Recommendation for non-conductive coolant

OK. Do you understand english?

As I already said:
all non-conductive coolant become conductive over time

this included Deionized water. The key is their ability to resist becoming conductive over time. Except someone proof me otherwise I believe Deionized water will become conductive pretty soon, which defeat its purpose from the safety perspective. And it is, I believe, where those non-conductive coolant stand out. They can keep their non-conductive properity even after long period of use. See this now if you haven't see it yet.

Learn to read. Stop force-feeding anything to anyone as if they are clueless.
 
As I already said:


this included Deionized water. The key is their ability to resist becoming conductive over time. Except someone proof me otherwise I believe Deionized water will become conductive pretty soon, which defeat its purpose from the safety perspective. And it is, I believe, where those non-conductive coolant stand out. They can keep their non-conductive properity even after long period of use. See this now if you haven't see it yet.

Learn to read. Stop force-feeding anything to anyone as if they are clueless.


For the simple reason of the article I linked to earlier, I would recommend MCT-5 if you feel you need a non-conductive solution. It is the only case I have seen of someone who was using in the real world for some time, then had a major leak and nothing died.
 
As I already said:


this included Deionized water. The key is their ability to resist becoming conductive over time. Except someone proof me otherwise I believe Deionized water will become conductive pretty soon, which defeat its purpose from the safety perspective. And it is, I believe, where those non-conductive coolant stand out. They can keep their non-conductive properity even after long period of use. See this now if you haven't see it yet.

Learn to read. Stop force-feeding anything to anyone as if they are clueless.

You make assumptions about products you don't even own. How can you assume that these solutions retain their non conductive properties over time better than DI water? Fluid XP broke down into particulates in my system within 3 weeks time. One can safely conclude that it stripped ions long before that, reionizing itself. Contact the companies tthemselves and NONE of them will guarantee their products against possible shortage in the case of a leak.

If you spring a leak, there's nothing you can do about the consequences. If you're lucky, you the leak won't occur over a sensitive area and you won't get a short. If you're unlucky, you'll have some new burnt components.

I have owned and used the majority of these products as I was once the clueless person as yourself believing into marketing hype and the notion that "expensive must equal good!!". I've used Fluid Xp, MCT, and PC-Ice. The only thing I haven't used was Koolance's and TT's solutions. After much use, the realization that those products are not only marketed unethically, and corroborating experiences with fellow enthusiasts over various forums, I stopped using them and learned the error in my ways. However, if you prefer to spend that kind of money just so that you can convince yourself you're doing the right thing, by all means sir.
 
All of these "non-conductive coolants" (stuff like Fluorinert not included) are water-based and are more conductive than pure distiller water. Additionally, once you begin adding contaminants to the coolant, it becomes more and more conductive (running it in your loop does this, spilling it on dusty components does this, etc.). There is little point in purchasing these "specialty coolants".

Hell, stuff like MCT-5/MCT-40 is more conductive than a 90% distilled, 10% ethylene glycol mix. :rolleyes:

QFT

There is no such thing as a non-conductive fluid suitable for watercooling at any reasonable price. Proper installation and leak testing is the only viable solution regardless of what you put in your loop. Any decent 10th grade science book will both confirm and enlighten if you wish more details.



(and dont bother posting about the exotic fluids, I said "suitable" and "reasonable priced", same as Petra mentioning Fluorinert )
 
QFT

There is no such thing as a non-conductive fluid suitable for watercooling at any reasonable price. Proper installation and leak testing is the only viable solution regardless of what you put in your loop. Any decent 10th grade science book will both confirm and enlighten if you wish more details.



(and dont bother posting about the exotic fluids, I said "suitable" and "reasonable priced", same as Petra mentioning Fluorinert )

QF fother mucking T

This needs to be beat down into the ignorant people left in this forum.
 
i think this thread has degraded into a complete waste of internet bandwidth, I come asking for pros and cons of non-conductive coolant and people rain down with their 1337 opinions in a typical shock and awe fashion.

It is like asking for advice for purchasing an exotic cars and suddenly you get comments like get a hyrid car instead, you corporate fata@@ with money to burn, global warming, place to go for dinner, my ex-gf is better than yours, etcetc..... typical internet forum.
 
i think this thread has degraded into a complete waste of internet bandwidth, I come asking for pros and cons of non-conductive coolant and people rain down with their 1337 opinions in a typical shock and awe fashion.

It is like asking for advice for purchasing an exotic cars and suddenly you get comments like get a hyrid car instead, you corporate fata@@ with money to burn, global warming, place to go for dinner, my ex-gf is better than yours, etcetc..... typical internet forum.

Unfortunately you are exactly correct. It is unfortunate that people couldn't get past their personal opinions and actually try to give some productive input. In case you missed it amidst the furor or naysayers....I recommended MCT-5 out of the three major solutions. PC ICE would be my last choice because it seems to have the most problems with particulates and dye separation.
 
i think this thread has degraded into a complete waste of internet bandwidth, I come asking for pros and cons of non-conductive coolant and people rain down with their 1337 opinions in a typical shock and awe fashion.

It is like asking for advice for purchasing an exotic cars and suddenly you get comments like get a hyrid car instead, you corporate fata@@ with money to burn, global warming, place to go for dinner, my ex-gf is better than yours, etcetc..... typical internet forum.

You're making absurd comparison. There's no such thing as a non-conductive liquid meant for home use. You're asking for protection against leaks right? The only real protection is to ensure that your system is leak tested. Out of all the non conductive solutions you've mentioned, deionized water is still the least conductive. Do you not want to hear the truth?

I'm at a loss on why you refuse to believe that deionized water is the least conductive liquid you can put inside your loop. Either you're refusing to listen or you're buying into the marketing spins that either of the three (pc-ice, fluid xp, mct) are less conductive than deionized water.
 
QF fother mucking T

quite fucking fother mucking true? its like saying ATM machine- automatic teller machine machine. or NIC card- network interface card card.

This needs to be beat down into the ignorant people left in this forum.
if people want to be ignorant then let them be ignorant. this isnt china, you cant force people to think one way or another.

You make assumptions about products you don't even own. How can you assume that these solutions retain their non conductive properties over time better than DI water?
how can you assume the opposite? have you done any tests or do you have anything to prove this one way or the other?

Deionized water is the LEAST conductive fluid you can obtain commercially.
Fluid XP is not the best. Nothing is better than Distilled Water in terms of cooling power. PERIOD.
both these statements are not true.

If you're worried about leaks, you should be doing a full blown 24 hour stress test in the first place WITHOUT ANY COMPONENTS INSTALLED/POWERED. To do otherwise is being foolish and stupid.
There is NO reason to have leaks develop in the future after this stress test at all unless you're moving components around and introducing torque on your blocks or new bends
there is plenty of reason to worry about leaks, as fatty said his leak happened after he had done a 24hour test. if you ever transport your computer to a LAN or just move it around leaks can easily develop. who has time to do a several hour leak test at the begining of each LAN party? i sure dont. also plastic can form cracks over time as there is constant pressure on water blocks. this isnt very common but it can happen. ive read that madshrimps review before and had similar experiences when i tried out PC Ice. it saved my motherboard when i had a leak around one of the barbs on my CPU block. theres no way of telling if it would have survived had it been regular water, but to some people its worth the $25 for the peace of mind of safeguarding $1200 worth of electronics, regardless of how well it does or does not work.
 
ive seen QFT used to mean lots of things, including quit f*** trolling. sooo i dunno. disregard that part then. :p
 
I've got a small point to make which I'll probably be slapped silly for. I'm a chemistry grad and I can tell you that distilled would be a better choice than deionized water. i say this because deionized water is an unstable form. Water prefers to have ions dissolved in it, so when you deionize it the water is out of equilibrium. Any chemist will tell you that a solution that is out of equilibrium will do what ever it has to in order to regain equil'm. In the case of a cooling system what's gonna happen is the water is going to eat away at the metals in order to replace its ions.
 
I had a small fissure in my chipset waterblock. A small amount of the fluid dripped on one of my 7900 gtx located right under it. The fluid found its way to the pci-e slot and that was the end of it. I heard a sizzling noise, followed by a spark and a plume of smoke. Had to replace the motherboard and the video card. Cost me 1000$. Contacted Danger Den and sent them pictures but they never replied.

I still use the stuff though. After replacing the faulty block and leak testing for another 8 hours, everything was fine. I'll be switching to the Zalman coolant. It'a cheaper and easier to get where I am.
 
Back
Top