Recommended mobo for Gaming?

2marshall8

Gawd
Joined
May 29, 2001
Messages
753
I own a P4X400 Soyo Dragon Lite and have faced memory problems which result in reboots while I play games (particularly bf1942/bfvietnam). I've also had the machine reboot suddenly while doing normal desktop work.

What mobo would you guys recommend for a Pentium 4 that has solid memory handling and is very reliable for gaming? I'm still not sure what the problem is with my machine but I think it might be due to the way RAM is being handled on the mobo. What is you guys' advice in regards to this?

thanks
marshall
 
ABIT/ ASUS/ MSI all have very good general reputations as being reliable and solid, as well as good overclocking boards. I play games regularly on my ABIT IC7/2.8c and have never had any problems...
 
Are you theorizing that your theoretical memory controllers theoretically handle your ram poorly :D? Or have you done the right thing by swapping out different sticks of ram?

Not trying to bust your chops but i don't want to see you swap your mobo to later find out that your ram was to blame ;)

Good luck either way
 
SJetski71 said:
Are you theorizing that your theoretical memory controllers theoretically handle your ram poorly :D? Or have you done the right thing by swapping out different sticks of ram?

Not trying to bust your chops but i don't want to see you swap your mobo to later find out that your ram was to blame ;)

Good luck either way

Good point and I have tried many different combinations and this reboot problem still pleagues me. The machine is most stable when I stay at one stick of 512MB. I have tried mushkin RAM, corsair, and now I'm using 2 two sticks of Kingston. Any time I go above 512MB I get these problems. I've ran the Microsoft Memory tester as well as the Linux x86 memory tester and the RAM tests out fine. My guess is that it is RAM related but it's hard to confirm.

Lately While using Windows XP I get a lot of freezing of programs where I'll have to do an "end task" to get control of my system. I also get a report when my computer reboots, from microsoft, about how the error was caused by a device driver but they don't know which one.

I'm still looking for more advice on a solid motherboard. I'm thinking I should go with an Intel board due to having an Intel Processor.

thanks
marshall
 
well I like open questions like this, as everyone gives there input...

but I think the best reviewed boards right now are like;

AMD:
MSI K8N Neo (nforce3) AMD 64
ASUS A7N8X-E Deluxe (nforce2) AMD XP
DFI LANparty stuffs

Intel:
MSI PT880 Neo-FISR (VIA)
ABiT MAX3 still?

anyways there are others that fit the bill, and also are prolly cheeper stuff, but I think you will find that everyone will say that there board is great and you will still not know what to get...
 
Zardoz said:
well I like open questions like this, as everyone gives there input...

but I think the best reviewed boards right now are like;

AMD:
MSI K8N Neo (nforce3) AMD 64
ASUS A7N8X-E Deluxe (nforce2) AMD XP
DFI LANparty stuffs

Intel:
MSI PT880 Neo-FISR (VIA)
ABiT MAX3 still?

anyways there are others that fit the bill, and also are prolly cheeper stuff, but I think you will find that everyone will say that there board is great and you will still not know what to get...

If we can keep the price around $100 that would be nice ;)
 
Here's what I'm going to choose from, Whatis your recommendation knowing the components I'll be placing on this board:

ASUS P4P800
ASUS P4P800 DELUXE

Gigabyte MB-8IPEPRO
Gigabyte GA-8INXP
Gigabyte GA-8IPE1000PRO

Abit IC7
Abit IS7M
Abit MB-IS7-E

MSI NEO2LS
MSI 865gNEO2LS
MSI PT880NEOLSR

My signature is all I'll be placing on the board.

thanks
marshall
 
2marshall8 said:
Here's what I'm going to choose from, Whatis your recommendation knowing the components I'll be placing on this board:

ASUS P4P800
ASUS P4P800 DELUXE

Gigabyte MB-8IPEPRO
Gigabyte GA-8INXP
Gigabyte GA-8IPE1000PRO

Abit IC7
Abit IS7M
Abit MB-IS7-E

MSI NEO2LS
MSI 865gNEO2LS
MSI PT880NEOLSR

I'd either get the IC7, and stay away from the IS7 unless you want to save cash, the IC7 has the faster 875 chipset.

And either of those ASUS boards would be good as well, I'm not sure about the Gigabyte or MSI boards though. (They'd probably be fine, but i just don't have any experience with them ;) )
 
stumpy said:
I'd either get the IC7, and stay away from the IS7 unless you want to save cash, the IC7 has the faster 875 chipset.

And either of those ASUS boards would be good as well, I'm not sure about the Gigabyte or MSI boards though. (They'd probably be fine, but i just don't have any experience with them ;) )

Concurred
 
so do you see the increase in speed from the IS7 to the IC7? Where is the increase in speed within the chipset, in what area?

thanks
marshall
 
Back
Top