• Some users have recently had their accounts hijacked. It seems that the now defunct EVGA forums might have compromised your password there and seems many are using the same PW here. We would suggest you UPDATE YOUR PASSWORD and TURN ON 2FA for your account here to further secure it. None of the compromised accounts had 2FA turned on.
    Once you have enabled 2FA, your account will be updated soon to show a badge, letting other members know that you use 2FA to protect your account. This should be beneficial for everyone that uses FSFT.

Recomend me a RAID controller

D

djBon2112

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jul 29, 2006
Messages
5,279
Sorry, I know this topic has been done to death, but I need some solid answers.

6-8 SATA ports, PCIe interface, hardware* RAID 5. Recommend anything please.

*Unless a Celeron 420 is enough to reasonably do software RAID 5 on a 6-8 disk array streaming a bunchload of content (HD video, music, etc.) over gigabit ethernet, while running BitTorrent downloading/uploading on the server. In which case, I'm open to software RAID 5 solutions too.
 
Anything by Areca I swear by their cards. Although be ready to spend upwards of $400 on one of those.
 
Everyone swears by Areca, and I have one on the way, I also have a Highpoint 3510 on the way as well. The Highpoint uses the same intel IOP chips as Areca, so it should be good. The 3510 only has 4 connectors though. The Areca 1220 has connections for 8 SATA drives and can be found for around $450.
 
for the price you are paying for a single controller i find it better to just build a seperate PC that could work as a storage box + router + maybe even HTPC
 
I own a ARECA 1210. Works great. Some other names are LSI, 3ware.
 
risqu3 said:
for the price you are paying for a single controller i find it better to just build a seperate PC that could work as a storage box + router + maybe even HTPC
Click to expand...

That's what I'm doing... only it'll be a 4+ disk RAID5 array of 750 GB drives. And I need a RAID controller of some kind for that.
 
if your building a new box then get a board with a good onboard chipset
 
I've been looking at the Dell PERC 5/i. They can be had on eBay for about $120, minus the cables. Any opinions on them?
 
Dont get a dell card if you dont have a dell that comes with it, you will get stuck with proprietary drivers that wont get updated after they quit using that model system. bad idea.
like i said in my first post Areca is #1 in my book, followed by LSI, and 3ware. I had a dell card in my dell and I didnt like how it acted with certain OS's so i got a Areca that all i have to say about that.
 
That's a little disheartening. Any recommendations for software controllers with 6-8 ports? Oh, and for the record I'm going to be running Ubuntu Server on the box.
 
Those Dell PERC 5/i are just rebadged LSI cards. I was able to flash my PERC 5/i with LSI's bios. Now I can use 512MB ram on the controller (came with 256MB - and Dell's BIOS didn't allow for anything more) and use LSI's drivers. No issues so far for me :)

nitrobass24 said:
Dont get a dell card if you dont have a dell that comes with it, you will get stuck with proprietary drivers that wont get updated after they quit using that model system. bad idea.
like i said in my first post Areca is #1 in my book, followed by LSI, and 3ware. I had a dell card in my dell and I didnt like how it acted with certain OS's so i got a Areca that all i have to say about that.
Click to expand...
 
vannguyen0 said:
Those Dell PERC 5/i are just rebadged LSI cards. I was able to flash my PERC 5/i with LSI's bios. Now I can use 512MB ram on the controller (came with 256MB - and Dell's BIOS didn't allow for anything more) and use LSI's drivers. No issues so far for me :)
Click to expand...

Got a guide/thread on how to do that ;) my Perc5/i from ebay should be here Thursday, already got my SFF-8484 cables from Provantage (~$25 shipped for both cables)
 
vannguyen0 said:
Those Dell PERC 5/i are just rebadged LSI cards. I was able to flash my PERC 5/i with LSI's bios. Now I can use 512MB ram on the controller (came with 256MB - and Dell's BIOS didn't allow for anything more) and use LSI's drivers. No issues so far for me :)
Click to expand...

Sweet! If that's the case, I'm set with a Perc 5/i since I see them for about $120! You have a link to the flashing tutorial?
 
djBon2112 said:
Sweet! If that's the case, I'm set with a Perc 5/i since I see them for about $120! You have a link to the flashing tutorial?
Click to expand...

If it's the one that has a "best offer" they have it set to auto-accept at $100, but they denied my offer for $95...

They don't have brackets for your PCI slots, so you'll have to buy one off ebay (another $10 from another seller, find your own, or use a vented PCI Slot and Zipties (What I plan to do :D )
 
Blazestorm said:
If it's the one that has a "best offer" they have it set to auto-accept at $100, but they denied my offer for $95...

They don't have brackets for your PCI slots, so you'll have to buy one off ebay (another $10 from another seller, find your own, or use a vented PCI Slot and Zipties (What I plan to do :D )
Click to expand...

I've got one seller who does the bracket in a combo with the card for about $130 USD, plus I think $25 shipping to Canada which isn't that bad. But I still need cables for it. Better than $500 though ;)
 
Why not go for the Perc6 controllers then, i heard they were a huge improvement over the 5 series. Although you're probably not going to max them out so that shouldn't really matter.
 
I haven't seen any on eBay for cheap :p

But yea, I doubt I'll be maxing this thing out. Hell, the only reason I want a dedicated hardware one is so I can use the cheapest CPU I can find and not take a performance hit ;)
 
djBon2112 said:
Sweet! If that's the case, I'm set with a Perc 5/i since I see them for about $120! You have a link to the flashing tutorial?
Click to expand...

Blazestorm said:
Got a guide/thread on how to do that ;) my Perc5/i from ebay should be here Thursday, already got my SFF-8484 cables from Provantage (~$25 shipped for both cables)
Click to expand...

Here's the thread:
readme if you are bored (12 pages)

It's about 12 pages of people moaning and complaining (myself included) about how the PERC 5/i is a pos because some of us couldn't get it work on Intel chipsets. Then I went to a 780i board and everything has been smooth since.

But then there's a work around if you have an Intel chipset (which kinda irks me that I didn't find it earlier; because I based my decision to go with the 780i on the fact the the PERC 5/i would not work with any Intel board). Read this link if you have an Intel chipset (P35, X38, X48)

readme if you have Intel chipset

Basically... you can re-flash the using LSI's 8408E firmware.
LSI link

Blazestorm said:
They don't have brackets for your PCI slots, so you'll have to buy one off ebay (another $10 from another seller, find your own, or use a vented PCI Slot and Zipties (What I plan to do :D )
Click to expand...

That's what I'm doing... I have a Rocketfish case and it has vented PCI slots ;)
 
Glad I found this thread and avoided some headaches, I bought a 965 board off ebay to go with it D= I really had no idea there was going to be any issues, but I didn't really do a whole lot of research either...

I'll read up on the thread and figure out what I need to do, thanks a lot :D
 
vannguyen0 said:
Here's the thread:
readme if you are bored (12 pages)

It's about 12 pages of people moaning and complaining (myself included) about how the PERC 5/i is a pos because some of us couldn't get it work on Intel chipsets. Then I went to a 780i board and everything has been smooth since.

But then there's a work around if you have an Intel chipset (which kinda irks me that I didn't find it earlier; because I based my decision to go with the 780i on the fact the the PERC 5/i would not work with any Intel board). Read this link if you have an Intel chipset (P35, X38, X48)

readme if you have Intel chipset

Basically... you can re-flash the using LSI's 8408E firmware.
LSI link



That's what I'm doing... I have a Rocketfish case and it has vented PCI slots ;)
Click to expand...
Looks good; since the mobo I'm getting is a G33 chipset (no other mATX mobos I've seen with 2x PCIe 16x slots for the riser I need [this card and an Intel dual gigabit Ethernet card]) I assume I'm going to need that mod ;) I like the nail polish idea, assuming that that is safe :p

As for the flashing, is there a way to reverse it if it goes awry? I've always been a little skeptical flashing BIOSes for different models etc., and I always like a fallback!
 
djBon2112 said:
As for the flashing, is there a way to reverse it if it goes awry? I've always been a little skeptical flashing BIOSes for different models etc., and I always like a fallback!
Click to expand...

yup... no problems reverting back to the Dell bios. You just have to do it with the NOCHECK (I forget the exact parameter) - basically tell the flash program to ignore the version number of the BIOS (the program will halt if it sees that you are trying to go back a version unless you specify the NOCHECK parameter).
 
I got my Perc5 today, my motherboard read it fine and booted fine... cables seem to work.

It says it finds 0 logical disks, but shows 4 drives under options once i dig deeper, I try to create a virtual disk but it just won't let me move over to OK even though it;s niot greyed out.

How did you flash to the LSI firmware, I'm thinking I should try that... do you boot from the flash program? I've been searching all around, can't find any clear answers for anything.
 
Good luck with the perc5 man, we have a couple at work and i personally don't like them very much at all. Maybe i should see if we should reflash them...
 
Figured it out...

I guess going into the OS and installing drivers and the MegaRAID software would have helped ;)

Flashed to LSI and have been building the Raid5 array ever since... 77% after a couple hours...

Didn't have to do the tape "mod" or anything, natively detected on my 945 Gigabyte board, it was bitching about a missing battery, but I might end up buying a BBU anyways, they're pretty cheap on ebay and I already got the cable.

Cables from Provantage work and even include an LED header for a backplane (which I don't have), although another website listed on cpu2 (I think) had them for $12 shipped and had locking cables (Provantage cables are Sata1 style, but feel secure))
 
Blazestorm said:
Figured it out...

Cables from Provantage work and even include an LED header for a backplane (which I don't have), although another website listed on cpu2 (I think) had them for $12 shipped and had locking cables (Provantage cables are Sata1 style, but feel secure))
Click to expand...

Glad to see that you got it working Blazestorm. Can you provide a link to those locking cables when you get a chance?
 
Sorry to resurrect this thread guys, just got a Perc 5/i from ebay and mine has what looks like a 4 pin power connector just below the heatsink,
Do i need to connect to this from my power supply? or is for the battery or something else.
 
It's not for power ;)

I think it might be to connect multiple cards together, but I could be wrong.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top