Report: NSA Intercepts Computer Deliveries

I'm not confusing anything NoOther, read this then talk.

Executive Order 12333 applies to ALL US Intelligence Agencies, all of them. It expressly limits and sets the requirements necessary in order to collect on a US Person.

From this wiki page;
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency


Because of Executive Order 12333 the NSA can't target a US Person unless they go through the courts. There are four explicit reasons the NSA would conduct targeted surveillance on a US person.

1. Espionage, a US Person who is spying on our own country. Allthough the NSA could be involved in an espionage case, it is the FBI's function and they would have to provide a warrant.
2. Treason, Involves specifically aiding an Enemy during time of war, knowingly and with intent, all the previous rules apply.
3. Counter-Intelligence, against foreign intelligence agents, sorry, their foreign by definition.
4. Anti-Terrorism, actually just a subset of the rest but hey, we needed new pigeon holes to keep things straight, still the FBI's job.

I enjoy your link to Wikipedia, but it does not contain all the information. And many of the answers to your question about domestic and foreign are right there even in your post. Terrorism is both domestic and abroad. Foreign intelligence is both domestic and abroad. Also you are completely forgetting about the charter of the NSA to safeguard American intelligence and communications which is very definitely both domestic and abroad. So yes, in fact they are both domestic and foreign. You are trying to take only one aspect of what they do and use that to your benefit. But foreign intelligence is only one aspect of what they do and its not even their primary focus. Also, as noted there, even the FBI requires warrants to gather information on American citizens, and the FBI very definitely is a domestic agency. You post about rules that apply to all agencies as if that is the charter for the NSA, it is not. So I fail to see where you are going with this?
 
My issue has only ever been with American intelligence agencies spying on the citizens they're supposed to serve and protect.



The NSA is part of the US government, which seizes money under threat of imprisonment from US citizens. I didn't think this necessitated explanation. Your semantical arguments are getting a bit bewildering.



Not one agency. One government. You should really stop imagining arguments and responding to them.

And yet almost all governments do the same thing. I am not imagining any arguments, just replying to yours with a little global and domestic perspective.
 
I'm not confusing anything NoOther, read this then talk.

Executive Order 12333 applies to ALL US Intelligence Agencies, all of them. It expressly limits and sets the requirements necessary in order to collect on a US Person.

From this wiki page;
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency


Because of Executive Order 12333 the NSA can't target a US Person unless they go through the courts. There are four explicit reasons the NSA would conduct targeted surveillance on a US person.

1. Espionage, a US Person who is spying on our own country. Allthough the NSA could be involved in an espionage case, it is the FBI's function and they would have to provide a warrant.
2. Treason, Involves specifically aiding an Enemy during time of war, knowingly and with intent, all the previous rules apply.
3. Counter-Intelligence, against foreign intelligence agents, sorry, their foreign by definition.
4. Anti-Terrorism, actually just a subset of the rest but hey, we needed new pigeon holes to keep things straight, still the FBI's job.

Also just a note from your own wikipedia posting:

Unlike the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) and the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), both of which specialize primarily in foreign human espionage, the NSA has no authority to conduct human-source intelligence gathering, although it is often portrayed so in popular culture. Instead, the NSA is entrusted with coordination and deconfliction of SIGINT components of otherwise non-SIGINT government organizations, which are prevented by law from engaging in such activities without the approval of the NSA via the Defense Secretary.[15]

Which is what I have been saying and you have been deflecting from.
 
And yet almost all governments do the same thing.

Amazing how one minute you can't compare the US to a country...and the next minute you can compare them to all countries.

...and still it has nothing to do, whatsoever, with the issue at hand; the hallmark of someone who does not like the issue being discussed.
 
NSA has no authority to conduct human-source intelligence gathering, although it is often portrayed so in popular culture. Instead, the NSA is entrusted with coordination and deconfliction of SIGINT components of otherwise non-SIGINT government organizations, which are prevented by law from engaging in such activities without the approval of the NSA via the Defense Secretary.[15]

Which mean what? Time to see if you actually understand it.
 
Which mean what? Time to see if you actually understand it.

Which means they do not have human operators working as spies. They collect intelligence information either through electronic surveillance or via other agencies. It also means they protect the network of the Unites States and communications within and out of the United States. And still this is just a sampling of their overall tasking.

In addition, that executive order you were so nice to post, specifically lists the NSA's scope as both domestic and abroad for the purpose of pursuing their mission.
 
Amazing how one minute you can't compare the US to a country...and the next minute you can compare them to all countries.

...and still it has nothing to do, whatsoever, with the issue at hand; the hallmark of someone who does not like the issue being discussed.

Are you really that naive, again with the twisting. You are truly lost Stiletto. As for how one country goes about overthrowing their government and banking principles, that situation is not at all comparable to what would be necessary or realistic in the United States. For the purpose of spying and collecting information on both their citizens and other countries, that is a very comparable situation to other nations. But it would not be comparable to all nations, as some nations barely even have a government or any control over their populace.

You are trying to mix apples and oranges here. The only one that doesn't like to discuss what is going on is you. You are the one deflecting and trying to twist things, constantly trying to mix up disparate comparisons.
 
And you are truly unoriginal.

Your right, when I am talking about issues, I like to use pesky things like facts, not made up conspiracies. Very unorginal, facts are. I can see why you don't like to use them, ever.
 
NSA has no authority to conduct human-source intelligence gathering, although it is often portrayed so in popular culture. Instead, the NSA is entrusted with coordination and deconfliction of SIGINT components of otherwise non-SIGINT government organizations, which are prevented by law from engaging in such activities without the approval of the NSA via the Defense Secretary.[15]

Yes NoOther, the NSA can't engage in HUMINT collection. (NSA has no authority to conduct human-source intelligence gathering)

But this part (. Instead, the NSA is entrusted with coordination and deconfliction of SIGINT components of otherwise non-SIGINT government organizations, which are prevented by law from engaging in such activities without the approval of the NSA via the Defense Secretary)

The NSA is pretty much in charge of all SIGINT operations, other SIGINT agencies must collect according to the NSA's rules and do so under the authority of the NSA's purview. At the same time, if a Non-SIGINT agency does collect SIGINT information it's up to the NSA to approve it first and make sure they are doing it right. No US Agency can conduct SIGINT collection without approval from the NSA :via the SECDEF.

And although you are correct, the NSA does so many things your interpretation of domestic and foreign is incorrect. For the NSA, there is only Foreign and US Persons, meaning someone has US Person's Status, or they do not. If a Person has US Person's Status, they get a warrant, if not, they don't.

As for the protecting of our Communications, there are a few different aspects, predominantly it's cryptographic and they are responsible for the rules and procedures for us Encryption within the DoD and State Department, etc. They manage the codes, they also manage the rules and other aspects of the physical elements as well. And you might guess that if a hacker tries to gain access to Military Systems for example, the NSA might be involved in that as well. But these days there is a new kid on the block, U.S. Cyber Command, they have their hands in much of this now and although DIRNSA is the commander of both entities, the U.S. Cyber Command is not part of the NSA. Of course there might be some very close teamwork going on.

The NSA might be actively monitoring a radio station being operated in say Nepal for example, what they will not be doing is monitoring a radio station in Brooklyn, not without a Court Ordered warrant and even then it would have to be for a very narrow reason, as in a DJ is sending espionage related data to the Russians hidden in the signal of Elvis' songs.
 
My issue has only ever been with American intelligence agencies spying on the citizens they're supposed to serve and protect.

How do you expect them to serve and protect the citizenship from foreign and terrorist threats without monitoring the communications systems that those threats are using? You're forgetting the step where the NSA needs to find out who the bad guys are before they can start spying on them.
 
Not to worry boys even in the absolutely unlikely in highly improbable event that The NSA is not spying on its own citizens. (use your head if you think they are not) They just ask The Canadians or Brits to do so.

No problem

http://www.truthersonly.com/2013/10/19/canadas-new-top-secret-billion-dollar-spy-palace/

http://benswann.com/snowden-leaks-more-nsa-working-directly-with-canadas-spy-agency-the-five-eyes/

http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/new-snowden-docs-show-u-s-spied-during-g20-in-toronto-1.2442448
 
Stiltto you can think either if you wish. But no matter how badly I think of the Obama Administration and the crappy impact they have had on much of the Federal Government, I still believe that the the DoD is somewhat insulated and the NSA even more so.

You are going to have to have much more on them then generalities to convince me otherwise. I know what their jobs are and it's not spying on Americans unless of course the FBI has a reason to think that American is doing bad things himself and is in contact with bad people, have opened an investigation and requested NSA assistance, which of course then requires a warrant from a Federal Judge.

Bullshit. Federal agents can write their own search warrants in your driveway thanks to the Patriot act.

And, they can throw you in jail if you tell anyone including your spouse about the contact.

Watch "Judge Andrew Napolitano Natural Rights and The Patriot Act part 1 of 3" on YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M1P53wMbnsw

"Judge Andrew Napolitano Natural Rights and PATRIOT ACT Part 2 of 3" on YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bjhNZjanX9k

"Judge Andrew Napolitano Natural rights Patriot Act - Part 3 of 3" on YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7n2m-X7OIuY
 


405547.jpg
 
And although you are correct, the NSA does so many things your interpretation of domestic and foreign is incorrect. For the NSA, there is only Foreign and US Persons, meaning someone has US Person's Status, or they do not. If a Person has US Person's Status, they get a warrant, if not, they don't.

This just shows you weren't paying attention. My whole point was that the NSA operates both foreign and domestic. That has been proven over and over again. What are you trying to argue about now? I didn't interpret foreign and domestic, you did. I didn't say they could spy on US citizens without impunity. I said they could operate in the US, which they do. And you saying if they are a US Person they have to have a warrant is not entirely correct either. If they are a suspected terrorist, they do not need a warrant. And since they deal in protecting and securing communications, there is a lot of grey area in where and how they operate.

Plus you trying to say they do more is funny, becuase that is exactly what I have been saying. Their scope is far broader than just collecting information or foreign intelligence. I don't understand what you are trying to get at.
 
Back
Top