recommendation for low-power server platform?

venm11

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
2,236
I'm unhappy with the power consumption of my home server (http/smb/nfs/dnla/vnc/vmware/bt/proxy) and would like to replace it with something much more efficient and just run it 24x7. I've tried complicated WOL schemes and various other tricks, but it's too difficult to insure that everything works together reliably.

I know there are some Atom-based solutions that would work well, but I'd prefer something with components that are interchangeable with what I already have, so that means ATX, AM2/3, DDR2/3, Sata, Ide, Raid, Linux, PCI/PCIe, etc. The trouble is that unlike CPUs, motherboards do not commonly have power consumption ratings that would enable me to compare efficiencies. I'd like to get a system that idles at 20w or so, and stays under 60w when fully active. RAID is not essential at this point.

Can you guys make some recommendations for chipset, motherboard, platform, etc? Or my approach to all of this. I've already exhausted WOL, power management, 80plus psus., laptop cpus, laptop drives, single-stick memory, passive heatsinks. I've discounted storage-enabled routers, NAS units, ITX systems, proprietary tech, etc. I'm ok with linux and dd-wrt, possibly windows. Cost is an issue, especially since I have so many PCs that can do the job as "servers".
 
Last edited:
yes. well, as opposed to what?

i'm measuring systems with a kill-a-watt. my laptops typically draw 30w at idle, and desktops about 60w.
 
I don't think it's possible. If a laptop draws more than 30W you're going to be hard pressed to get desktop components to run an entire system at under 20W.
 
We're talking about the same "chips" in laptops and desktops, just different speeds, voltages and power management schemes. I see no reason you can't get lower than a laptop, especially considering that DYI motherboards will give you more control than a laptop will. The question is probably which chipsets/cpus/etc are the most efficient. Actually, I have desktops that consume around the same as laptops, but they're proprietary and not suitable for my purposes.
 
Well, I think you still spend a lot of money chasing your goal and will still come up short. My u-ITX Atom 330 / Ion system draws ~25W idle in CentOS (doing literally nothing). I think you'd be better served trying to reduce your electric bill elsewhere and accepting a higher power draw from your 24/7 server. Or, spend the money to go uITX with an Atom / Via / etc based system which can probably get into the low 20's idle if you're careful about component choices.
 
I have a dell P4 desktop that consumes 27w at idle. If I had control over the various speeds/voltages and more modern hardware i could get well under that.
 
Motherboard idle power does seem to vary a lot even between boards of the same chipset, in general higher end chipsets will draw more but this seems to be dwarfed by other motherboard differences.

One thing you do have to think about when doing this sort of thing is cost effectiveness. 1W of continuous power consumption is equivilent to 8.6 KWh per year. According to Average price of electricity in the USA is about 12 cents per KWh making the cost of using 1W continuously about a dollar a year. At that rate spending money on knocking down an idle power consuption from say 60W to say 20W can take a very long time to give a return.

Another big problem is devices like the kill-a-watt are notoriously inaccurate at these levels so it's actually quite difficult to measure whether you are winning or losing.

Anyway what is your current server rig and what is it's power consumption? and what are you using to measure said consumption?
 
This project isn't just about maximizing savings (40w ~ $5/mo), although that's a factor, esp in the summer. And I may want a few of these if it's low enough.. But mainly it's simply because it shouldn't be that hard to do with the right information - if you can find it. Specs, reviews, sticky green computing guides?

I've identified a few cheapish ~22w AMD cpus, LP drives, etc, but I have no idea what these mobos will do, like you say. Are there better brands in this regard, specific component types in powering the cpu, like digital vrms, etc?

As far as the kill-a-watt, I've not noticed the measurements to be inconsistent or out of line with component specs, at least for anything I've measured in this range. Seems like people have issues with it at much higher wattage, which seems like an expected behavior for something like this.
 
Back
Top