Recertified motherboard?

ArbY

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 6, 2007
Messages
390
I just received an EVGA "Recertified" board and it just simply does not work.

In light of this, I am interested to know more about the "Recertified" label. My assumption was that the product had been returned to the manufacturer and had either been fixed or deemed working through an exacting sequence of tests. In my case, if the guy at the warehouse had merely plugged the darn thing in, I'd never have received the defective item.

Obviously there are plenty of cases where people receive defective products that are sold as new, but am I correct in assuming that recertified boards probably receive more attention than the ones rolling out of the factory?

Not that I'm royally pissed at either EVGA or Newegg, I'm more interested to know how loose or tight these guidelines for recertification are with computer products (namely motherboards). Anyone have experience buying "Recertified" or have more knowledge on the subject?
 
There have been a couple times that i've seen some recertified deals that seem too good to be true but i still steered clear. Unless it's a local shop where it's not a huge hassle to return it I just buy new since it gives me warm fuzzy feelings.
 
I would have always assumed recert meant it was tested and verified as working and not a DOA or the like at the retailer level...disappointing almost to hear otherwise. good luck though....
 
I'm the same as Stick, They usually are tested working.

Are you sure other components are good?
 
The BIOS POST codes that would stick were either 25 or 08.
25 referred to video BIOS shadow and 08 referred to a keyboard test.

25 might suggest either a faulty graphics card or the same of a PCI-E slot. Tried a 6870 and an 8800GT in both the primary and secondary PCI-E slots. Didn't change a thing.

Keyboard test. Well, nothing's wrong with my keyboard. Tried all the USB ports, and made sure only the keyboard was plugged in at the time.

Just for the hell of it, I phoned EVGA support and after I had told them what I had tried they simply asked me to unplug the 24-pin power connector from the mobo, remove the battery and wait 10 minutes. Of course that didn't fix a thing. Now I have no idea if every motherboard is tested before it is packaged and sent off to be sold, but I know recertified boards are at least understood to be. Not sure what happened in my case. Probably will avoid the recertified label in the future now though.
 
Re-certified and Refurbished sometimes means different things to different people.

As a computer and computer parts retailer, to my understanding the general consensus in the industry is the following

Refurbished: Item is defective and repaired (although not necessarily by manufacturer-often 3rd party does this). Generally a bit more used than recerts.

Recertified: Item is sent back to factory. . . OR. . . never leaves the factory (doesn't pass testing or recalled component) and repaired. Items are generally tested prior to re-release.

However, just like new items, a lot can happen after that test. Item has to be packaged, handled, shipped and received by dealer. Improper handling can de-magnetize components or jog something loose--not to mention moisture, etc. Unfortunately, it is not logistically practical for a dealer to test every item when they receive it, especially someone turning over a lot of inventory.

Its unfortunate that you got a bad board. From our experience, re certified items can be very good.. . It is not uncommon for us to receive re-certified items that appear to be new (notebooks with original keyboard covers and unopened software)

I don't believe that we have seen a difference in defects between new and re-certified items, as in our case we handle both (including motherboards.) I think it all depends on who you are purchasing from. Some dealers list refubs as re-certified items. I am not sure if they do so to be deceiving or that they don't realize that there is a noticeable difference. New, refurb, or recert, though, sometimes you just get a lemon :mad:
 
Recertified/Refurb is fine, depending on warranty. I've seem some with only 30 day warranties, which is scary.

However, EVGA throws in 90 days which seems good enough to me. I think a solid state part like that will likely break soon or not at all. So 90 days seems like long enough to get peace of mind.
 
That's odd since as you said recertifications usually get more attention. Also as said sometime you just get a lemon.
 
Back
Top