Replacing a dying video card for dad

krueL

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 29, 2004
Messages
211
he games on the occasion, as long as this card equal to or greater than his old ti4200 is all that really matters to him.. only reason he is getting a new one is because his current one is slowly dying. his system is a amd xp 2000+ 1gig of value ram.. so too much would just be bottlenecking. i searched for a while trying to find something for the amount of money he is willing to spend.. and i narrowed it down to the two cards i listed.. even getting one of these im going to have to invest some of my own money cuz its over the limit he gave me.. the first card i listed is a 128mb card, and the second is a 256mb. The only reason i havent already ordered the 256mb is cuz it doesnt list the memory clock.. which it does list a RAMDAC speed.. which im not sure what is... so i still need your guys help.. out of these two cards.. which is the better deal?
 
9800s are nice cards, and can play most newer games at decent resolutions. I'm guessing you want to stay well under the $100 price range, and you're limted to AGP, I guess that rules out anything in the X series for ATI. If you wanted to spend a tad more (around 110), you could opt for a cheaper or refurbished 6600GT (around 100-110), and that's a damn good card for the price.
 
I vote for a 6600GT if you can swing the cost for one, otherwise a 6600 at the least. The advantage over a 9800 is that you get SM3.0 support, DX9 support, PureVideo support and an overall faster performer! :)
All for a price that can't be beat.
 
consumer9000 said:
I vote for a 6600GT if you can swing the cost for one, otherwise a 6600 at the least. The advantage over a 9800 is that you get SM3.0 support, DX9 support, PureVideo support and an overall faster performer! :)
All for a price that can't be beat.

i say the 6600gt as well..
 
Kruelz, out of the two cards you first posted, the only difference is 128mb vs 256mb, which is negligible for games unless he plays at higher resolutions.

Again, I remember the 9800SE cards could be unlocked into 9800 pro's, which means between the two versions you posted, one could yield higher unlocks, but I am not too sure.

The Second links you posted a few posts down from your original do not work.
 
Check the FS/FT forums for 9800s you can get a 9800pro 256bit 128mb card for 75$ (thats where I got mine) or less other than that 6600gt or 6800vanilla of course the 6800vanilla might be a bottle neck for that 2000+XP
 
Rocco123 said:
Check this out:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814121197R

~20 dollars more. Now given this isn't going to perform like a 6600GT, but I believe this would be a better card than the 9800 pro. And if you're dad doesn't want to spend the extra 20 dollars, we'll all pitch in 50 cents for you to get a 6600 :)

9800 isn't a bad card at all, but a 6600 will last him longer.


lol, shall i post my paypal info?! :p
 
I think you might wnana go 6600, 6600GT if he wants a little more out of it. It's got about 1000 points more on bechmarks for 3dmark 05 than the 9800pro, and it has smart shader 3.0 instead of 9800Pro's Sp2.0. Also, whoever said that AGP rules out ATi's whole X series, that's wrong.... there are versions of X300's - X850XT PE's that are AGP =D
 
Back
Top