Report A Security Flaw, Get Sued

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A researcher finds a security flaw in a company's software. He reports the flaw privately to the company...they threaten him with a lawsuit for extortion. And no, although it is the same tactics we read about last week, the company isn't Best Buy. :D

"It came out of nowhere," Acidgen says of the legal threat. He was awaiting word on when the vendor would be issuing a patch: "Then I get back a really threatening lawsuit letter that they are going to press charges for extortion for [the] exploit code," says Acidgen, who says the PoC he gave Magix is a benign one that just starts up the Windows Calculator.
 
Did he make up the security flaw and ask for 3 times salary raise? Who is the bigger douche him or the employer? Time will tell.
 
I guess the only way now is to be anonymous and plost it on the internet from a internet cafe.
 
I had to deal with this company once. I ordered a special discount software package from Musicians Friend that said "Free upgrade to version xxx" on the box. It was cheap, so I bought it.

When I got it, I used the link provided for the free update to the next version and the page was 404.

I tried to email their support. I got back a really nasty automated email stating that because I didn't put a special paid support code in the header, I was trying to get around paying for support, and they basically would not help me. Something like that, it's been over a year now...

So I called them. I think they were in Florida. She asked for my paid support number. I said I just bought it, and just wanted to know how to get to the advertised free download for the next version.

They were completely insistent that they would not do anything for me whatsoever unless I purchased a paid support plan that cost more than the damned software did in the first place.

After going round and round for 15 minutes with them, I did something I've probably done twice in my life. I was so mad I slammed the phone down.

I immediately RMA'd the software back to Musicians Friend for a refund. Due to the bizarre issues I had with the company, they took it back even though it was opened.

Assuming this is the same Magix, these are not nice people. They will never get business from me again.
 
I had to deal with this company once. I ordered a special discount software package from Musicians Friend that said "Free upgrade to version xxx" on the box. It was cheap, so I bought it.

When I got it, I used the link provided for the free update to the next version and the page was 404.

I tried to email their support. I got back a really nasty automated email stating that because I didn't put a special paid support code in the header, I was trying to get around paying for support, and they basically would not help me. Something like that, it's been over a year now...

So I called them. I think they were in Florida. She asked for my paid support number. I said I just bought it, and just wanted to know how to get to the advertised free download for the next version.

They were completely insistent that they would not do anything for me whatsoever unless I purchased a paid support plan that cost more than the damned software did in the first place.

After going round and round for 15 minutes with them, I did something I've probably done twice in my life. I was so mad I slammed the phone down.

I immediately RMA'd the software back to Musicians Friend for a refund. Due to the bizarre issues I had with the company, they took it back even though it was opened.

Assuming this is the same Magix, these are not nice people. They will never get business from me again.

Can you say boycott? That's an awful way to treat your customers.
 
/rocking back and forth in the fetal position/
No good deed goes unpunished
No good deed goes unpunished
No good deed goes unpunished...
 
This is pretty common practice, and it's retarded. I guess executives view things differently than technical people or something.

Company gets info from a hacker type that says, "Hey, you're vulnerable to this, you should fix it." Company is busy and maybe doesn't give a fuck about a theoretical attack when they have other, more pressing issues.

So rather than work with the hacker type (extra work) to fix the (perceived to be imaginary) problem, it seems to be easier to sue them.

Often times this pushes the technical hacker types to release info on the exploit/proof of concept code to the public in order to make them aware of their vulnerability in using the program. This is usually when they get sued.

It's pretty ridiculous though that they're being sued just for talking to the company in private about it.
 
someone in accounting probably saw it and decided to was cheaper to sue the guy trying to help than to actually fix the problem.
 
The German company might have saw his "for free" comment as an implication that he might have charged them but he was feeling benevolent. The way I read the letter, it feels like the company lawyer was saying "you're damn right you'll do it for free - or not at all. Piss off for even suggesting it".
 
"Extortion" would imply that he wanted something. Technically, he did want them to fix their security issue, but that's hardly an unreasonable demand.
 
screw the law suit, hack the hack out of their operation and let them face the damage on their own, i mean i'm sure they've insurance. if it was me i would warn them of flaws rather than showing them and get some cash for meself, call me crazy but that's what i'll do. if you make mistakes you should pay for it with cash or some other means.
 
screw the law suit, hack the hack out of their operation and let them face the damage on their own, i mean i'm suyey've insurance. if it was me i would warn them of flaws rather than showing them and get some cash for meself, call me crazy but that's what i'll do. if you make mistakes you should pay for it with cash or some other means.


Good thing your still in your moms basement than!
 
But opening the windows caluclator is serious business. What were to happen if a young child were to see the calculator open and display "80085" or "8008135", he could end up scarred for life!
 
Back
Top