Reccommend a Graphics Card based on Needs/Specs

Chris.

Gawd
Joined
Aug 26, 2006
Messages
804
Ok basically, I'm about to hop into this Windows Media Center PC hype. Purchased a PC, will only be using it for media like HDTV & using the Tivo function with my TV. Will also be playing Xbox 360 on it, and perhaps watching HD-DVD/Blu Ray movies on the PC. Will also be web browsing & typing up papers, but not as often as i'll be doing everything else.

Coupled with that i'll be picking up a 2007WFP from Costco early next week.

What I wanna know is, what kinda graphics card would you suggest in my position? Mind you, I don't PC game, at all.

Specs are as follows:

Intel® Pentium® D Processor 820 with Intel® Hyper-Threading Technology (2.80GHz, 2MB L2 Cache)

Operating System
Microsoft® Windows® XP Media Center Edition 2005 with Update Rollup 2

Front Side Bus Speed
800MHz

Chipset
Intel® 945G

Memory
1GB PC-4200 533MHz DDR2
(Expandable to 2.0GB)

Hard Drive3
250GB 7200rpm Serial ATA Hard Drive RAID Ready

One x1 PCI Express (free)
One x16 PCI Express (free)
Two PCI (One free slot)
 
If you won't be playing games, then the integrated graphics will be adequate.
 
stealthy123 said:
good lord those cards are overkill.

price/performance winners. why spend nearly as much on an x1300 or something?
 
Tutelary said:
price/performance winners. why spend nearly as much on an x1300 or something?


half the price isn't close to nearly as much, and he doesnt need the performance as he doesn't game at all
 
stealthy123 said:
half the price isn't close to nearly as much, and he doesnt need the performance as he doesn't game at all

I'm not going to saddle anyone with absolute crap when fine cards exist which will take care of everything they want to do for just slightly more. sure you can spend half, and get what, a 6200? Hes going to need to run 1650x1080, and might want to throw vista on in the future. In the end its his choice. I don't see you recommending anything worthwhile.
 
Tutelary said:
I'm not going to saddle anyone with absolute crap when fine cards exist which will take care of everything they want to do for just slightly more. sure you can spend half, and get what, a 6200? Hes going to need to run 1650x1080, and might want to throw vista on in the future. In the end its his choice. I don't see you recommending anything worthwhile.

I linked a card that is head and shoulders better for his needs than what you guys recommended.


lol @ saddling with a crap card
 
stealthy123 said:
I linked a card that is head and shoulders better for his needs than what you guys recommended.


lol @ saddling with a crap card


Like I said, his choice, but youve got 2 recommendations for the 7600gs vs yours. :D
 
Tutelary said:
Like I said, his choice, but youve got 2 recommendations for the 7600gs vs yours. :D


you're right you win

hopefully the OP will look at both choices and read a review or two regarding the video quality and temperatures of both cards and make an edjucated decision.
 
stealthy123 said:
you're right you win

hopefully the OP will look at both choices and read a review or two regarding the video quality and temperatures of both cards and make an edjucated decision.

Sorry to be a grammar nazi, but the whole "edjucated" thing, lolol. Irony is such a bitch. :D
 
Tutelary said:
Sorry to be a grammar nazi, but the whole "edjucated" thing, lolol. Irony is such a bitch. :D


take a look at your keyboard

whats that right below the "u"

accidently key presses aren't the same thing but thanks for playing
 
stealthy123 said:
accidently key presses aren't the same thing but thanks for playing

Haha. You are REALLY cracking me up now, just stop. :D
(But let me know when your video comes out, with an act like that you must be a riot).
 
Telling the OP to get a 7600GT if he doesn't game is like telling your grandmother to get a Core 2 chip for surfing the net and checking e-mail. Not only is it overkill, but the benefits of that choice over the much cheaper alternatives are inconsequential to the situation. He doesn't want to game, so chances are whatever integrated graphics came with the PC will be enough. Should he decide to upgrade to VIsta, even an X1300 would be more than enough. The only benefit for an HTPC would be AVIVO or Aero if he upgrades, but aside from that there's absolutely no reason for anything more powerful than integrated graphics since there simply isn't a need for it.
 
Yeah I do intend on running it at 1650x1080, upgrading to Vista (Heard November if you've already got XP), and might be hooking it up to an HDTV (32" Samsung) for HD-DVD at some point in time around Spring/Summer next year.

But right now my main concern is being able to properly utilize a widescreen monitor.
 
only reason I recommend an add on card is for the various display choices it will allow
and for video playback an add on card will give a better overall experience.
 
Really, I'd keep the on board video but i've heard there's a lot of trouble with widescreen monitors.

So I figured i'd bite the bullet & just buy a nice video card that would Suit my needs.
 
onboard video always gives me video noise if there such a thing, the display on the screen just never looks right to my eyes and annoys the hell out of me. and I don't run widescreen.
 
Zero82z said:
Telling the OP to get a 7600GT if he doesn't game is like telling your grandmother to get a Core 2 chip for surfing the net and checking e-mail. Not only is it overkill, but the benefits of that choice over the much cheaper alternatives are inconsequential to the situation. He doesn't want to game, so chances are whatever integrated graphics came with the PC will be enough. Should he decide to upgrade to VIsta, even an X1300 would be more than enough. The only benefit for an HTPC would be AVIVO or Aero if he upgrades, but aside from that there's absolutely no reason for anything more powerful than integrated graphics since there simply isn't a need for it.

Its not a 7600gt, its a 7600gs. If he intends to run vista, which he has already stated to do, he would need a 256meg card to run aero glass at that resolution anyway. Lets face it, its just part of the experience.
 
Tutelary said:
Its not a 7600gt, its a 7600gs. If he intends to run vista, which he has already stated to do, he would need a 256meg card to run aero glass at that resolution anyway. Lets face it, its just part of the experience.

no he wouldn't
turbo cache and hyper memory make it so

you might should stop giving out advice

and with that, I bid the OP good luck and walk away
 
stealthy123 said:
no he wouldn't
turbo cache and hyper memory make it so

you might should stop giving out advice

and with that, I bid the OP good luck and walk away

Because sucking up system memory with a shitty card is acceptable, right? I must have gotten lost and stumbled into the [W]eak forum somewhere along the way.
 
At this moment, i'm going to add another gig of ram bringing it up to 2GB for sure.

Now i've gotta decide on a video card.

Jotted down a few from this topic so far, trying to find one that's cooled, as well as I don't want to add an extra fan inside the case.
 
I linked the Asus card because he said he wanted to run HD DVD/BluRay and it is the only budget card that currently supports Microsoft's DMCA implementation and Nvidia has the edge in Video Quality over ATI. ATI has the IQ edge in games but that isn't what the OP wanted the card for so do a lil research yourself stealthy123.
 
Chris. said:
At this moment, i'm going to add another gig of ram bringing it up to 2GB for sure.

Now i've gotta decide on a video card.

Jotted down a few from this topic so far, trying to find one that's cooled, as well as I don't want to add an extra fan inside the case.

passively cooled cards don't generally need fans on them, thats why they are passively cooled. The plus there is they are silent and perfect for HTPC use. even still the tiny fans that they throw on vidcards tend to be quite loud much louder than a large case fan would ever be.
 
chris.putertech said:
I linked the Asus card because he said he wanted to run HD DVD/BluRay and it is the only budget card that currently supports Microsoft's DMCA implementation and Nvidia has the edge in Video Quality over ATI. ATI has the IQ edge in games but that isn't what the OP wanted the card for so do a lil research yourself stealthy123.


the difference in video quality is well subjective, I actually prefer the look of video on ati cards the colors are richer and more vibrant to my eyes.
 
stealthy123 said:
the difference in video quality is well subjective, I actually prefer the look of video on ati cards the colors are richer and more vibrant to my eyes.
Actually, stealthy, his post was not made to compare IQ, his post was made to state that the card to *best* suit the OP's needs would be the HDCP - DMCA thingy card.
 
BlackTigers91 said:
Actually, stealthy, his post was not made to compare IQ, his post was made to state that the card to *best* suit the OP's needs would be the HDCP - DMCA thingy card.

considering the controversy surrounding the plan, and that entire countries have stated that they won't follow intel's plan I wouldn't feel comfortable at all debating hdcp-dmca because I can't see where the tech is going

in his post he said nvidia has better video quality than ati which is something i am comfortable debating
 
stealthy123 said:
in his post he said nvidia has better video quality than ati which is something i am comfortable debating
According to the latest test of video quality, NVIDIA did win out over ATI (by 5 points, it was like 118 to 123). Realize though, that this is only with the latest series of cards.

As for default color vibrance, it really doesn't matter. Any videophile is going to go in and tweak that.

As for that, the minimum NVIDIA card with all supported video features is the 7600GT - http://www.nvidia.com/page/purevideo_support.html
 
i wasn't refering to Intels plans for implementing Copy Protection I was refering to what Microsoft has already implemented in Windows Vista the Asus 7600 is the least expensive card that is fully "Built for Vista" the next card in the lineup that fully meets Microsofts copyprotection in HD/DVD&BluRay is the newer 7900's since the OP says he's not a gamer then those are definately overkill.
 
Blu-ray/HD-dvd will need a good video card to run them i dont think a 50 dollar x1300 is gonna be to basic for the job. I know that the blu-ray stand alone players are 2.5ghz P4 with 1 gig of PC-2700 and decoder chips to run ...on a PC you would have to increase those stats a healthy amount .. probably a 3.2ghz P4 atleast and 2 gigs of system ram. Not to mention a beefy video card ..for right now you mighrt wanna hold off till Vista is out and the requirements to run blu-ray on a PC are known not to mention a Software decoder released for the PC that will decode blu-ray movies .
 
Godmachine said:
Blu-ray/HD-dvd will need a good video card to run them i dont think a 50 dollar x1300 is gonna be to basic for the job. I know that the blu-ray stand alone players are 2.5ghz P4 with 1 gig of PC-2700 and decoder chips to run ...on a PC you would have to increase those stats a healthy amount .. probably a 3.2ghz P4 atleast and 2 gigs of system ram. Not to mention a beefy video card ..for right now you mighrt wanna hold off till Vista is out and the requirements to run blu-ray on a PC are known not to mention a Software decoder released for the PC that will decode blu-ray movies .

Well i'm running a 2.8ghz pentium D, and have 2 GB of RAM already.

Plus i'm waaaay more interested in HD-DVD, than I am Blu Ray. I Just threw that in as it's included in HD Movies and I might bite the bullet on Blu Ray later next year (Summer-Fall ish).
 
Chris. said:
Well i'm running a 2.8ghz pentium D, and have 2 GB of RAM already.

Plus i'm waaaay more interested in HD-DVD, than I am Blu Ray. I Just threw that in as it's included in HD Movies and I might bite the bullet on Blu Ray later next year (Summer-Fall ish).

Worry about it next year, then. You'll probably need an HDCP-protected video card to play HD-DVD - they're pretty rare now.
 
Until HD-DVD and Blu-Ray actually come out for PCs, there's no way to know exactly what hardware or software will be needed to make use of the new formats. Basically, buy something that suits your current needs, and worry about what you'll need to use the HD formats once you know for sure exactly what you will need.
 
Back
Top