Re: AMD Bulldozer Criticism

It just means that AMD outgrew those designers comfort level and now AMD has to learn to live without them.
No, it means that AMD dropped out from being competitive in design, possibly not by deliberate choice if Maier's history is accurate. The switch in design methodology is clearly different from when Sanders was CEO, and arguably much worse.

There have in fact been many high profile designers who have left both AMD and ATI since the purchase. And the results are what you see now: it takes 2 cores to match 1 from the competition, with insanely slow development of a new CPU architecture (although credit is given for Bobcat... that only took 40 months, a tick-tock-tick-t worth of development time, from announcement to product release :p).

That's certainly another challenge the next CEO will have to overcome: attracting new talent to get the processor business back on track.
 
Last edited:
?? I'm pretty sure the ARM licensee like Samsung, Qualcom, NVIDIA have acccess to capacities far in excess of what Intel has.I believe Apple buys significantly more silicon than Intel produces in the form of SOCs and memory.Intel is only the tip of the iceberg in the supply equation.
Not in terms of fabrication ability, when it comes to SOC's Intel has everything already in place except production of a chip as power freindly for its performance as an ARM chip.
AMD ? Who is AMD ? Compare AMD with Samsung or Qualcomm. The later 2 would love to be the "foundation of the digital world". ARM moved up the ladder in 2 years from non-existant to a real threat to Intel's position. THe new QC chips in the pipeline will touch Intel's low end and threaten the bulk of the sales. And ARM's growth is exponential.??
They are a threat to Intel and AMD's dominance in the world of general use microprocessor production. They are not a competitor for any high level use applications. What arm has managed to do is produce a CPU competitive with a GHz Pentium MMX that doesn't use a whole lot of power, they are and will be for the foreseeable future be a poor substitute for general and performance computing. ARM can't and their target isn't to produce a truly desktop replacement CPU. Its fantastic their accomplishments with the mobile computing world and lines will be blurred in the future, but none of them are ready, and none of them own the licenses that allow them to make a CPU from scratch if the need arises. Additionally they suffer the same problem as the Android platform a whole does, thats diversification. Great for Android, but even if their growth is fine, none of these companies outside Samsung can support a CPU business that has grown as much as it has if they are too late to the party or if a truly superior option is available (from Intel or anyone else).

PII was introduced in mid 1997 with 233MHz. Two years later we had PIII Katmai with 600MHz. By mid 2000 ( your 3 year horizon ) we had 1GHz PIIIs. That's a 4x increase in performance. Your premise is simply wrong.
I should avoid using actual numbers without double checking the source. You are correct. But there is measurable difference in Intel's launch strategy and available options when there is competition. Also pricing. We haven't had a pricing war in a while, but mainly because when AMD does lower its price Intel releases a cheaper separate product. My premise is wrong because I was trying to make the wrong point. Even with the K6, with the K6-2 and it eating the fairly expensive PII's underline cost, Intel did something they never did before and that was off a truly low priced CPU the the Celeron, after it flopped they released a second one that became the basis for their Coppermine CPU. IF you can't see the difference between their release schedule with and without AMD competition then I am not sure where to go from here.

And AMD has a back up IA64 design in the works at the time. Who would have thought ?
They can't Intel designed IA64 specifically so that it wouldn't be covered in AMD's cross license agreement. AMD has no patents and Intel has yet to License IA64 to any other Microprocessor manufacturer.
Regardless of this, you fail to grasp my argument. Intel needs to innovate so people replace PCs. If Intel slows the release schedule to once a year 5% faster and 50% more expensive people would not replace their PCs. How hard is this to grasp ?
They don't have to innovate to get people to replace Machines. Generally a machine running the same tasks year after year with the same OS, its precieved as slow (or bogged down so badly) that people replaced their machines after 3 years. That still happens to this day. Much like a car, they will be replaced as they fall apart hardware or Software wise and that will drive sales. Not the new CPU that is 4 times faster.
Intel needs Nehalem to rock so millions of perfectly fine C2Ds PCs are discarded. SB/IB has to out do Nehalem so millions of Nehalem based systems get replaced.
How else can Intel dream of shipping 1 million CPUs per day ?? Do you think they'll sell many $500 per piece CPUs in Bangladesh or Zimbabwe ?
I don't want to make CPU performance unimportant. It helps sales and in a monopoly no change will get them in trouble very quickly. But as competition goes down so does selection. There is no impetuous on Intel to add variance within a market. So sure they may have a $150 dollar option, but will it be an SB, or an SB as we know it now. You can drive replacement value on a faster CPU, by not making them so fast in the first place. That $150 dollar CPU in the future can still be upgraded with a CPU that's twice as fast 3 years later, but still not having it be as fast as it could be. Think of a world where AMD didn't push Intel to re-release the Celeron with the Celeron-A. A world where its cheap and just fast enough, and sure it upgraded but its still no where near as fast as its could be, maybe well behind the performance CPU. It won't be something that happens right away would be gradual We already know because it has happened before.

Intel doesn't have competition above $300 and there are exactly 3 products in that space. Otteline can say prayers all night but the market would not move to the segment irrespective of AMD. People who can afford a $400 PC and replace it every 3 years would pay the same with or without AMD. And if Intel positions itself above that segment, others would be more than happy to jump in. Just ask Samsung, NVIDIA, Qualcom, etc...
They can't, they can't compete. Maybe just maybe with Windows 8, but my understanding is that Windows 8 for ARM will not be compatible with Windows 8 for PC. There is a market for post $300 CPU's, its not large. But the impact on Intel above that market is small so the selection is miniscule. It was only 4 years ago when at the height of both their performances there were dozens between the two of them.
That's BS and your whole argument starts from a false premise. If the new offers do not offer compeling upgrade reasons the 3 years will suddenly become 5. Look around you, the whole world is spinning around accelerated innovation. Each new generation of products floods you with new features just so that you upgrade sooner.
Who said it has to be compelling. People are stupid. People are irrational. I have a friend that is pretty damn intelligent, does some light gaming, bought two different $1.4k laptops in a year because the system fan bearing went bad in one of them rather then get it fixed. That's a guy who isn't rich but has some disposable money. When your talking about a $400 desktop acting up and its like $120 to have Best Buy even look at it, they will buy a new one and Best buy will be more then happy to help them buy it.

Yes and Intel would sell so many of those, enough to fill 1/4 of one of their 5 production FABs. A true ROI masterpiece.

ROI investment isn't spending billions in R&D, New FAB production, New processes. All the while deviating heavily on production options and variations. New processes will go on, new CPU's will get built, but that couple hundred mill they lose by building 6-7 variations when binning would suffice would go a way. Want to know what would make it easier for them to sell a new system, have the $150 CPU (or cheaper) be just fast enough that no ARM system (if they could truly run the same platform) could compete with it but slow enough that the $400 CPU is actually enough faster to make it worth the money.

Its not immediate but its been seen before in this market and dozens of others. Its not about what happens the second it happens but the affects on the market 5-10-15 years out with another free market option.
 
I can't believe how many people are suggesting that the lack of AMD wouldn't be horrible for the consumer. Sure, Intel would still be limited by the market somewhat, there's only so much people will pay for a CPU. Sure, they'd still have sub $150 CPUs, since the market demands it. Would they be the quality of the i3 2100 though? Hell no. It'd be Pentium type quality. What we paid for what we got would be worse than it is today.

People seem to use Sandy Bridge being priced low despite AMD not really competing as evidence of Intel pricing fairly without competition. In reality, Intel priced Sandy Bridge so low (the 2500k and 2100 both were priced right into the heart of AMD's lineup at the time) to put a major squeeze on AMD and I'm sure it's worked. Given the current prices and performances, I honestly can't recommend anybody buy an AMD processor over the $100 price point, Intel wins across the board. You don't think that wasn't Intel's plan all along? AMD went from being the easy choice in the 100-200 area, to suddenly hardly being a choice at all.

I'm not saying Intel is evil. It's a business. AMD would do the same thing without competition. The market limits the extent to which you can take advantage of it and you do have to keep innovating to give people reasons to upgrade, but without the push of somebody competing against you, there's no reason to go the extra mile.
 
I can't believe how many people are suggesting that the lack of AMD wouldn't be horrible for the consumer. Sure, Intel would still be limited by the market somewhat, there's only so much people will pay for a CPU. Sure, they'd still have sub $150 CPUs, since the market demands it. Would they be the quality of the i3 2100 though? Hell no. It'd be Pentium type quality. What we paid for what we got would be worse than it is today.
There's a kink in the logic you are (reasonably) using. Prices are not unbounded, and there is historical data from when Intel had no real competition in mainstream and faster parts. Neither suggests that competition caused Intel to halve prices of processors, although clearly competition does keep prices lower.

There is a price point of systems that demands a (very large volume priced) $25 processor, $50 processor, $75 processor, etc on both desktops and mobiles. That won't change, even if AMD stops making CPUs. The market may bear price premiums above current nearly historical low prices and it's part of business in any market to take advantage of that. Read AMD's FTC complaint for the very argument that AMD wanted to make processors more expensive so it could become profitable. The low prices were/are killing it, while not affecting Intel much at all.

And thank you for not suggesting that "a celeron will cost $500" or the other nonsense some people spew which is a market impossibility.
 
There is no doubt that IntEl would cut R&D drastically if they have a chance. If they were the only player in the market, investors would slaughter them for uneeded CapEx when they could line their pockets much thicker if IntEl just recycled their old products that are already on the market. Just llike they continue to sell 5 year old processors now, their entire lineup would be filled with old and outdated products if there were no competition to push innovation. Thankfully, IntEl won't be allowed to take that route because AMD is going nowhere but higher in marketshare and revenue. Those that bought into these IntEl shills' FUD and propaganda aren't going to be pleased.
 
There is no doubt that IntEl would cut R&D drastically if they have a chance. If they were the only player in the market, investors would slaughter them for uneeded CapEx when they could line their pockets much thicker if IntEl just recycled their old products that are already on the market. Just llike they continue to sell 5 year old processors now, their entire lineup would be filled with old and outdated products if there were no competition to push innovation. Thankfully, IntEl won't be allowed to take that route because AMD is going nowhere but higher in marketshare and revenue. Those that bought into these IntEl shills' FUD and propaganda aren't going to be pleased.
Why the hell do you keep capitalizing the "E" in Intel? It's obvious you are doing it deliberately. No one gives a shit about whatever message you are trying to send and it looks just as dumb as writing M$.
 
Why the hell do you keep capitalizing the "E" in Intel? It's obvious you are doing it deliberately. No one gives a shit about whatever message you are trying to send and it looks just as dumb as writing M$.

I was thinking that as well. I wonder if he'll let us in on his little joke. :rolleyes:
 
I figured it was because the name Intel came from Integrated Electronics. IntEl.

Yeah it's just an abbreviation of Integrated Electronics, not sure why those 2 are having a fit about it. IntEl seems more appropriate.

Back on topic, I don't think people should be judging Zambezi performance by the rumoured pricing. Remember that A64 was pounding Pee4 for less money also. ;)
 
There's a kink in the logic you are (reasonably) using. Prices are not unbounded, and there is historical data from when Intel had no real competition in mainstream and faster parts. Neither suggests that competition caused Intel to halve prices of processors, although clearly competition does keep prices lower.

There is a price point of systems that demands a (very large volume priced) $25 processor, $50 processor, $75 processor, etc on both desktops and mobiles. That won't change, even if AMD stops making CPUs. The market may bear price premiums above current nearly historical low prices and it's part of business in any market to take advantage of that. Read AMD's FTC complaint for the very argument that AMD wanted to make processors more expensive so it could become profitable. The low prices were/are killing it, while not affecting Intel much at all.

And thank you for not suggesting that "a celeron will cost $500" or the other nonsense some people spew which is a market impossibility.

Yeah, a lot of people are going overboard on what would happen with no AMD. Still, I was surprised some people seem to also think it'd be no big deal. While they'd still sell processor at all price points, I'd expect to get much less quality for the price. I mean, just think about how good of a processor the i3 2100 really is for the 120 bucks it costs. It's quite absurd really. I just don't see that type of a bargain existing with no competition.
 
IntEl seems more appropriate.


/smartass suit on

main-logo.png


Every "Intel" word on "Intel's" site is labeled as "Intel" including their logo.

:p
 
Yeah, a lot of people are going overboard on what would happen with no AMD. Still, I was surprised some people seem to also think it'd be no big deal. While they'd still sell processor at all price points, I'd expect to get much less quality for the price. I mean, just think about how good of a processor the i3 2100 really is for the 120 bucks it costs. It's quite absurd really. I just don't see that type of a bargain existing with no competition.

Better yet, would they even have bothered with making the i3 2100 ?
 
Umm, in a 'free market' we wouldn't have had a second x86 chipmaker, unless you wanted to commoditize x86.
Not true, unless intel kept their prices super low and their quality super high. Even then, they wouldn't have 100% of the industry for more than 2 years.

Under the current market conditions, a collapsing AMD would be allowed to be sold and still keep their license..
Under a free market AMD would be allowed to be sold if that's what you're getting at.
I don't think that there is anyone willing to take the risk of investing 10s of billions in capital on a gamble of whether or not they can compete with Intel in their own market.
It may not take 10s of billions. And the 10s of billions certainly wouldn't be a gamble if intel started raising prices and/or reducing quality. No company is naturally invincible. Whenever a company starts making mistakes, then new competition comes along.
 
They can't Intel designed IA64 specifically so that it wouldn't be covered in AMD's cross license agreement. AMD has no patents and Intel has yet to License IA64 to any other Microprocessor manufacturer.

Actually, HP can fab the Itaniums royalty-free.
 
No company is naturally invincible. Whenever a company starts making mistakes, then new competition comes along.

Standard oil, Bell... every time there's been a nonregulated monopoly the government has had to step in even if that company as you put it starts making mistakes. Monopolies are bad and markets with a high barrier to entry rarely compete if they don't have to.
 
It may not take 10s of billions. And the 10s of billions certainly wouldn't be a gamble if intel started raising prices and/or reducing quality. No company is naturally invincible. Whenever a company starts making mistakes, then new competition comes along.

A company can become virtually invincible if they legislate themselves into business and can engage in predatory pricing. The barriers to enter the processor market are tremendous. The only reason that AMD remains competitive is because they have won lawsuits allowing them access to the x86 instruction set. Intel tried to use legislation to quash that. Look at Cyrix, Nexgen, et al. Without AMD progress would slow and Intel would go back to resting on its laurels and charging top dollar for everything it manufactures.
 
Not true, unless intel kept their prices super low and their quality super high. Even then, they wouldn't have 100% of the industry for more than 2 years.


Under a free market AMD would be allowed to be sold if that's what you're getting at.

It may not take 10s of billions. And the 10s of billions certainly wouldn't be a gamble if intel started raising prices and/or reducing quality. No company is naturally invincible. Whenever a company starts making mistakes, then new competition comes along.

Basically, in a truly free market we would have OTHER (non-x86) architectures competing with x86, since Intel created it, which means it would be theirs to determine who they license to and how. Which would be similar to what we have now, without the FTC investigations.
 
"Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men."

or

"Unlimited power is apt to corrupt the minds of those who possess it"
 
I figured it was because the name Intel came from Integrated Electronics. IntEl.

/smartass suit on

main-logo.png


Every "Intel" word on "Intel's" site is labeled as "Intel" including their logo.

:p

Intel doesn't spell their own name in any of their text or logos as "IntEl." I do not know why FlippinWaffles keeps capitalizing the "E". It doesn't make sense. That's like always typing AMD as "AmD" repeatedly. Why?
 
Actually, HP can fab the Itaniums royalty-free.

Licensed the Architecture, not the production of the CPU. HP wants to make sure that Intel doesn't roll back production after having HP shut down PA-Risc. HP doesn't have licenses to create and market their own product, only right to manufacturer CPU's Intel has designed for use in their own systems.
 
Intel doesn't spell their own name in any of their text or logos as "IntEl." I do not know why FlippinWaffles keeps capitalizing the "E". It doesn't make sense. That's like always typing AMD as "AmD" repeatedly. Why?

Intₑl rocks man.
 
Intel doesn't spell their own name in any of their text or logos as "IntEl." I do not know why FlippinWaffles keeps capitalizing the "E". It doesn't make sense. That's like always typing AMD as "AmD" repeatedly. Why?


Makes perfect sense:

AMD is an acronym for Advanced Micro Devices.

IntEl is an acronym for Integrated Electronics.
 
Makes perfect sense:

AMD is an acronym for Advanced Micro Devices.

IntEl is an acronym for Integrated Electronics.

Intel no longer really stands for anything. It is a name in and of itself. They changed the name of the company to just be Intel after they bought the rights to the name. It's kinda like how the SAT doesn't actually stand for anything anymore
 
intel
Intel iNtel inTel intEl inteL
INtel InTel IntEl InteL iNTel iNtEl iNteL inTEl inTeL intEL
INTel INtEl INteL InTEl InTeL IntEL iNTEl iNTeL iNtEL inTEL
INTEl INTeL INtEL InTEL iNTEL
INTEL
 
intel
Intel iNtel inTel intEl inteL
INtel InTel IntEl InteL iNTel iNtEl iNteL inTEl inTeL intEL
INTel INtEl INteL InTEl InTeL IntEL iNTEl iNTeL iNtEL inTEL
INTEl INTeL INtEL InTEL iNTEL
INTEL

yo dawg I heard you liked permutations.
 
Makes perfect sense:
Maybe over 40 years ago. :p The name has been "Intel" since, even with the dropped (lowercase) e back then.

zDSWj.jpg


Wow, did the first (commercial*) single chip microprocessor have humble beginnings. ;)

And since this is the AMD forum and ancient history is the topic... "[AMD] began as a producer of logic chips, then entered the RAM chip business in 1975. That same year, it introduced a reverse-engineered clone of the Intel 8080 microprocessor. " :p

* the US military designed and built the first single chip microprocessor used in fighter jets, but it was classified for many years.
 
the US military designed and built the first single chip microprocessor used in fighter jets, but it was classified for many years.

An excellent example of government waste having unintentional positive benefits on society.
 
Standard oil, Bell... every time there's been a nonregulated monopoly the government has had to step in even if that company as you put it starts making mistakes. Monopolies are bad and markets with a high barrier to entry rarely compete if they don't have to.
Standard Oil had less than 75% of the market they were in by the time they were broken up by the DoJ. They had been losing market share each of the 10 years prior to when they were trust busted. See DT Armentano.

As for Bell, they were a government created monopoly.

A company can become virtually invincible if they legislate themselves into business and can engage in predatory pricing. The barriers to enter the processor market are tremendous. The only reason that AMD remains competitive is because they have won lawsuits allowing them access to the x86 instruction set. Intel tried to use legislation to quash that. Look at Cyrix, Nexgen, et al. Without AMD progress would slow and Intel would go back to resting on its laurels and charging top dollar for everything it manufactures.
That's if they legislate themselves into business. Only natural monopolies aren't possible.

Basically, in a truly free market we would have OTHER (non-x86) architectures competing with x86, since Intel created it, which means it would be theirs to determine who they license to and how. Which would be similar to what we have now, without the FTC investigations.
In a truly free market, there would be no IP, and thus a newcomer could copy intel's designs, pay their executives less, not have to pay as much for R&D, and sell the product for less. Intel would have to rely on being first to the market without patents, because their products could be just reverse-engineered in an IP-free world. They would have to spend money to engineer their products so that they're not copyable.
 
I honestly have been using intel for a while now. But there are a lot of people that still buy AMD, since I work retail I know. AMD fusion chips are a hit and I have a lot of people everyday asking about those. A8 series chips are going to be a blast with more then enough horsepower to run graphics. I think that is one field where intel hasn't spent too much time at.

Even if bulldozer is not the biggest hit or doesn't beat or match sandybridge, AMD's priority right now seems to be the integrated market. They will probably end up taking over all in one tablets. In the long run buying out ATI might have saved AMD.

Their design on fusion chips and the upcoming tablet chips is going to cost intel alot to be honest.

They still dont have IGP that can compete or even come close to AMD's. I think that in the long run, may be in 4-5 years we might be talking about how and when AMD turned corner.

If I was to build a computer for my dad, my nephew, even my brother are not gamers or dont know the difference between intel or amd, I would probably get the A8 chip and get the new board and build each one of them a system with it.

Just think about it when you build a system for one of your family members, do you always go for gaming? probably not. You go for what is the best for them, i3 is good, i5 is good, but can they beat the integrated graphics of the A8 chip? probably not. I would sacrifice a little processing power that will go un-noticed over a decent integrated graphics core of radeon.

I will probably go sandybridge for myself while I will build like 2-3 computers based on amd fusion chips that will more than satisfy my loved ones.

I can finally see AMD vision that I never thought would come true when they were struggling financially. It is nice to see fusion finally coming together.
 
Intel doesn't spell their own name in any of their text or logos as "IntEl." I do not know why FlippinWaffles keeps capitalizing the "E". It doesn't make sense. That's like always typing AMD as "AmD" repeatedly. Why?

at least he doesn't use "i" as a prefix to every noun like an Apple fanboy i know
 
Just think about it when you build a system for one of your family members, do you always go for gaming? probably not. You go for what is the best for them, i3 is good, i5 is good, but can they beat the integrated graphics of the A8 chip? probably not. I would sacrifice a little processing power that will go un-noticed over a decent integrated graphics core of radeon.

I will probably go sandybridge for myself while I will build like 2-3 computers based on amd fusion chips that will more than satisfy my loved ones.

I can finally see AMD vision that I never thought would come true when they were struggling financially. It is nice to see fusion finally coming together.

hmmm I havnt price compared but I would bet atm the A8 chip and a appropriate mb would be more expensive then a comparable intel chip/mb and decent graphics card ...
 
Back
Top