Reddit Bans Posting Nude Pics Without Consent

I can't agree with that. I can see rules to a point, but they shouldn't govern how people act. If I want to act like a child without breaking any laws, I can.

Surely you can appreciate that posting nude pics of someone else without their consent doesn't meet your definition of "without breaking any laws".

Then again after some of the stuff you posted, probably not.
 
We'll just have to wait and see. Until then, what I said remains true

What you said does not remain true at all. Your "freedom" to take nude pics of someone as a photographer and your supposed "copyright" of those pictures does not necessarily give you express permission to post it for the world to see, which is what you insinuated in your original post. Which is why all of these laws are being made in the first place - because this stuff is already happening and posters (and, in some cases, hosts) of those pictures are being prosecuted.
 
What you said does not remain true at all. Your "freedom" to take nude pics of someone as a photographer and your supposed "copyright" of those pictures does not necessarily give you express permission to post it for the world to see, which is what you insinuated in your original post. Which is why all of these laws are being made in the first place - because this stuff is already happening and posters (and, in some cases, hosts) of those pictures are being prosecuted.

And as I have already stated, go and look at every tabloid magazine sold, that posts pictures they purchased from photographers of celebrities nude and otherwise, taken by said photographers against the celebrity's/photo subject's permission; and come to the realization that at this point in time, what I stated is true - no matter how much you do or don't like it.
 
If what you were saying was illegal, all these tabloid magazines would be barred from sale, as they contain photos taken and published without the photo subjects consent. Which seeing as these tabloids are still on sale all throughout the US, clearly isn't the case, and it's not illegal.

Because the photo, its contents, and the copyright and ownership of the photo doesn't belong to the subject in it; it belongs to the individual who took the photo. Even without the subject's permission.
 
According to the law in the U.S.A., whoever took the photo owns the copyright, and the owner, of that given photo. Not the subject.

Not really true when it comes to photos of subjects.

For you to exhibit a photo of me, as a subject, you might need a model release.
 
Not really true when it comes to photos of subjects.

For you to exhibit a photo of me, as a subject, you might need a model release.

Can any of you saying this isn't true, then explain why the entire paparazzi/tabloid industry legally exists in the US?

Why nude photos are published in these tabloids, who purchased them from paparazzi, who took them, purchased them and then published without the subjects consent?

If you want to tell me I'm wrong, then explain this please to help your argument.
 
Just wait till the FCC decides to apply this to the internet as a whole under a new "regulation", since after tomorrow it will be a public utility.

Rubes! :rolleyes:
 
If what you were saying was illegal, all these tabloid magazines would be barred from sale, as they contain photos taken and published without the photo subjects consent. Which seeing as these tabloids are still on sale all throughout the US, clearly isn't the case, and it's not illegal.

Because the photo, its contents, and the copyright and ownership of the photo doesn't belong to the subject in it; it belongs to the individual who took the photo. Even without the subject's permission.

It's called "revenge porn" and many states are outlawing it. Even those who have not outlawed it have had both state and federal charges pressed against them for doing those things. The vast majority of those who do end up getting away with it, but authorities are starting to crack down.

The guy that hosted a revenge porn website himself got 7 years in jail, and he never even uploaded a photo. He's guilty by association.

Tabloids have also been targeted by the justice system recently.

It may not be deemed illegal in many areas, but that doesn't mean you won't get in trouble with the law if you still do it. And the current state of affairs is a far cry from what you claim, that the photographer has full discretion on what happens with the photos.
 
It may not be deemed illegal in many areas, but that doesn't mean you won't get in trouble with the law if you still do it.

Lol, please, explain the legality, or merit behind this. Please.
 
And the current state of affairs is a far cry from what you claim, that the photographer has full discretion on what happens with the photos.

Then what is it, in the legal sense, not the moral sense?
 
And again, if what you claim is true, then simply explain how the entire paparazzi/tabloid industry legally exists in the US? That's all you have to do. Please. Explain.
 
And again, if what you claim is true, then simply explain how the entire paparazzi/tabloid industry legally exists in the US? That's all you have to do. Please. Explain.

It doesn't "legally exist in the US", it's a very shady business where photographs are bought by tabloids when the photographer doesn't necessarily have a right to sell the pictures. It would take a lot of time in court to fight every single case, which is why not much has been done about it.

But there has been a rash of lawsuits against tabloids over the years.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revenge_porn

Read under "Legislation". There are a myriad of different charges used in place of an actual revenge porn law to criminalize the act.

Did you?

Some scholars have argued that new criminal laws meant to combat revenge porn are likely to be overbroad, resulting in unintended consequences.

An estimated 80% of revenge porn pictures and videos are taken by the subject themselves.[38] Those individuals can bring actions for copyright infringement against the person who uploaded their nude or semi-nude "selfies". American victims may file Digital Millennium Copyright Act takedown notices with service providers.[39] Revenge porn site MyEx.com has been a defendant in a copyright infringement case.

Some free speech advocates object to revenge porn laws on First Amendment grounds.[43] United States courts are generally reluctant to uphold legislation that restricts free speech.[44]

Revenge porn uploaders and websites may also challenge lawsuits using state protections against strategic lawsuit against public participations (anti-SLAPP laws),[45] which allow defendants to counter lawsuits aimed at stifling free speech.[46][/QUOTE]

And also:

It doesn't "legally exist in the US", it's a very shady business where photographs are bought by tabloids when the photographer doesn't necessarily have a right to sell the pictures. It would take a lot of time in court to fight every single case, which is why not much has been done about it.

But there has been a rash of lawsuits against tabloids over the years.
.

If that were the case, then magazines who publish said photos, would be legally barred from sale in the US? So if what you said is true, then why isn't this the case?
 
Did you?

If that were the case, then magazines who publish said photos, would be legally barred from sale in the US? So if what you said is true, then why isn't this the case?

None of what you just quoted has anything to do with supporting your claim that uploading photos you have taken of someone else in the nude is perfectly, 100% legal. In fact, most of it goes against your original claim, indicating that it is more illegal than legal.

Besides that fact, I believe I have fulfilled the burden of proof that doing so is still at best extremely dubious and subject to prosecution under privacy laws in states without revenge porn laws.

Lastly, I don't have a measurable answer as to why tabloids still exist. I know that there have been lots of lawsuits against them for privacy concerns. The only answer I have is that the American public is made up of complete hypocrites - they (mostly women, mind you) gush about pictures of half naked celebrities on the beach, but once it's THEM getting uploaded to a revenge porn site, they suddenly have a huge problem with it.

I think this sudden explosion of this stuff is probably going to shift the conversation into why tabloids exist. We haven't quite gotten there yet, because we're so focused on ourselves at present. But I think there will be a time where tabloids will be seen in the same light as internet content hosts, and will be prosecuted as such. I may be wrong, but it would be extremely hypocritical of our justice system if revenge porn for the average person was illegal but it wasn't for celebrities.
 
None of what you just quoted has anything to do with supporting your claim that uploading photos you have taken of someone else in the nude is perfectly, 100% legal. In fact, most of it goes against your original claim, indicating that it is more illegal than legal.

An estimated 80% of revenge porn pictures and videos are taken by the subject themselves.[38] Those individuals can bring actions for copyright infringement against the person who uploaded their nude or semi-nude "selfies". American victims may file Digital Millennium Copyright Act takedown notices with service providers.[39] Revenge porn site MyEx.com has been a defendant in a copyright infringement case.

Except for this part right? Because this shows, copyright and ownership lies with the individual who took the photo, not the subject. Which is what you were trying to tell me I'm wrong on. From your own 'proof'.

The rest goes to show how all the other laws you are claiming support your view, might be (and are considered by many) unconstitutional.

Besides that fact, I believe I have fulfilled the burden of proof that doing so is still at best extremely dubious and subject to prosecution under privacy laws in states without revenge porn laws.

I'm still waiting to see that proof that in the U.S.A. copyright and ownership lies with the subject of a photo, and not the photographer. which is what you say I'm wrong on.

Lastly, I don't have a measurable answer as to why tabloids still exist. I know that there have been lots of lawsuits against them for privacy concerns. The only answer I have is that the American public is made up of complete hypocrites - they (mostly women, mind you) gush about pictures of half naked celebrities on the beach, but once it's THEM getting uploaded to a revenge porn site, they suddenly have a huge problem with it.

I think this sudden explosion of this stuff is probably going to shift the conversation into why tabloids exist. We haven't quite gotten there yet, because we're so focused on ourselves at present. But I think there will be a time where tabloids will be seen in the same light as internet content hosts, and will be prosecuted as such. I may be wrong, but it would be extremely hypocritical of our justice system if revenge porn for the average person was illegal but it wasn't for celebrities.

Then don't claim to know about things you are ignorant on; and don't claim your feelings to be facts or laws.
 
Except for this part right? Because this shows, copyright and ownership lies with the individual who took the photo, not the subject. Which is what you were trying to tell me I'm wrong on. From your own 'proof'.

The rest goes to show how all the other laws you are claiming support your view, might be (and are considered by many) unconstitutional.



I'm still waiting to see that proof that in the U.S.A. copyright and ownership lies with the subject of a photo, and not the photographer. which is what you say I'm wrong on.



Then don't claim to know about things you are ignorant on; and don't claim your feelings to be facts or laws.

The 80% statistic of people who take their own pictures is irrelevant, the fact that photos uploaded of pictures taken of a subject and not by the subject are susceptible to "revenge porn" law or privacy law infringement states to the contrary, that despite any claim of "copyright", your ability to do with a photo as you please is still limited in certain instances.

That was my claim all along. I didn't claim that the copyright lies exclusively with the subject, or vice versa. Maybe we have a miscommunication somewhere here.

And I would love for you to prove that tabloid photos are in fact 100% legal. If that were the case, there would not be a myriad of lawsuits against them...
 
You allow a certain type of photo of yourself. You did what you did. No amount of pretending it didn't happen undoes that.
 
The 80% statistic of people who take their own pictures is irrelevant, the fact that photos uploaded of pictures taken of a subject and not by the subject are susceptible to "revenge porn" law or privacy law infringement states to the contrary, that despite any claim of "copyright", your ability to do with a photo as you please is still limited in certain instances.

And your own 'proof' shows that is under contention as being unconstitutional. In which case the law was unlawful from the get-go, and should have never been allowed to come to pass, if found to be.

That was my claim all along. I didn't claim that the copyright lies exclusively with the subject, or vice versa. Maybe we have a miscommunication somewhere here.

O'rly?

That's not necessarily true either. Vampire Weekend was sued by the subject in a picture used on one of their albums, because she supposedly didn't give consent for the photographer to sell the photos. She won that suit.

http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1041448811&postcount=23

And I would love for you to prove that tabloid photos are in fact 100% legal. If that were the case, there would not be a myriad of lawsuits against them...

The fact you can go and purchase them legally anywhere in the U.S. is all the proof one would need. Or, are you now trying to say every newsstand, grocery isle, and magazine rack in the U.S. is openly displaying illegal material for sale?

It's not illegal to file lawsuits against someone/a company in the U.S. People file lawsuits all the time, and they get thrown out or found to have no merit all the time as well.

Doing so (being named in a suit) isn't proof of guilt either (for the defendant). Have you never heard of, or just choosing to ignore, 'Presumption of innocence'? You know, that thing that's a cornerstone of our justice system?

So, I dunno what you were hoping to achieve with that last point there.

Again, don't argue on subjects you are ignorant on.
 
And I would love for you to prove that tabloid photos are in fact 100% legal

And also, the fact paparazzi are allowed to do what they do, magazines are allowed to buy and publish the photos, and sell magazines with said photos.

If it were illegal, the profession of paparazzi would be illegal, the magazines would be prosecuted and/or shut down every time they bought a photo, again when they published it, and the magazines containing said photos would be barred from legal sale and publication for containing illegal materials. Which isn't the case. Or are you gonna just ignore that faction of reality as well?
 
Can any of you saying this isn't true, then explain why the entire paparazzi/tabloid industry legally exists in the US?

Why nude photos are published in these tabloids, who purchased them from paparazzi, who took them, purchased them and then published without the subjects consent?

If you want to tell me I'm wrong, then explain this please to help your argument.

Sure.

The United States establishes a provision for media attention for people who have willingly made themselves a public figure.

The definition of this is nebulous and has come under court scrutiny before.
 
Sure.

The United States establishes a provision for media attention for people who have willingly made themselves a public figure.

The definition of this is nebulous and has come under court scrutiny before.

Like you say

The definition of this is nebulous

So one could argue putting a picture you took into a public domain, say the internet, no matter where on the internet that might be (whether a cloud storage service, or image board), would constitute willingly making yourself, or the subject of your work, a public figure.
 
Surely you can appreciate that posting nude pics of someone else without their consent doesn't meet your definition of "without breaking any laws".

Then again after some of the stuff you posted, probably not.

I've said it several times in this thread - I am fully for what reddit did. It's an appropriate response.

What I was talking about was in response to what another poster was saying - the men of the internet are going to make the boys into men. Make them follow their rules. Not going for that. Define what is too childish or too out of control for the internet. We'll all have different definitions.
 
See, some things are black and white. It's that grey area where people want to control that I don't like.

Bingo. I've really couldn't care less if nudes are or aren't on Reddit personally. Doesn't matter to me one way or the other.

Now, Reddit can do with Reddit as Reddit damn well pleases. It's their site.

What does worry me, is Reddit deciding that the actual owner of a photo, can not display their own content there, based on who might be in the photo (regardless of 'maturity rating' of said photo). Which this does entail, whether it is their intention or not. Because it's only a matter of time before someone (whether Reddit themselves, or a third party) uses this policy to go against a legitimate case of 'for the greater good of public interest'.

Sex scandal involving a politician or religious official, with photo evidence? Uh-oh - the subject of that photo doesn't want it posted - and according to this policy, is to be immediately taken down. What about someone in a damning photo that is non-sexual, but the subject of the photo claims it is. How are you to know the circumstance of the photo, or what's going through the subject's head? So now you either have to comply, or define sexual, which is another can of worms.

And also it bothers me how Reddit does this while still claiming to be a bastion of free speech. Either stop claiming you are, or actually be one. Take a shit or get off of the toilet.
 
Haha, their political correctness is going to be the death of them. How fitting.
 
Back
Top