smart. Its how Scaled Composites' SpaceShipOne was launched.
 
Anyone want to calculate how large of a balloon to get a rocket up there? (hint think about a football field sized one)

Also from low earth orbit, it's really not that far out of Earth's gravitational field to make THAT much of a difference, I think at around the space shuttle's orbit (WELL above where a balloon could take it) it is still about 90% of what the gravity is at the ground. The ONLY reason it's easy for them to get to a higher orbit is because they already expended a ton of energy (read fuel) to get up to SPEED at that point, i.e. they're going fast enough that they're orbiting the Earth. This balloon won't have any such advantages of speed, won't be orbiting the Earth, so at best they need 10% less fuel to get to the Moon.

I can't imagine this being a terribly good idea now that I've thought about it a bit, I can't see Romania as being part of the Lunar club just yet.
 
Anyone want to calculate how large of a balloon to get a rocket up there? (hint think about a football field sized one)

Also from low earth orbit, it's really not that far out of Earth's gravitational field to make THAT much of a difference, I think at around the space shuttle's orbit (WELL above where a balloon could take it) it is still about 90% of what the gravity is at the ground. The ONLY reason it's easy for them to get to a higher orbit is because they already expended a ton of energy (read fuel) to get up to SPEED at that point, i.e. they're going fast enough that they're orbiting the Earth. This balloon won't have any such advantages of speed, won't be orbiting the Earth, so at best they need 10% less fuel to get to the Moon.

I can't imagine this being a terribly good idea now that I've thought about it a bit, I can't see Romania as being part of the Lunar club just yet.

Based on looking on your name, I take it you know more about physics than I do. I am wondering what difference their might be in launching a rocket at that altitude in an angle or flat, as opposed to launching it "straight up" from the ground like most rockets. Also wondering what kind of advantage there might be with the issue of air resistance, as I imagine the air would be much thinner 11 miles up.
 
Based on looking on your name, I take it you know more about physics than I do. I am wondering what difference their might be in launching a rocket at that altitude in an angle or flat, as opposed to launching it "straight up" from the ground like most rockets. Also wondering what kind of advantage there might be with the issue of air resistance, as I imagine the air would be much thinner 11 miles up.

Don't let the name fool you, I basically used it way back when I was in college, taking physics, and well it kind of stuck with me. Now I just teach it, I really have meant to change the name, its just well this has been my internet identity for so long (another reason why I should change it! :D)

To answer your questions, if you launch at an altitude you typically want to launch it at some angle to get in a particular orbit you want to achieve, basically the idea of "what goes up must come down" will work as well unless you have escape velocity. For whatever reason (and I'm not picking on you ;)) a majority of "the public" (in my experience students eager for learning... or getting that physical science requirement out of the way) seem to think when the rocket gets up to a certain height it magically goes into orbit, which is the furthest thing from the truth. Now when they launch rockets from the ground they are launched completely vertically, but they do end up doing minor corrections to get them "angled" as they go up. I can only hazard a guess however that when you're at altitude that you really don't have much time to "course correct" to get the proper orbital angle. That being said, if you're aiming for the moon you want to use all your energy to go there, as you don't care about orbital issues around the Earth.

As to your question about air resistance, there absolutely is some friction due to air, however I can make a guess that it really doesn't make that much of a dent in the speed of the rocket compared to the amount of thrust it's putting out, they are fairly aerodynamic being all pointy and phallic :D. That being said resistance increases with speed, and the rocket is moving the slowest when it's near the ground, so as it speeds up it'll be higher in the air and the air will be thinner as well.
 
That being said, if you're aiming for the moon you want to use all your energy to go there, as you don't care about orbital issues around the Earth.

My understanding was that moon-bound spacecraft go to a parking orbit before going to the moon. Wouldn't the energy use be the same as going straight to the moon? Its not like you'd have to keep the thrusters going to maintain a parking orbit over a short period of time, and once you're in orbit you can line up for the trans lunar injection burn more accurately than you could in the upper atmosphere.

The air resistance question is interesting. I don't know how big of a factor it is, but by launching at 11 miles up like the Romainian rocket would greatly reduce atmospheric drag (some 50% of the gas in the atmosphere is below 18,000 ft).
 
I wonder what they plan on filling the balloon up with to hit 11miles up as the buoyancy of the balloon will decrease as it gets to higher elevations. The displacement of mass at one point of elevation is quite different then it is at another especially when we are talking thousands of feet.

Well, good luck to them with the creation of a 5000ft diameter balloon.
 
My understanding was that moon-bound spacecraft go to a parking orbit before going to the moon. Wouldn't the energy use be the same as going straight to the moon? Its not like you'd have to keep the thrusters going to maintain a parking orbit over a short period of time, and once you're in orbit you can line up for the trans lunar injection burn more accurately than you could in the upper atmosphere.
By no means an expert, but yeah basically, you don't make a straight line shot towards the moon, but you can course correct such that when you get there you're aiming at the right angle to go directly into orbit and drop from there. Basically the moon in the 3 days it'd take to get to it will move around 1/10th of it's orbital position, or a bit more than 1.5 million miles from where it was. They want aim where the Moon will be not where it was :D

The air resistance question is interesting. I don't know how big of a factor it is, but by launching at 11 miles up like the Romainian rocket would greatly reduce atmospheric drag (some 50% of the gas in the atmosphere is below 18,000 ft).

Never claimed air resistance wasn't an issue, I would just think that it'd be minor compared to trying to leave Earth's gravity.
 
Anyone want to calculate how large of a balloon to get a rocket up there? (hint think about a football field sized one)

Also from low earth orbit, it's really not that far out of Earth's gravitational field to make THAT much of a difference, I think at around the space shuttle's orbit (WELL above where a balloon could take it) it is still about 90% of what the gravity is at the ground. The ONLY reason it's easy for them to get to a higher orbit is because they already expended a ton of energy (read fuel) to get up to SPEED at that point, i.e. they're going fast enough that they're orbiting the Earth. This balloon won't have any such advantages of speed, won't be orbiting the Earth, so at best they need 10% less fuel to get to the Moon.

I can't imagine this being a terribly good idea now that I've thought about it a bit, I can't see Romania as being part of the Lunar club just yet.

Sorry for the TL;DR post, but I do this sort of thing for a living, and I can say that the amount of fuel needed to get to orbit from a high altitude is SIGNIFICANTLY less than from the ground.

The problem comes into play with air resistance as others have hinted at. Basically, you have two competing effects: aerodynamic losses (drag) and gravity losses. To minimize the gravity losses, you want to launch to orbit quickly, and therefore minimize your time in flight. However, if you go too quickly, your drag (which goes up the faster you move) goes up as well. Vehicles that launch from the ground therefore have to strike a balance between these two competing factors.

On the other hand, launching from high up, you are above a bunch of the atmosphere, and therefore drag (which is proportional to the atmospheric density) goes down. At these higher altitudes, you can accelerate faster without incurring the massive aerodynamic losses.

Some calculations I was doing for work showed a close to 90% reduction in propellant mass required by air launching the payloads, not counting the weight of the airplane and such. The calculations were for a totally different mission, but the underlying concept is the same.

Note: I am not saying that this is always a good idea, or that a balloon is a good way to launch a rocket. Balloons are notoriously hard to control, and launch angle is also a big concern for these types of things. They may have a good enough guidance system on-board so that it will be okay, but I dunno. I guess a balloon uses no fuel, so in that respect it is great.
 
Some calculations I was doing for work showed a close to 90% reduction in propellant mass required by air launching the payloads, not counting the weight of the airplane and such. The calculations were for a totally different mission, but the underlying concept is the same.
Really 90% less? Wow, never would have imagined that much less, mostly because I wouldn't guess that air resistance would really play that much of a part in the drag on the vehicle. If it's really that much less fuel why don't they air launch more often?
 
Dont you save a huge percentage of fuel usage by going 55 MPH rather than 70 MPH? Scale that to hundreds/thousands of miles an hour and I'm sure its even more pronounced.
 
Really 90% less? Wow, never would have imagined that much less, mostly because I wouldn't guess that air resistance would really play that much of a part in the drag on the vehicle. If it's really that much less fuel why don't they air launch more often?

I don't claim to be an expert on this (even though it is my job :p), but I imagine it has to do with packaging constraints, and I doubt you could scale this method up to Saturn V size payloads very easily. The stuff we were looking at are small payloads, so there are plenty of vehicles that can carry our rocket up to high altitudes. For larger payloads, the choice of vehicles would be a lot smaller. Plus you introduce a host of new complications when it comes time to release the rocket from the airplane.

The benefit is certainly there on paper, but I imagine the implementation is its downfall on the large scale. It certainly would be awesome to see someone try it, however. :D
 
Dont you save a huge percentage of fuel usage by going 55 MPH rather than 70 MPH? Scale that to hundreds/thousands of miles an hour and I'm sure its even more pronounced.

Sure if you are driving a 1950's era car, with more modern and aerodynamic vehicles this isn't the case.
 
Sure if you are driving a 1950's era car, with more modern and aerodynamic vehicles this isn't the case.

I doubt it. I managed 40 MPG on a car that usually gets low 30s by driving 60 MPH with the AC off, as opposed to 70ish.. i know just the AC off didnt give me 20% more MPG. It would be 5% at most, I believe. EPA is only rated at 31 or 33 MPG. I can't get it below 30 when cruising at 70 MPH. While I know there are other variables such a torque distribution and engine efficiency changes at different RPMs, I've observed it enough to know it does help A LOT. Unfortunately, I'm too impatient to cruise at 60 MPH to save the money.
 
Back
Top